Ron B.
Yelp
This higher-end farm-to-table restaurant is very unique to the Lansing area, but this place has me 'on the fence' a bit, and not because of the price.
Over the past year I've had the opportunity to dine in some great degustation restaurants in major cities and while Red Haven has some qualities that allow comparisons to be made, there are a few areas that warrant improvement.
Here are my observations based on a recent dinner with three, during which we thoroughly sampled the menu through consumption of 8 courses, dessert, and some cocktails and wine:
First, while the food is generally of great quality and beautifully presented and the kitchen puts up some great flavor combinations, a couple of the components were not too good. The kale 'garnish' in particular (part of two of our dishes -in identical form) was way too salty. If I pay 'top-dollar' I would like everything to be excellent, without exceptions. (Additionally, I thought the dishes were generally a bit on the sweet side. This is of course entirely personal, but I would have enjoyed some more light / delicate courses.)
Second, the speed with which courses were brought out generally worked fine. We received two courses at a time twice, but then all of a sudden four at once (2+2+4). This seemed to have been intent, but it resulted in us eating a couple slightly colder dishes. Thus, bad course management by the kitchen ...
Finally, I think the menu is a bit presumptuous and unclear (as others have said too):
- I don't mind asking a thousand questions, but it's a bit frustrating that this is in fact required to get an understanding of what the different options entail.
- I disliked the need to order everything at once. If you claim to be a tapas-style restaurant then this makes no sense.
- Here's just a suggestion, but a true degustation or tasting menu (with paired wine option?) would be great. It would totally fit with this style of restaurant.
Now, the price we paid for the food (all including 20% tip):
$130 for the 8 courses ($43pp)
$160 for the 8 courses plus 3 desserts ($53pp)
This is probably high by Midwest (and, judging from some reviews, astronomical by EL) standards, but based on the restaurant type, ambiance, and especially food quality, I'd say this is par for the course, if not better. For us, the eight courses + 3 desserts was a bit overkill. 6+2 or 7+1 would have been fine too, so it wouldn't be hard to go a bit cheaper and leave satisfied.
(Our bill of course ramped up pretty steeply by adding some cocktails and wine -and yours will too-, but the prices for just the food are totally acceptable.)
There were also some definite highlights:
The waitress that served us was beyond excellent. Knowledgeable, personal, and relaxed. She gave great advice, answered all questions patiently, and was fun. (When our four main dishes were brought out all at once, we had a different server and he gave -in hindsight- the wrong advice for which dish to finish with, so possibly not all wait staff is just as good.)
Most of the food was really quite excellent. Here's a rundown of our dishes:
- Bake: fresh bread with beet jam, and a delicious butter w honey & salt
- Dip: burnt rye worked remarkably well with the fresh dip.
- Press: goat tacos were ok. Not really memorable.
- Mash: potato w cream & butter deep fried. beef cheek garnish. Bay leaf 'pesto'. The mashed potato 'block' was really delicious, but the beef cheeks were not as tender and juicy as expected.
- Duck: breast over leg. Great waffle syrup sauce, a bit peanutty. Nice dish, but the kale was way too sweet and salty.
- Crust: Pork brined. Sweet caramelized onions w a small 'kick'. Very nice and beautifully presented.
- Grill: trout a bit cold. Great parsnip vanilla purée.
- Broil: squash broiled, but quite 'al dente'. Kale again; Too salty again. Appel was nice n fresh. Pawpaw soymilk sauce (mango-banana like; vanilla-ish) was great.
Wine: 2012 sexual chocolate. Sirah/Petite-sirah/Zinfandel blend. A bit tight. Not very complex but nice.
Desserts:
- Birthday [cake]: nice sweet potato cake with great frosting. Root beer liquor drizzle very unique and delicious.
- Chocolate [beets]: flourless cake. Very nice taste but a bit dry texture. Pumpkin sauce yum.
- Pawpaw [split]: nice n light.
So, in summary of this loooooong review. Definitely a very interesting place to eat and clearly unique to the area. Improvements are possible, but overall I thought the food was great (although not universally so) and beautifully presented, and serving excellent. In comparison with big-city quality dining, this place would get stuck in 3-star range. However, in the mitten-state this is worth 4 stars for me.