Mark K.
Yelp
I've lived in Columbus for 35 years but just never made it down here. Not on my way anywhere, and downtown, which I avoided anyway, plus parking is nuts. But I have some free time now, and am downtown often, and I keep hearing how good it is. And I like a good burger, so I came down here on a weekday afternoon.
They close at 2 PM at least a few days a week, so get there early enough to eat before then. It is down an alley, in an old old building that used to be the rathskeller. There is outdoor seating for nice days. Darn small inside. It is dark and woody and cozy. I'm sure when it's busy it gets loud and hectic. But when I went, there were only one or two other customers.
Service was excellent. The menu is interesting. Mostly sandwiches, a lot of burgers. I got the de la Hoya, since I liked what it had on it, and I didn't want to go too big or over the top. It was still big, a half pound burger, and not over the top but almost too big to pick up and a little messy, so come prepared. The bun was fluffy and perfectly baked. The burger was perfectly cooked. Also has provolone, aioli, and roasted peppers. A nice flavor combination.
Is it the best burger in town? No. It's good. It's up there in the top 5 or 10 let's say. But we have some other pretty darn good burgers too. Still, they have a variety of choices of toppings and sizes of burgers. Plus a few other sandwiches. It's tasty, and very filling. I also got onion rings, and they were very good.
Women's restroom is a small door right off the dining room. The men's restroom is down a pretty steep flight of stairs for an old guy, and is very basic. There's also another overflow/party/storage room down there. That would almost double the capacity at busy times.
I would gladly come back. Plus, the overall experience was excellent. The building is cool inside and out. Service, choices, pricing, just the ambience and experience were great. I parked in the state house lot, really just a few steps away across the street. There's otherwise very very limited parking in the area. If you are down here for something else, definitely stop by. Is it worth a special trip? Well, maybe from the burbs. Certainly not from out of town. But a very good burger in a cool setting. I should not have waited this long to try it.