Rome to Brooklyn, Pizza & Panzerotti

This place is an absolute gem! From the moment you walk in, you can tell it’s run by people who truly care about quality and authenticity. The aroma alone makes you feel like you’ve stepped right into a small pizzeria in Rome. The pizza is on another level – thin, crispy, and perfectly balanced between the sauce, cheese, and toppings. You can taste that everything is made with real ingredients and attention to detail. The panzerotti was out of this world – golden, perfectly fried on the outside, soft and flavorful on the inside, with just the right amount of filling. It’s not something you find often in New York, and they absolutely nailed it. Service was warm and friendly, and the staff made me feel like a regular even though it was my first time there. You can tell they take pride in what they do. The place itself has a cozy, welcoming vibe – clean, comfortable, and full of good energy. If you’re a true pizza lover, this spot is a must. It’s easily one of the best pizza experiences I’ve had in the city, and I’ll definitely be coming back again (and again!). Highly recommended!

Oh my GAWDDD, THE BEST PIZZA EVER! they fell off for a lil bit but tonight I had to immediately write this review because I am totally enjoying this delicious margherita pizza ! It's perfect from tip to crusty top, the sauce is authentic, the mozzarella cheese taste homemade! Simply delicious 😋

This was a nice lil spot - there must have been a leech in my stomach bc I was eating every five seconds. And so of course once I past here and spotted the garlic knots, the Staten Island in me couldn't say no. The price wasn't bad at all either. But given the size (and the fact that my stomach was about to burst) I only bought one. Sadly, it wasn't the garlic knots of my memories. It was too dense - not light and fluffy like the smallies I was used to. Thought this was just larger but with the same airy taste. But as mentioned, I finished it bc i had no self-control on this fateful day. The service was great, and there was seating enough for about 6 people- nothing out of the ordinary.

This place was just so good. The guy behind the counter was super friendly and patient. Pretty sure it was obvious we weren't from the area. I loved every bite of that pizza. Definitely a lot better than the stuff I can get around home.

not just the best slice on grand street, it’s the best damn slice in williamsburg. great options, buffalo chicken slice is my favorite, and the other options are incredible including the penne alla vodka. great and friendly staff, the owner is such a hardworker and is so welcoming to everyone in the neighborhood. excited to check out the newer location in greenpoint 🤘 every neighborhood would benefit from Rome to Brooklyn

Controversial take, but this is hands down my favorite slice in the city. The pies never miss and the owner is a gem. Everything on the menu hits, but if you haven’t yet… do yourself a favor and try the grandma pep, BBQ or buffalo chicken, and margherita. You’ll get it. We moved and still citibike across the city once a month for it. That should tell you everything.

Best slice I’ve ever had. Burrata, Pesto and Vodka Sicilian. It was big and affordable at $5.99. Such a premium slice. The dough has a good crunch while yet being doughy at the same time. Please come here!!

Super great owner and staff. Pizza was amazing. Open late. Highly recommend.

I usually have this pizza after work so right around 10pm which is an hour before this place closes. Mind you the pizza still tastes fresh and delicious despite closing in an hour. Most pizza places would just serve you old pizza that's been sitting there but not Rome to Brooklyn. Not to mention the staff is always super nice and welcoming. I love this pizzeria, they've got my business as long as I'm in New York.

So happy I had another show in the area cause it let me come back to this place. Decided to try a slice I've never had and went with the grandma slice. It was SO GOOD and I think I may have to switch to eating it every time I'm able to come here. The flavor is so delicious and kinda puts the regular cheese slice to shame. Can't wait to go back and eat it again!!

It's been a few years since I last came to Rome to Brooklyn... but it was JUST as good as I remembered! My partner and I were in the area and had a hankering for some pizza, luckily Rome to Brooklyn came to the rescue. My favorite slice this time around was the Vodka Burrata Pesto Sicilian pizza. Vodka sauce and pesto were great. Burrata creamy. Crust perfect combo of doughy + crispy. One of my favorite slices of 2025 so far. Small, local spot for sure with only a couple of two seater tables. Pizza came out fresh and hot, and rather quickly which I appreciated. Friendly service. Will definitely return!

My new go to pizza place omg Pizza is heavenly here- Truly the dough is amazing/ the flavors are so good. I order Uber eats from here all the time when I'm craving a pizza. I've tried the prosciutto one, the broccolini one, bbq pizza, and regular cheese. Everyone single one hits and is delicious. My favorite is the broccolini one, the flavors are so good and the broccolini is such a nice texture to it. The bbq pizza wow, the ratio of sauce to chicken is so good. I love the bbq sauce they use and onions wow so good. Their garlic pinwheels are also spectacular, the best I've had in nyc. So much garlic in between the layers of the pinwheels is immaculate. If u want to order pizza in, I def recommend this place!

Amazing pizza place, and when Aurel overlooks the pizza and does quality control, you can't go wrong! Super light but delicious pizza with the perfect portions of cheesiness and bread, these slices are super addicting and a great local spot to eat on a monthly basis l!

Best pizza especially in Brooklyn. Unique! The presentation is great and the taste reflects it.

I've come here a few times and previously tried their Buffalo Chicken Pizza. My personal favorite is their Vodka Sauce Pizza. The sauce does overflow but you can pick it up again with your pizza crust. This is a great pizza spot on in Williamsburg. They have a vast selection of pizza on display to choose from as well as a menu with other food items such as panzerotti, focaccia, pasta, etc. I came first thing in the morning to start my weekend with a slice of pizza from them. It was worth the wait since it did require to cool down before cutting a slice. What I liked about this spot is that it's your classic pizzeria with the staff hard at work making the pizza and sharing in conversation on making sure the pizza turns out great. A bit of overheard conversation while eating but I quite enjoyed it. It's very chill at some part of the days as well as get a bit lively. Recommend adding this on your next pizza quest/journey in NYC or casual pizza night. It's worth the $4.50+ pizza slice price tag and make every bite count

For a really teeny pizza by the slice place, this place packs a punch! The unconventional square slices are perfectly crisped and charred, and full of flavor. I wish this place were closer to me. Mushroom truffle was soooo good.

I was around the neighborhood & was craving pizza so I tried 3 types of pizzas: grandma slice, wild mushroom truffle slice & margherita slice. Out of the 3 slices, the best in taste was the grandma slice (tomatoey, garlicy, etc). The mushroom truffle was ok and lacking in flavor. The margherita was ok as well (not the best margherita I have eaten) - I think because it was a bit cold & not heated up or crispy. Staff was very friendly & nice. Some indoors seating.

Wobbled over here on a Friday night with not many people inside. Only a couple tables to the right near the counter, so it's mostly a spot to take on the go. Opted for slices of the Buffalo Chicken and the Margherita, along with a water (total $10). Crust on both items are perfectly crispy, not overcooked and light up top. Margherita is easy to eat - good blend of the cheese and sauce with a slight kick. Buffalo chicken isn't too greasy, nice chicken chunks and the right amount of buffalo sauce. Service is quick as the guys got the slices in the oven and out again within a few minutes. Perfect place for a quality slice in the middle of bar hopping or just needing a quick fix.

Discovered this slice house while doing a self guided pizza tour throughout Brooklyn. Seemed like mostly a to-go / pickup spot, but there were some tables in the front where we were able to sit while enjoying our pizza. The service was fast and friendly (got our piping hot pizza within 5 min of ordering - and still tasted fresh). The pizza was incredible - we tried three different slices / squares. A vodka slice (cheese on bottom, sauce on the top - which was creamy but not too soupy), a pepperoni square (pepperoni themselves were delicious, wasn't the biggest fan of the tomato sauce tho), and a hellraiser square (soppresatta with spicy peppers, cheese, and hot honey). I was a huge fan of all three (the crust on both the slices and squares were immaculate). Will definitely be back again!

This was our first visit for delivery, and when we looked at reviews we saw that the 1/2 buffalo and 1/2 truffle white pizza was a popular option - and my husband and I's respective favorite pizzas! A large pie by itself, or mix and match will run you $28+ tax. There is no option for 1/2 pie on the website or 3rd party vendors like GrubHub, but I placed a buffalo chicken pizza and added the 1/2 pizza request in the notes section and they fulfilled it without any fuss. The buffalo was delicious - nice and saucey, tangy, thin crust, and the chicken tasted very fresh I'm a truffle lover, and overall I give the mushroom truffle a lesser rating than the buffalo. You could absolutely smell and taste the bit of truffle, but everything else left a bit more to be desired for me. I wanted the mushrooms to have more flavor, but they were mostly just cooked and slapped on the pizza to me - but maybe cooking in garlic, or some sort of cream sauce would make the overall taste pack a punch just a bit more! I still enjoyed it, but I'm a bit pickier when it comes to my favorite flavor. It's not shy of mushrooms and is loaded with them, as well as fresh rosemary. I also appreciated that they don't upcharge you for a 1/2 and 1/2 pizza. Overall, this spot would definitely be a go-to pizza spot for me if I lived in the area. I wouldn't hesitate to recommend this spot if you're looking for easy, fast, accurate delivery or pick up pizza!

Was craving pizza so I had to find a pizza place within delivery distance from my place and something I haven't tried. We ended up picking Rome to Brooklyn Pizza! It arrived maybe after an hour after I ordered. I ordered the grandma pie with pepperoni and it came in a very large pizza box! The pizza wasn't hot when it came, so I decided to throw it in the air fryer to heat it up. I did eat a slice in the mean time up to get the initial tasting. A little soggy, but still good. The pizza was thinner than I'm use to for grandma pies. A lot of basil and thin pepperonis. I noticed that they topped it with some Parmigiano reggiano. What I liked about the pizza, it was saucy. I topped it with some hot honey and it was so delicious! I like my thin pizza crispy and that hot honey elevated the pizza a lot! I would definitely order again!

The pizza if by far the best pizza in NYC! the owner is great! Staff is super friendly. I love pizza and have tried all, Rome To Brooklyn is the best by far. Looking forward to their new location opening in Greenpoint as well. BEST PIZZA EVER!!

I went to the new From Rome to Brookyn on Manhattan Ave in Williamsburg and being someone who makes my own dough and sauce, I was delighted to find that this was the best pizza in the neighborhood. I have tried L'industrie and their pizza was very good but I felt the sauce lacked flavor. From Rome to Brooklyn had a crispy thin crust and a delicious homemade sauce with fresh basil. Now I know that if I don t feel like making it myself, I can order it and I won t be disappointed. So happy to have this great pizza close by. Roe

Owner is super nice and cool. I tried a few different slices and they were literally the best slices I've had in my life. Go here if you're looking for a great slice of pizza.

I was in the neighborhood with a friend and wanted some pizza. I ended up choosing the meat lovers slice and a vodka slice. The meat lovers was very tasty, but the vodka slice was crazy delicious. I'd go back just for the vodka slice!

Lord almighty, I've been looking for a good pizza spot since I moved to bed stuy and was having problems finding one. I am currently on a keto diet and wanted to find a cauliflower pizza, I am not kidding when I say this was delicious even for a keto pizza. Delicious crispy cracker like crust, crispy cheese and sauce just muah *** chefs kiss*** . 10/10 recommend the grandma pizza , cauliflower crust if you want something low carb.

Ordered a large margarita and it was absolutely amazing. Perfect balance of cheese and sauce with the fresh basil. This is the best pizza in the neighborhood hands down.

I took a ride on the L train to sample RTB's Pizza. It is a tiny location that has seating for only four diners. I ordered a Margherita slice, and a Mushroom slice. Both slices were tasty, but very small. I ordered a Grandma's slice because I wasn't quite full. The Grandma's slice was decent a well. My bill with a can of soda was $15.25. I don't think that I'll be returning.

Small spot near our office in Brooklyn. Clean inside , friendly and fast service. If you want to have a couple slices this is a good bet. Take a look at the case and you'll have a hard time deciding what to get. I tried a grandma slice and a meat lovers slice. Both were delicious but I give the regular style slice with the perfect amount of meats the win between the 2. Crisp crust at perfect thickness and quality ingredients. I'd gladly return and definitely recommend. I look forward to trying some more of their offerings.

I have a severe wheat intolerance and decided to come here during a quick stay in Brooklyn after reading the stellar reviews for their gluten free pizza. Well folks, the reviews don't lie. This is seriously the best pizza I have had in over a decade, and the best gluten free I have eaten anywhere ever. I wish I didn't live across the country because I want to try all of their pies now. My husband said the pizza with gluten (AKA normal pizza) is also amazing. Plus, it was ready quick! 10/10. Come here if you are in, or even relatively close to, Williamsburg.

Some of the best pizza in east Williamsburg for sure. I ordered takeout today through GrubHub because there was a discount, but I've ordered directly through their website and had great delivery experiences before. My favorite pizza is the upside down Sicilian. Oh my god it's fantastic and very very filling. A large pizza gives me leftovers for days. Their sauce is so good. They use the little round pepperoni that is so tasty. The shop is very small so you definitely can't eat inside. I've also walked in just for a slice or two and they're often really busy because the pizza is so good. We are so lucky to have Rome to Brooklyn in our neighborhood. Today I tried the vodka slice which was great and got the meatball appetizer and it comes with two focaccia slices and hits the spot. I actually couldn't finish all the meatballs because this place doesn't skimp. Can't wait to have the rest tomorrow tomorrow. :)

Rome to Brooklyn serves ridiculously delicious pizza and definitely lives up to their five-star Yelp rating. Their grandma pie is absolute perfection. The crust is thin and crispy; the sauce is flavorful and not acidic; and they are generous with their toppings while still maintaining a perfect balance. I could easily eat it every single day and not get tired of it. That being said, I haven't tried anything else that they offer because I can't seem to deviate from the grandma pie. It will happen someday though, and I'm sure I won't regret it based on the photos I've seen!

Such great pizza.. wow! It was thin crust and so incredibly tasty. We went close to closing and tried the vodka and bianco slices. They were absolutely amazing! I've never had a vodka slice so good. The bianco was perfect with the ricotta and carm onions! The service was quick and efficient. They were very friendly! It's a small space but perfect for what it is! 10/10 recommend if you're in the area

Pizza is excellent. Highly recommend. Had a delivery hiccup, but owner made it right. Classy move.

Great Pizza! Wow we tried a bunch of stuff and it was all great. Especially the pepperoni grandma slice and the vodka sauce slice!

Rome To Brooklyn provides excellent service and pizza. My favorite was the vodka slice. The sauce was perfection and the crust was nice and cripy. There's a couple tables and seats inside if you want to eat the pizza fresh or ask to take it go in a box or bag. I will be back to try the garlic knots and the square grandma slice. They take credit card but have a $5 minimum.

We were very hungry one evening. We had just picked up a guest from the airport. There was a lot of traffic and it was getting pretty late. I was able to order online quickly and walked in to pickup the order. As you can see everyone was very hungry and we ate in the car even before driving away. Both pizzas were hot and delicious!

all pizza ain't built the same nor should it be...what you like may not be what i enjoy and vice-versa. and thankfully in New York, you can go fuck off and i'll still be right bc of facts and you're being terminally wrong. hahaha Rome To Brooklyn Pizza serves a tasty quality New York City slice. it's classic in its own right. a thin crisp crust but holds firm bc there's a good amount of chew in the crust itself, a little flop when folded...covered in a not too sweet nor too acidic sauce...with a thin sheet of melty mozzarella cheese. the slice is satisfying company after a long day of touring through Brooklyn. the menu, here, is pretty large as there is a variety of difference pies and slices served here on top of garlic pinwheels, panzerotti, salads, pastas, desserts and more. tbh, i am not interested in most of that bc the New York plain cheese slice can't be eclipsed. but like anything in life, you should find what you enjoy...and explore that...which is why i am forever discovering and enjoying nyc pizza in all the boroughs. the space is small, clean, and modern--a few tables for dine-in. staff seems a bit busy and curt bc but their efforts are clearly in the food.

Best Buffalo pizza in Brooklyn hands down. Ain't no one coming close to this little coner Buffalo handmade pizza. Delicious, full of chicken, chives, onions, cheeses, and loads of Buffalo sauce! YUM. This is a little tiny shop and they seem to gather much if their business from carry out and delivery. They do have a few tables and chairs so their customers can enjoy a quick siñce of pie.

Everything about this place is phenomenal. The owner is the sweetest person, great guy. I told him to give me his favorite slice and it was absolutely amazing. 10/10

This review is for delivery only. Literally my favorite place to order pizza from. I've ordered from here too many times to count and it's always perfection. The delivery times do take awhile, so just make sure you plan for that. My go-to order is: -Grandma Pizza with pepperoni: obsessed. I am someone that likes a very saucy pizza and sometimes have an extra side of sauce I dip my pizza into, but not here. This pizza is super saucy! They are generous with the toppings (love the little pepperonis) and it's always cooked perfectly. -Garlic Pinwheels: omg so good. Buttery, doughy, cheesy, garlicky. -Kale Caesar: nothing exciting, but I usually order in an attempt to feel healthier. I've also tried the Barbecue Chicken, which was very good.

I got the Margherita pizza and it was pretty good! Tbh it is kinda hard to get pizza wrong (I think) so First of all, I was very surprised by the large size. If you're like me, you probably wanna know how big the pizza is going to be so you search and search but don't find any info soo I uploaded a pic with my hand for reference. It'll feed 3 people or even more but luckily I just got it for myself. As for the taste, the tomato sauce is kind of sweet and it tastes "fresh" like it doesn't have a very cooked note like pasta sauce if you know what I mean. The pizza all together was satisfying and thin crust. Now, for leftovers the middle gets soggy but it's still good. For the price point and size, it's a deal. Live a good life and just get some pizza. If you don't like it then ignore me lol. I am not a passive pizza eater.

Visited this location a few days ago and tried their Grandma Pepperoni and Bianco slices. The food was so delicious!!! Staff was really helpful and nice, and the place is perfect for a quick bite to eat. Highly recommend coming here!!

Great pizza, EXCELLENT customer service!! I placed a huge order because...well...I have a big family. I was really anticipating the blueberry pizza as it's a huge pregnancy craving. Upon placing my order I talked about how good it sounds and how I can't wait to dig in. I get a call 10 minutes after my order was placed to tell me they ran out of blueberry slices. I can't lie, I cried. It's a pregnancy craving I couldn't have so I cried. I opted for the ricotta with onion instead but I really didn't want that. My husband called the pizzeria and made some sort of arrangements for them to make it for me as a pie. They were so kind enough to do so. I'm so glad he called them behind my back because it's everything I expected. The sweet, savory and salty mix together was perfect. Shout out to Rome In Brooklyn and husband for making those accommodations for me and baby. Everything was absolutely amazing from delivery to the flavor of the pizza and crunchiness of the crust. They have a loyal customer from now on.

Heard about this place but never been until now. Stopped by right as they were opening and taking the pizzas fresh out of the oven. Let me set this straight, when you first walk into this place and you immediately take a look at their slices you know something really good is going on here. Not only do they have slices you won't find anywhere else but you could tell this place is a step above with its ingredients and just the way the slices look. I went with their white slice and vodka slice. The white slice is 1000% better than any white slice I've ever had in NYC. Change my mind. Riccotta and mozzarella topped with caramelized onions, black pepper, and extra virgin olive oil. You tell me who else does a white slice like this? The vodka slice was just as good. Sweet vodka sauce and fresh mozzarella can never go wrong. Both slices were perfectly sized and cooked well. I will most deff be back! Eat here!

One of my fav slice shops in the area. They have many options and the pizza undercarriage is perfectly crispy with no flop. Tried the meatballs on my last trip and they were chef's kiss

The grandma pizza with grilled zucchini, kalamata olive and roasted peppers (vegeteriana) is amazing, as is the BURRATA, VODKA & PESTO SICILIAN. Crust is excellent. This place is great, and lots of options to order avoiding seamless and their fees.

Delicious gluten free pies! Interesting flavor combinations and I appreciated all the options to customize. The pear and Gorgonzola pie was awesome; it's even more incredible if you add blueberries. Also highly recommend the vodka pie. Their vodka sauce is BOMB. Looking forward to my next order!

Biiig fan! katalino (adoptable) highly recommends the garlic knots. The prices are so reasonable and the staff is divine. Follow on IG @littlekittiesbigcity

Soooo delicious Buffalo slice pizza pepperoni square mushroom square fresh mozz and basil square. This food is excellent :)

Cuisine: 10 Service: 7 Decor: 5 Value: 10 Overall: 9 Currently, the square slices here are my biggest pizza craving in NYC. I am lucky to drive by here every few weeks, and without fail, always stop by for a few bites. Yesterday, on the way home, I bought lunch back for the family from here. There was three of each type: Grandma, Mushroom, and Pepperoni. Hard to choose a favorite, they were all too good. Everyone enjoyed the pizzas and said they want to try it fresh next time at the restaurant. What makes it so great? Like all pizzas imho, it starts with that amazing crust, crispy, flaky and delicious. This is what separates Rome to Brooklyn from almost all other pizzerias. Top it off with sauce, fresh cheese, and quality toppings, every bite just makes it more addictive. I can't wait till next time I'm in the neighborhood.

The first time I came here I got the white truffle mushroom pizza and the buffalo chicken pizza, and then it was so good that I came back with my wife and got the grandma pizza and prosciutto/arugula pizza! The crust on these pizzas are perfect and if I were to go again I'd definitely get the white truffle mushroom pizza and the buffalo chicken pizza again. Overall both really had a great flavor that was addicting. The truffle smell/taste is strong but not overpowering and the buffalo sauce was surprisingly good. The other pizzas were really good too! I'll definitely come back the next time that I'm in the area.

My partner called me yesterday raving about this place! He asked me to write a review giving praise to its excellent pizza and service. "the best slice of pizza I ever tried in my life" Hearing this makes me excited to try it myself!

1st time having pizza in New York and really enjoying it! Had the mushroom and truffle oil pizza and the flavors were amazing. Some slices were heavy on the rosemary but overall really good. I absolutely loved the penne all's vodka which went nicely with the garlic and cheese pinwheels.

Hands down one of the best pizza places I got to try while in NY. A small little shop located in Brooklyn that I found and did not disappoint! They have 2 small 2 seater tables outside where you can eat but most people like to take out or deliver. Ordering is easy online or you can walk in and grab a slice that is already made on the shelf. I ordered truffle mushroom, Buffalo chicken, grandma, a and prosciutto arugula pizza. Everything was so good! They add so many toppings and the pizza never got soggy! I loved how you could do half half pizza so we could try multiple flavors without having to buy so many pizzas. The pizza tastes best when you can eat it right out of the oven so eating there is best but they don't have a ton of seating so you may or may not be able to sit outside and eat. Usually we didn't see anyone using the tables the 2 times we went so you may be likely to grab a table. The workers are very nice and helpful if you had any questions or need anything! If you aren't sure of what you want, you can ask them or grab a few pre made slices and try all of it out! Me and my husband ended up eating the entire pizza there because it was so delicious and came back again the day before we left! We will definitely be coming back again when we visit NY next time!

My girl found this place and it was phenomenal! Had the Grandma's pep--from sauce to crust top quality!

Ordered delivery and definitely went overboard but it was 100% worth it. We got the Grandma's Pie, Penne Alla Vodka, Pinwheels and Nutella strawberry desserts. The pizza was great - thin crust and sauce was tangy, basil fresh. Penne was good; hit the spot but I think the pizza was better. The garlic pinwheels were amazing, not too garlicky. We'll definitely order from here again!