Provincetown Fudge Factory

These guys had me at “the world’s best peanut butter cups”. We saw the sign and had to go in and try them out. I’m not sure if they truly are the world’s best. But they are very good. We got 5 different kinds to sample and we got some fudge. I thought the price was fair and the treats were delicious. Stop in and get a peanut butter cup. You won’t regret it.

We received Provincetown Fudge from my daughter as a gift. The chocolate with walnuts was delicious. I'll have to try the other flavors if my wife doesn't eat the rest.

A Delightful Fudge Experience! We stumbled upon a wonderful fudge shop nearby, and it turned out to be a highlight of our day! As I waited outside with my miniature dog, one of the friendly employees warmly invited me in, saying, "Please come in, we are dog friendly." This welcoming gesture made all the difference. Inside, I was delighted to find an array of delicious fudge options. We bought several flavors, including pumpkin, peppermint, salted caramel, coconut, cranberry, and walnuts. Each one was rich, creamy, and absolutely delightful! The atmosphere was inviting, and the staff's friendliness made our experience even better. I can’t wait to return and buy even more flavors. Highly recommend this gem for anyone with a sweet tooth!

We wandered in right before closing & the service was friendly & patient! Took home a few different types of fudge & turtles that were all yummy. Will be goimg back for more. Even ordered a gift delivery on-line & saw they offer a military & veteran's discount which is awesome & appreciated!

Excellent fudge, coconut cluster and peanut butter cups

You must try the peanut butter cups! I stopped in to pick up some for my hubby and ended up loving these cups myself. I got some peanut butter and peanut butter Oreo and then some s’mores,,, the chocolate is sweet but not too sweet or bitter and it’s easy to bite into.. The peanut butter is so creamy and again, sweet but has that sharp peanut taste. Just soooo good..and these are some chunky pb cups.. We are going to order some online; love that we can get it online!! Also, staff was so friendly and this place was well kept and clean. If anyone tries the caramel let me know if it’s soft to chew? Take care all. 7/2022 just got the peanut butter cups some salted caramels and Oreo peanut butter bark, all milk chocolate. Absolutely delicious!!!!

Have been both an in person & online customer.Truly the best fudge shop on the cape.High quality ingredients,delicious fudge & specialty products.They are responsive to questions & answer in a timely way.I’m definitely a big fan of their penuche!

Super nice place for candy and other sweets. Peanut butter cups are out of this world. Nice to know they can be shipped! ❤️

Such a cute little Store. Friendly service, and very clean. I recommend the s'mores bark.

Do not order from Provincetown Fudge Factory!!!! I made multiple orders for extended family members. Only half were even acknowledged and received tracking numbers (even though all were charged to my credit card!!!). There is no way to contact a human on their website and emails to their customer service site went unanswered.

Really loved the peanut butter cups, and the Oreo Chocolate Peanut Butter bark! Great place to get something sweet!

I love this store. As I walked in, the smell of fudge and chocolate, just wrapped my senses right away...it was just a really excellent sensory experience...a nice fresh smell. I decided to get some white chocolate almond bark, which was just delicious and very very sweet...that's why it's good to eat small portions at a time. They have ice cream, fudge, chocolate, truffles, chocolate turtles, salt water taffy, gourmet popcorn, etc...just a great stop for a sweet tooth shopper.

If you have "World's Best Peanut Butter Cup" on your sign, of course I'm going to check that out. They're not lying, the peanut butter cups are great. Service is friendly and knowledgeable. Definitely a place to drop by while you're in P-town!

I love the peanut butter cups here! They have such a good variety and they are all delicious. Also, the people who work here are just lovely. In the past I've had some of their fudge (also good) as well as ice cream (that's good too). But for me, nothing compares to their peanut butter cups, especially any of them with dark chocolate. They also have a great selection of tasty truffles as well. The only knock that I could consider is that the treats aren't cheap but then again, you're getting exceptional hand crafted candies that are so much better than the chocolate you can by at the checkout in the grocery store. Plus, they have such a wide variety, no matter what your preference, they will have something you like. This place is always five stars in my book.

Maple walnut fudge was good. That was about it. Chocolate covered pretzels were stale so we tossed them. The turtles with almonds and those with pecans were terrible and hockey puck size. Utterly tasteless. The nuts werent roasted and the caramel tasted like glue, it had no vanilla flavor or even a hint of caramel. Chocolate had no taste at all so Ill assume they're selling stale candy. For $50 I can make better at home! I wouldnt return here.

I LOVE it here! I ordered a square of the caramel fudge and it was delicious. I also love their large selection of candy. They have gummy candy for those who are allergic to dairy. The fudge was filling and could have been enough for two desserts. This place is amazing and I love how delicious all of the chocolate and fudge are. I look forward to my next visit because I would love to try the other flavors of fudge. The strawberry looked fun. It was the only fudge with gummies on top, and it was pink. I love this store.

Amazing selection of Fudge , very cute packaging and reasonable prices ! The place smells amazing when u walk in . This place was a recommendation from a caregiver at the airbnb in town we rented for our anniversary ! This place was definitely a treat and we will be back !

While we rarely eat fudge, we always buy it when traveling to certain places and Provincetown is one of those places. Two weeks ago my husband and I had a day trip to this final stop at the very tip of Cape Cod. We enjoy going to Provincetown once a year, usually after the summer crowds have dissipated. After lunch, we popped into this hopping place and spent a few minutes deciding amongst many delicious sounding flavors. We settled on the maple walnut which did not disappoint. The fudge was creamy, decadent, sweet but thankfully not cloyingly so. You can buy the fudge by the ounce and it is wrapped in waxed paper, served in a box and plastic cutting knives are available. The shop has additional sweets other than fudge like peanut butter cups, chocolate turtles, candy and apparently ice cream (although given my laser focus on the fudge, I missed that. While the store was busy, we were served in fairly short order and were in and out within minutes with our treat. If it is something sweet you want while you stroll the streets of fun Provincetown, this is a great option.

If you're visiting PTOWN, you have to stop here and get some fudge or delicious candies. I love their barks, turtles and the bar with oreos and peanut butter. Overall, everything here is incredible. One of my favorite small businesses to support every time I'm in town!

Great spot! The guys that worked there were so nice and helpful! Known for the peanut butter cups- we thought they were good/very messy/melty consistency but good quality chocolate. I liked the Oreo/PB cup best! Also tried a pecan turtle- it was pretty large and also delish. I loved the variety of options - this spot absolutely prob had best selection! Would absolutely recommend!

Giving them a 4 only because of the lazy employees that work at this place. 5 for the fudge and yummy treats and 2.5 for Service. Manager/owners need to observe how unfriendly the tall guy with the black hair is .

This is the most delicious fudge ever in the whole wide world ever ever. They advertise the best peanut butter cup in the world, but definitely try their fudge!!!

Peanut butter cup & turtle were exceptional. Truffles were so-so. Very friendly & fast service.

Delicious fudge, long lines but fast service! Will definitely be back, as always. Chocolate and maple walnut are the best.

They had a bunch of options to choose from whether it was fudge, chocolates, or peanut butter cups. We went with the 2/$4 peanut butter cups - one dark chocolate M&M and one Oreo cup. The M&M one was good but could've had more M&Ms in it. I don't like milk chocolate but the Oreo one was better in my opinion, and oddly less sweet.

Peanut butter cup heaven! The white chocolate was better...though it's all about preference. Dark chocolate was great too! Very fresh made.

Got the rocky road fudge and a truffle. The fudge was really good but the truffles were too bitter. Overall, the fudge is worth trying.

Cool spot for some yummy treats. Their fudge is definitely the best thing to get. I ordered the rocky road fudge and it was so delicious. I also ordered the dark chocolate peanut butter cup and dark chocolate truffle and they were just ok. The cups were stuffed with a lot of peanut butter, which made it a little overwhelming.

While walking the main strip, what caught my attention for this place was the sign that said world famous peanut butter cups. I love peanut butter cups. Its my favorite snack. Nothing is better than mixing chocolate and peanut butter together. Everything this place offered looked great. I bought 2 peanut butter cups to try them out. A dark chocolate one with m&ms in it and a creamy white chocolate one (2 for $4.00). They were both super delicious. Definitely amazing peanut butter cups. So, their sign is legit and stands up to my taste. This place also offered lots of fudge options and taffy inside as well. Didn't try anything else, but all looked good. A nice little shop for a quick snack, while in the area.

Excellent fresh fudge at reasonable prices. Never had I had a bad piece of fudge . DELICIOUS !

I was in P-Town during the off-season, and so I certainly can't speak to the usual foot traffic, etc. What I can speak to is the quality of the fudge and the kindness of the employees here. The staff at this fudge shop were so sweet and accommodating when I came in. I was the only person in the store, and I was buying a good bit of fudge. The man who took my order, whose name I sadly didn't catch, was so sweet and helped me choose the best treats for my family. He let me sample some of the fudge as he beautifully packaged my order, and even threw in a free piece at the end. I will definitely be making this a regular stop on my visits!

Ice cream: Sea salt Caramel Truffle. I dare you! 1 cup is not enough for the 3 of us. It's salty ish with a touch of the burn sugar undertone. Must try!!! Dark chocolate Peanut Butter Cup. OhEmGee... i have never tried anything better than this. Sorry no picture. We ate them all

This is a dangerous place if you are on a diet - fortunately I was NOT. Great peanut butter cups, smores, etc - but....BUT.....Oreo fudge - - Oreo F'n Fudge!! I mean, life is too short to pass on Oreo fudge.

Just attempted to support local and shop here for a sweet treat after dinner. Checked the store's site as well as Google to confirm hours, which seemed to be until 7pm on a Saturday. We got to the shop at 6:45pm to see a "we're closed" sign. Decided to clarify with the woman at the counter and she reported the shop "is closed now." We then attempted to ask, for future reference, "when does the shop close?" to which she rudely replied just "Now!" Sadly, they lost some treat-loving customers, who will also encourage friends against supporting such a rude place of business. Sad to see on a busy, lively and joyful day in Provincetown after the election confirmation! This is a time for love, not hate.

Considering the word Fudge is in their name, you'd think they'd slack on their ice cream. But, lemme say, their ice cream is divine. I had a mocha/coffee/mocha chip something - i can't remember the name - and it was stellar. Also, big points for their staff. Everyone there is friendly and helpful, even when someone strolls in 5 minutes before closing (someone who shall remain nameless fine it was me okay stop it right now how dare you). And their fudge is scrumptious too. Had a piece of their dark chocolate coconut fudge. It was like a meal. Go, indulge, enjoy!

Fudge is amazing! We drove an extra 1.5 hours further onto the Cape just for the fudge. Selection is amazing! Well worth the trip to Ptown!

Ohh, this place is dangerously delicious. I walked in to the store after reading reviews ... and impatiently waited behind a couple. Glad I was behind them however ... because it gave me a chance to chat them up. They were regular Cape visitors that were buying gifts for their children back home (the one thing that their children ask them to bring back). They gave me the low down on their favorites ... and added some penuche to their purchase after I shared my love of it with them. From the reviews - I had to try their walnut penuche. After grabbing and going with a quick quarter pound ... I too was SOLD on how yummy and fresh their fudge is. I'll be back.

Great fudge shop. The fudge was really good and the staff was super friendly but they advertised their peanut butter cups as world famous. World famous?! It tasted no different from a Reese's peanut butter cup. How is this world famous?! If I ask 100 people around the world about their favorite peanut butter cup, I bet no one would mention Provincetown's fudge shop's peanut butter cups. Granted, they're fine but certainly not world famous. However, the fudge, oh the fudge, that was pretty damn good!

AMAZING selections for a smaller store! They have wonderful choices and all are DELICIOUS and fresh too!! The store is very clean, well stocked, wonderful selection and the staff is ALWAYS pleaseant!! Stop in and support them!

A sweet curly-haired guy who works here recommended these m&m peanut butter cups to me and they're to die for!

In town with my family and I suggested a fudge tasting later on; I wanted fudge from Cabot's, one of my Aunts wanted it from PFudge Factory. We went to both and then compared each later on: Taste: Cabot's won; PFF was not creamy Aesthetics: two of the three flavors from PFF looked like it was a pile of manure Service: the woman working around 1pm on Sunday September 11th could not have looked any more bored with her job. Cabot's won, and their prices are better.

We came here for the deal we saw on Yelp. Great chocolate but they could not hide how unhappy they were about showing up with a Yelp deal. Oh and we paid regular price...

Amazing sweets, we tried pb cups and turtles. So amazing. Just a little sad that this place is so far away from home...but maybe that is a good thing ha ha!

Tried a few fudge flavors and they were good, but not good enough to make me want more. Ended up buying the peanut butter cups. I got all three (white, milk, dark chocolate) with crunchy peanut butter, because for me, it's crunchy or nothing. :D Surprisingly, the white chocolate peanut butter cup was not as sweet as the dark chocolate, which I liked. The dark chocolate was way too sweet, kind of defeats the purpose of dark chocolate, no? Milk chocolate was still the best. Pick that if you only want one.

I wanted to give a most sincere shout out to fudge factory! They hooked up the American Horror Story Season 10 crew while we were in town and the only sad part was that we ordered for our last day instead of every day prior! Ed helped my co worker put together a large order of assorted fudge, toffee and white and dark chocolate peanut butter cups. When I walked around set with your goodies they disappeared in minutes and then I had more people coming back for seconds Thank you Nicole and hubby Rob (fudge Chef Extraordinaire ‍) for running the cutest most decadent shop in Provincetown I can't wait to return.

Biggest and best chocolate turtles anywhere! Great fudge; they're usually open later than most stores on Commercial Street, so it's a great place to hit after dinner.

Delicious as always, try the peanut butter cups. Their fudge is delicious, as well, and they have a couple interesting flavors!

We got a half pound of peanut butter fudge, and a half pound of chocolate peanut butter fudge-- both SO good!! We will be back for sure!

Homemade Peanut Butter Cups? Check (although the peanut butter was a little too creamy/loose). Fudge in Many Inspired Flavors? Check Friendly boys behind the counter that will allow you to taste? Check. I got the Irish Cream Fudge (and a couple of peanut butter cups) - DEE - LICIOUS! Plus, they packed it for me.

Wow, so up to this day the only "fudge" I have eaten was from little Debbie and I thought it was awesome because it had m&ms on them. My eyes have been opened, my taste-buds awakened, and my sugar levels have been risen!! Fudge is amazing and they have so many different flavors. We had to try them all, literally the give you samplers of each one to ensure you get the one you want, and fudge is not cheap, but it's soooo good!. I really liked their snickers and Oreo mixed fudge. The also had many other flavors worth tasting and eating. Both the Oreo and snickers had big chunks of these chocolate snacks. They also have a chocolate chip swirl fudge that was pretty amazing. This fudge is smooth, soft and nothing compared to those fudge candies bought in a box for less than $2. Sorry Debbie, don't think I can turn back now. :) Definitely recommend this place for fudge. It has been open for over 30 years for a reason! May they stay open for many many more years!

Great staff, super expensive We enjoyed what we got. Similar experience to my past experiences with places like this, the chocolate isn't super sweet and I don't like it that much. Tastes chemically. We got Peanut butter cups: milk chocolate crunchy and dark chocolate smooth, Milk chocolate Oreo peanut butter, Milk chocolate caramel pretzel

Stopped on a whim while craving something chocolate for later. I picked up a Bailey's Irish cream truffle, and orange and chocolate truffle, and a s'mores cup and traditional peanut butter cup. Let me tell you, THESE ARE AMAZING! I'll definitely be going back to pick up some more before heading back to Indiana!

Visited this jolly establishment this past weekend and left with happy tummy's. The peanut butter cups coming highly recommended so we (being the chocolate-loving fatso's that we are) purchased 10. Yep. 10. But wait for it - we also bought fudge - the oreo and the raspberry. It's now 4 days later as I write this review and guess how much of that is left? None. Needless to say - this place is very tasty and legit. You should buy some stuff there - and mail me any leftovers.

Other places in town say they are the best but they aren't. The Fudge Factory is the real deal! Super fresh ingredients and very flavorful. One fudge place we went to shorted us on what we asked for. Not good and that place had mediocre fudge. Totally bland. When in P-town hit up The Fudge Factory, you will not disappointed.

Gold selection of candy and (obviously) fudge. However I always make a bee line for the 'pic-n-mix' or maybe known locally as 'penny candy'. The maltesers chocolates were especially nice. Friendly service too.

Good customer service.Great Frozen hard chocolate almond Yought! Thought I was eating rich ice cream! The Chocolate covered peanut butter cup-first time having one it was amazing! Sampling the fudge was fun! Will definitely buy the Deal!

Meh. We got 3 different kinds of fudge: bailey's, rocky road and regular chocolate. We tried the bailey's first. Taste was alright, but texture was weird. Kind of dry and crumbly. We thought maybe it was just that kind, but we found the same texture issues with all 3 kinds of fudge we bought. The taste was fine, but all 3 types were weirdly crumbly and dry. I don't know if I just got 3 not so fresh types, but the place was hopping so I can't imagine much sits for too long. Lots of money for not great fudge. We did get a couple of peanut butter cups and they were amazing. I'd say, if you find yourself in here try the peanut butter cups and get your fudge elsewhere.