Robert
Google
My wife and I decided to try a new steakhouse instead of our usual go-to, Cowboy Star. We wanted a change of scenery, so we ventured out of downtown and headed to Rare Society. We didn’t have reservations, but we were fine with sitting at the bar—honestly, that’s often where the best conversations happen anyway.
We kicked things off with a couple of drinks: a whiskey sour and an extra dirty vodka martini. Both were spot on. No complaints here—the whiskey sour was made the right way, shaken with an egg white, which is how it should be.
For food, we went with the Cedar River prime ribeye (non-aged). I’m not the biggest fan of dry-aged steaks—they tend to taste a bit gamey to me, which I think is more of an acquired taste. We ordered it cooked medium. The flavor was solid; it could’ve used a touch more salt, but overall, it was good.
We also ordered a Caesar salad. It was decent—not amazing, but not bad either. It had a lot of cheese—so much that they might as well rename it the “Cheesy Caesar.” Not a complaint, just an observation.
We didn’t try any appetizers or dessert, so I can’t speak to those.
Will we go back? Maybe. I wouldn’t mind trying a few more items from the menu. But to be honest, I’d probably rather check out another steakhouse or just stick with Cowboy Star.
One heads-up: parking is rough. Most of the street spots were already taken, so consider taking an Uber or getting dropped off.
Bon appétit.