Rockfish

This place was so great we went twice on our visit to the Vineyard!! We had the same bartender both times. He was fantastic! Everyone was very friendly and the bar area is lively. The first night they had the game on and boy do people in Boston take their sport serious! So much fun watching them cheer their team on!

Very relaxed atmosphere. Quick service. Lobster roll was incredible- worth the money. Truffle Risotto Balls were very truffle-y, and the mashed potatoes that they were served on were cold. Prosciutto and Arugula pizza would have been better if it had shaved Parmesan on top to finish it off and a little crispier. Drinks were delicious- Aviation and Espresso Martini. Would recommend if you’re in town for a date night. I’d say it’s expensive, but what isn’t expensive these days. I would come back.

Cool little place in Edgartown. Almost have to look for it very low key entrance. The food was incredible. Warm lobster roll incredible, tons of meat and the perfect bread. My husband had the Guinness Short Rib. It was seriously delicious. Maybe get the crunchy onions on the side - he thought heavy handed with those but did not change our 5 star rating. Another real star was the French fries. Perfect cut and texture - don’t miss them. Great bar with fun cocktails. Almost didn’t stop here for one of the water front noisier places - so glad we did! Almost forgot prices ver reasonable especially for the drinks!

Rockfish was one of the few spots open in Edgartown over the Easter holidays, and I’m glad we gave it a try. The space itself isn’t fancy — it feels more like a pub than a restaurant — but the upstairs seating has a nice view of the street and a charming house right across from the window. We had a table by the window, which made for a cozy setting. Our server, Sarah, was super friendly and welcoming from the start. I had what was probably the best lobster roll of my life. Generous chunks of lobster, deliciously seasoned lobster salad, and a big portion of fries on the side — it really stood out from other Lobster Rolls I’d tried on this trip. Rockfish may not be a design destination, but if you’re after great seafood and a laid-back atmosphere, this place delivers. Come for the lobster roll, not the decor — and you won’t be disappointed.

We are visiting from our ship tendered near Martha’s Vineyard. We took the “free bus” from Oaks Bluff. The restaurant was highly recommended. The server was wonderful. Her name is Sarah. She gave us helpful tips. The lobster roll was excellent. We shared it. The soup (clam chowder) was perfect on a cloudy, cold day.

Was at the Island for a week and there were a couple of nights that this place was the only restaurant open for dinner so if you're visiting around this time, be prepared for a.) loud environment b.) super loud music on top of everyone talking loudly c.) wait time Food-wise, the fried calamari is one of the best fried calamaris I've had- the coat was just right and the squid was tender. The Lobster Pot Pie was unique, but a too salty for me. My friend had the Bolognese and said it was nothing special. The Filet Mignon was great. Overall, this place is worth a try when visiting MV. This is a local fave, as well.

Had an absolutely amazing time. I was stranded on the island over night during some bad weather. My server Brad was sooo awesome! He was friendly and Made me feel comfortable. Always checking in to see if there was anything I needed. If ever on island again I'll definitely be back!!

Matt/Matty was amazing as our server. The food was good. I LOVED my mussels. Mom was okay with her lobster roll. She expected more butter toss for the choice she'd made... I wish mom had asked for butter or spoken up bc she was so excited for the best lobster sandwich.