Rome to Brooklyn, pizza & panzerotti

I heard about this place and had to try it, and it didn't disappoint. This place primarily sells grandma square slices, and there are about 8 varieties that you can choose from. Extremely crispy and flavorful, you're getting flavorful bites through out whether from the fresh ingredients or just the base ingredient composition. Even between my two slices of pepperoni and mushroom, they were completely different experiences. The flavor reminded me of Mama's Too, except you're getting thinner grandma slices rather than thicker Sicilian slices. Overall, this place really checks all the boxes you want for topping-based grandma slices. I think it could be a top pizza slice shop in NYC.

Thank goodness a second location of Rome to Brooklyn opened here bc we all need more of this pizza! Bigger than the original, with an open airy dining area and plenty of seating. Don't sleep on the vodka slice - best in the city and it comes as a regular slice or a Sicilian with vodka sauce, pesto, and burrata.

Truly the BEST pizza. Just WOW. So many great pizza spots in New York obviously but this somethin else. From the crust to the sauce. 🤤

I’ve been so excited for them to open. I stopped by for the grand opening and got three slices to go. The Burrata Pesto slice was SO fluffy with a crisp bottom. The pepperoni Grandma slice had so much flavor. Even the plain slice was amazing. I can’t wait to try to Pear Gorgonzola slice So happy to have a great pizza shop in the neighborhood

So glad this pizza place opened up nearby! Only been once so far but the two slices we tried were incredible: the vodka sauce and sausage with broccoli rabe. Will be back!! 10/10

$5 Topping pizza, recommand mushroom and white truffle oil slice. very clean and spacious

Solid Margherita slice. The sauce was a bit sweet, which is my thing. I hear the potato slice is the tops.

The vodka, burrata, and pesto Sicilian is v good. A bit doughy, but I was very satisfied.

I had an amazing experience thanks to Jordan! From the moment I walked in, his warm and friendly attitude made me feel welcome. He's knowledgeable, passionate, and recommended one of the best pizzas I've ever had.

Shoutout Jordan for an amazing pizza! Crust was delicious, ingredients fresh, and the store was beautiful and clean. Staff lovely, would absolutely come back to try more flavors

First to review! Well deserved 5/5 stars. I previously reviewed the other location in East Williamsburg, but after coming to the new location, I wholeheartedly give this place a perfect 5/5 star. I've been to a good 40+ pizza joints in my lifetime and I've literally gone from Rome to Brooklyn and Brooklyn to Rome during the summers for Agosto with my Italian partner back to his hometown in lazio. Namely, Lucalis's, l'industrie, Fini, Di Fara, Luigi's, John on Bleeker, MyPie, Upside, Paulie Gees, Scarrs, Mamas Too, etc. This place deserves a rightful place in hall of fame for top 3 pizzas in all of NYC. The pizza here is thin, albeit some other thicker pizzas are Sicilian style, but delicious in a different style. Very light and not heavy or greasy, you could easily scarf a few slices! My personal poison are the garlic knots. Best garlic knots in all of NYC. The owner Aurel is a super nice down to earth guy, and he is the stereotypical friendly neighborhood pizza owner. A definite favorite pizza joint I visit frequently, and now I don't have to go all the way to East Williamsburg anymore! Convenient for my desires, dangerous for my waistline ‍

I'd rate Rome to Brooklyn three and a half stars. I think it's a Taglia style pizzeria. The crust style was sort of a Sicilian style but I don't think that was the intention given the pizzeria is called Rome to Brooklyn. The toppings were the showcase of the slice. We had one with vodka sauce and pesto sauce. Lots of seating inside. Service was very quick.

Solid place to get a slice! I find it kind of hard to rate pizza, because I feel like at a certain point, it's all the same to me lol. That being said, I thought the crust had a good texture, and the toppings were yummy. I love a white sauce mushroom pizza, so of course I had to get a mushroom slice. I do wish that more of their slices came in a triangle shape though, because I'm not a huge fan of square slices.

Very Brooklyn vibe pizzeria. After much deliberation, ordered a mushroom grandma pie to go. Mushrooms were a plenty, fresh & meaty. Crispy & not bready crust. Garlic infused tomato sauce, could have used just a tad more salt. Service couldn't have been any friendlier. I will definitely go back & try a regular pie.

I've been walking by this place for months since it was under construction and I finally got the chance to grab some slices today for dinner. I grabbed six slice and five of them were thin slices with the crispiest crust ever. You could tell ingredients are prioritized here because the pepperonis were those cute and fancy little cup ones! Each slice tasted so fresh and crispy. I did grab one thicker slice which was the burata and vodka slice. This one was hands down my favorite I couldn't get enough of it and I refused to share that slice (corner left in the pic!). I am so excited to get a fresh pie of the vodka burata and see how much better it taste fresh out the oven my mouth is actually watering as I think about it! Rome to Brooklyn is going to be my new go to spot for dinner (and probably lunch). If i could give 10 stars i would that's how amazing this place was.

Amazing pizza & amazing service. The staff was very kind to me and my service animal. Fresh ingredients were used in the food which made every bite enjoyable. They are true pizza masters!

My wife and I loved the pizza, but what really stood out was Jordan's exceptional service. He went the extra mile to ensure we had a wonderful experience. We'll definitely be back!

We got a Mushroom slice and a Grandma slice. Crispy, cheesy, perfect! Both were to-die-for DELICIOUS. Service is pretty amazing too! I'm getting a pie next time! A+++

Amazing service the staff is so friendly unreal pizza and garlic nots. Definitely come here