Jessi C.
Yelp
This is a mixed review. I happened to be in OTR all day Saturday, so I came here once in the afternoon to hang out on the patio, then came BACK again that night around 11:30pm with a large group. If I was writing my review just off of the afternoon, it would have been 5 stars hands down. But based on my experience at night, that would have been 3 stars...So I'll stick with 4 stars.
The atmosphere is amazing, very casual on the patio and indoors it feels like someone's living room off to the side but there's also industrial areas with tables for smaller groups. Big TV's to watch football or baseball. This is the largest outdoor patio I've seen in OTR, so if you have a large group, this is a great option!
The afternoon experience: We came here to hang out on the outdoor patio and enjoy what little bit of sunshine we could before it starts getting cold. They let us bring our dog onto the patio and brought out a bowl of water for him. The service was great, they kept track of our tab and let us order food from the food truck. Beer selection is amazing, probably 20+ beers on tap, plus just as many in bottles or cans. Very small wine list, and no cocktail list (WHAT?? Get a cocktail list ASAP!). If you're with beer drinkers, this is definitely a good option.
The Saturday night experience: The crowd was decidedly younger (lower 20's), and definitely rowdier. It took us over 20 minutes to get a drink because they only have the one bar on the inside, and the bartenders weren't paying much attention to who arrived when (I get that they were busy, but we kept getting passed up by pushier people that arrived after us). Still no cocktail list, so we stuck with beer. They need another bar on the outside, at least one serving canned beer or something. Also there were no cups for the water station, so there was no way to get water except to ask the bartenders. The bathroom was out of toilet paper and paper towels. Around midnight a drunk guy threw up all over the stairs to the seating area, so that was our cue to leave. As you can tell, a very different atmosphere at night time.
Overall, I would come back to enjoy the patio on a sunny afternoon, but it's not my scene after 11pm. And they really need to start making CRAFT cocktails (no one wants to go to OTR and order a Jack and Coke)!
UPDATE: They now have a craft cocktail list!