Latiasha B.
Google
I went to Tio Pepe for lunch with my coworkers on December 16, 2025, and as someone who has lived in Baltimore my entire life, I was surprised to realize I had never heard of this restaurant before.
Let’s start with the pros, because there were many. The ambiance is absolutely lovely. From the moment you walk in, you’re greeted warmly and professionally. They take your coats (checked at the front), seat you immediately, and the dim lighting creates a cozy, elegant, family-style atmosphere. It felt welcoming and classic, and I truly loved everything about the environment.
The service was also excellent. Our servers were attentive, kind, and efficient. We didn’t wait long for our food, and the staff overall was very pleasant and professional.
The menu had an impressive variety of options, all of which looked amazing. One of my coworkers and I both ordered the Pollo y Langosta Catalina — chicken and lobster tail sautéed in a sherry-infused seafood sauce. Flavor-wise, it was outstanding. The sauce was creamy, rich, and absolutely delicious, truly the highlight of the meal.
Unfortunately, this is where the experience took a disappointing turn.
When the entrées arrived, the other plates were placed directly on the table. However, the server removed both my plate and one of my coworker’s plates from the table to prepare our dish on a table directly behind us. I did not turn around to observe whether the entrée was divided or exactly what was done; however, after a few minutes, both plates were returned with food on them. By the time the dish was served, the portions we received were extremely small. Each plate contained only a small scoop of rice and very minimal amounts of chicken and lobster in sauce. I am unsure whether this is standard practice, but the portion size was disappointing given the price. The rice itself also lacked flavor.
For a $50 entrée, there is absolutely no reason it should be split between two plates unless it is clearly intended to be shared (which seems to be what may have happened). Everyone else at the table received generous, appropriate servings, which made the discrepancy very noticeable. This was both surprising and disappointing.
While the food itself tasted wonderful, the portion issue significantly impacted the experience. Sadly, because of this, I don’t think I’ll be returning. It’s unfortunate, because Tio Pepe has so much going for it, ambiance, service, and flavor, but portion value matters, especially at that price point.