Proof Bakery

Go here! Go here!!!! GO HERE!!!! Saw this place while doing my research. My plan was to hit it on my first day in Nags Head and grab a bunch of stuff for me and my relatives stay in Rodanthe. But I called an audible and hit it on morning we were leaving. HUGE MISTAKE. This place is utterly fantastic. The owner is obviously a talented baker by the first glance in the display case. Doughnuts, fresh baked bread, chicken schnitzel, hamburgers, twice fried real frenchy fries. Local told me to get the sausage (made in house), egg and cheeseon a challah bun (baked in-house). If I lived within 50 miles I would eat this every day. I'm a biscuit guy but this is by far the greatest breakfast sandwich I've ever had. I also got a buffalo chicken stuffed pretzel and a Boston cream doughnut. Both awesome. My travel partners got chicken schnitzel tenders and a homemade dipping sauce. He raved how good they were. My other relative had an apple pastry that was as beautiful as it was tasty from the taste she gave me. No inside seating but do have a really nice outdoor seating area. Lady waiting on us was so helpful and she loved her job and knew the product and made excellent recommends.

Easy In and out. No line. VERY reasonably priced. A real "Nags Head insider hack". We found this place by accident. It's like a German Bakery. The food is divine. The Schnitzel Sandwich is unbelievable. The "Stuffed Pretzels" are incredible......they taste EXACTLY like in a Bakery in Germany

Tuesday morning a friend called me and said she was stopping at Proof Bakery and if I wanted anything. I said if the have plain (no filling) beignets I would like 2, but if not to get me 2 doughnuts. She said all the beignets they had included some type of filling, so I got 2 doughnuts which were delicious. The best part of this story is that the girl who was helping my friend asked when she would see me again, my friend responded on Thursday. The girl who works at Proof (sorry, I didn’t get a name) said, no problem I know what he wants, he wants Louisiana style, come back Thursday morning and I will make some for him. Well, I had them this morning and I’m not kidding when I say they were even better than Cafe du Monde in New Orleans. She went above and beyond by making me a special order on pretty short notice. The kind of customer service that I really appreciate and is sadly not that common these days. I will be ordering again very soon. And to the girl who made them for me, THANK YOU so much. I would love to come in and meet you, but that may be a while, I had my left leg amputated below the knee a few months ago and it’s still fairly difficult to get out of the house. The girl that picked up the pastries this morning is my nurse who helps me out around the house a few days a week.

If you have a craving for Donuts or Danishes, this place is a must! All items are baked in the shop freshly. Although there's not a dining area, most customers get take outs. Besides the baked goods, breakfast sandwiches are also available. You may want to try out their Creme Brulee donut. We have not seen this made elsewhere. We can confirm that it is as good as it sounds.

This place is dangerous! I came in hungry and wanted to eat everything!! Settled on the Caribbean jerk sandwich, dang tasty!!!! That Bavarian cream-filled donut was stupendous.. I was so happy to finally visit this place. Can't wait to get back.

Proof Bakery is a great donut, pastry, and sandwich shop in the Outer Banks. Everything is made fresh every morning. The donuts were the best I’ve ever had and the service was wonderful. Do come early because there is a line!

Excellent pastries! Have a sweet craving? Then you have to stop here. Everything was made fresh and reasonably priced. I was more than impressed with the flavor of my honey bun & dulcet de Leche donut.

We visited this place for the first time admittedly when we tried to go to our favorite coffee house and the line was out the door. We arrived at Proof where the line was TO the door, but at least it involved the AC! It was a fortunate discovery because this place is delicious and will remain in our rotation. There were so many delicious sweet and savory pastries it was hard to choose! They offered coffee but I spotted glass bottle sodas and opted for that. The line took about 10 minutes from walking in to ordering, and once we ordered, the wait was practically negligible. So don't be discouraged by a long line. We'll be back!