Jason M.
Yelp
I've passed Pubstreet many times when in Pleasantville; I'm a frequent flyer to the area as I attend Jacob Burns Film Center regularly. Despite this, I have never been here for a meal. I was planning to catch a movie with my brother and since we were both looking for some food beforehand, he suggested we go here - so off we went.
Pubstreet is located in the main commercial hub of Pleasantville - parking can be a challenge during peak times, but you have many options including the train station lot and several municipals. We were there on a Saturday night around 6pm - we waited about 15 minutes for a table but all things considered it wasn't bad at all. The dining room isn't large, but there were a good amount of tables as well as a small bar area. Color scheme was mostly greys - nothing too noteworthy IMO, but simple in a good way.
We started with drinks - I got their pear cocktail which was very tasty. The food menu was mostly American, with a selection of starters, pastas, sandwiches, mains, and sides. I decided to start with the French Onion soup; I enjoyed this - the broth was flavorful without being overly salty, and there was just the right amount of cheese and bread. For my main I got the fish sandwich. Again, this was very good - the fish was battered well and topped with a tasty slaw. It was kinda messy and fell apart as I was eating which was a little bit of a turnoff, but overall the flavors worked well; bonus points for using a sesame seed bun.
Service was good, the restaurant was well-staffed and there was a good flow to everything. Overall, I had a good experience at Pubstreet - the food was quality and this is definitely a solid choice when looking for places to eat in Pleasantville; I would have no qualms returning for another meal.