Tracy S.
Yelp
When Husband was fourteen years old, he saw a video in Spanish class that showed this restaurant. He swore to himself, "Someday, I will eat that piglet!" This summer, more than twenty years later, he did...and he was not disappointed.
The thing to realize about Jose Maria's is that it is mainly about the spectacle. If you don't allow yourself to be caught up in it, you may walk away unhappy. But if, like us, you came to see the show as well as eat the food, you will most likely be thrilled. We were a party of ten, so we had a huge round table on which to display all of our courses coming out, and two servers to spoil us. Add to that several bottles of wine, and by the time Jose Maria came down, donned his huge gold pig-chopping medallion, and set to work hacking our pig up with a dinner plate, we were all giddy. It was a fantastic experience, and the food was equally good.
We all had the cochinillo asado (duh), with starters of salad, sweetbreads, and tempura vegetables. It was difficult not to fill up on the starters--the tuna in the salad was so gorgeous that I wouldn't allow a single chunk to be cleared from the table; the kidneys were rich and tender and plentiful, and many of us had second and third helpings; the veggies were fresh and firm. The main event though--the piglet--cannot be equaled. I have read several reviews from diners who did not like the richness of the meat and the sauce, it being so beautifully fatty, but I was ready to pour that fat sauce right down my gullet, it was so wonderful. It is difficult to stick with utensils at this point, as the meat is so tender that you just want to get in there with your fingers and pull out the choice bits.
I have only one complaint about our experience. As the piglet is sliced into six pieces, there are many different cuts to go around. Husband was smart enough to ask the waiter for a face piece. Friend got stuck with the ribs, which, while still tasty, had a much chewier skin, so she wasn't sure why we were all blissed out over the crispy skin until I started sharing mine with her. I got ass...tail and all. I couldn't say which cut is the best one, but they are not all equal.
So, was our meal worth the three-hour drive? Absolutely. Wish granted, Husband...where to next?