Rosie's Handcrafted Ice Cream

DELISH! I got the Oreo one and the extra cookies one and WOW they were absolutely delicious. Good serving size and the lady working was very polite and friendly! Also she PACKED the cone…which places never do…so the ice cream didn’t just fall right off the top when I lick it. The elite way to scoop ice cream❤️

Best ice cream around, hands down. I don’t even live around here. My dad and I were in town for the borderlands festival, as we were working it. We had to have gotten Rosie’s at least 3 times and yet here we are outside of the festival on their location down the road. Owner is a wonderful person and the ice cream couldn’t be any better.

A must visit place in East Aurora. They have some classic flavors like vanilla and rose berry (if you like strawberry try this) but their unique and adventurous ice creams are where Rosie’s really shines. Honeylou, Chocolate Chirp and 42 Drunken Raisins were all really good and some of my favorites I’ve tried! They let you try samples which I love. Staff is super friendly and the inside and outside areas are both so cozy. Perfect place to relax with friends and family

One of the best ice cream shops I have ever been to. The flavors are creative and appealing. The ice cream smooth and creamy. The hardest part was deciding what to choose because everything we tried tasted delicious. The staff made the experience even better with their friendliness and advice. This is a MUST-VISIT place if you're ever in the Buffalo area. Also, the cinnamon waffle cone is well worth the upcharge.

Cute little shop with lots of space to sit outside and enjoy a fresh come! They have a LOT of pretty unique flavors, and I highly recommend the homemade waffle cones (cinnamon especially!) The only downsides I saw was that the line was pretty long (worth it though, and they get through it very quickly!) and they don’t let you taste flavors before committing. I totally get it for the time factor of things, but when your flavors are as unique as Rosie’s are, you’re not gonna know that you’re sold until you get a taste in my opinion. Nothing to keep you from trying this space out though, grateful for the small businesses like this in the south towns that make for a nice summer night stop :)

My husband and I have enjoyed visiting Rosie’s after the Bills games. The lady who serves us is one of the most pleasant gals in customer service I have ever met. The vegan ice cream is scrumptious and the homemade waffle cones are indescribably delicious!

Great ice cream, can really taste the difference, the ice cream is...richer than most other places. The "Threat Level Midnight" was excellent but the mint chip almost had a menthol/toothpaste flavor to it, maybe too many years of artificial mint ice cream has corrupted me but I didn't love it. The staff was really friendly and the interior was clean and they sell ice cream sundae sauces to take home! Just wish they gave out samples, so many flavors I wanted to try.

If you happen to be in East Aurora, be sure to make a stop at Rosie's Handcrafted Ice Cream. The staff is friendly and efficient. The Oreo Milk ice cream is fantastic!

Rosie's Handcrafted Ice Cream - A Sweet Win in WNY! If happiness came in a cone, it would be from Rosie's Handcrafted Ice Cream! We circled the block twice before finding it (small lot in the back with maybe 10 spaces, or street parking nearby), but once we walked through those doors--it was game on! As a proud Buffalo Bills fan, I couldn't pass up the chance to try Josh Allen's favorite flavor -- Pistachio, aka "The Joshalicious." My brother joined in, both of us going full waffle-cone mode, while my sister did her own thing with the Oreo Milk flavor. Every flavor looked incredible--honestly, there's not a bad choice in the bunch. A huge shout-out to Chloe, our amazing server! Friendly, patient, and full of good vibes, she made us feel like regulars from the start. She even let me take a video for this review--thank you, Chloe! We sat outside on an unseasonably warm afternoon, enjoying our cones and chatting with other Bills Mafia members visiting from Utah & Indiana. Turns out, we all came to town for the same reason--and while the game didn't go our way, this stop was an absolute win. If you're anywhere near Western New York, make sure Rosie's is on your list. Fantastic flavors Friendly staff Laid-back, neighborhood vibe This isn't just ice cream--it's a little scoop of WNY happiness.

I ordered the bourbon ice cream which had chocolate covered pretzels mixed in! It was delicious and the staff were very kind in offering samples too. All the flavors are super unique and they had seasonal options for fall as well. There's a small seating area inside and a nice spacious balcony to sit when it's nice outside. There's also plenty of shopping that you can walk to after your ice cream stop

Stopped in the area to try out Bar Bills for wings and checked out Yelp for dessert options and so happy we did. Rosies was a quick walk down the street. The homemade waffle cones smelled amazing! Small, clean shop with descriptions listed clearly for all the flavors. Short line at the door. Great, fresh ice cream options with decent portion sizes. All the flavors were so spot on and creamy. Simple parking area, cards accepted and appropriately staffed. We look forward to returning to try additional flavors, highly recommended.

I can't believe it took me so long to finally make it here. Definitely one of my new favorite ice cream shops. I tried 3 flavors and they were all delicious and super creamy. They even asked me which order I wanted my scoops in! The employees were super friendly and gave me a few samples to try as well. I already can't wait to go back to try some more of their (unique) flavors.

Oh em gee this was some of the best ice cream I've ever had. The description for the Oreo milk ice cream was like when you dunk Oreos in milk. This tasted exactly like when you let your Oreos get soggy in the milk. It was so freaking delicious. The waffle cones were also homemade which is a plus as a waffle cone lover. The service was quick and easy. It's a nice space with indoor and outdoor seating. I will definitely be back for more yummy ice cream.

Another amazing flavor - blueberry pie. Already came back for it again since this photo lol! Rosie's - you're simply the best.

Great stop for ice cream with both indoor and outdoor seating options, and friendly staff. The wide variety of ice cream made it difficult to choose just one, but I ordered the dairy-free (made with oat milk) chocolate and maple ice cream in a bowl which was absolutely delicious! Highly recommend!

Larrge variety of ice cream. All homemade. I tried the HoneyLou, which was delicious!! Would have given 5 stars, but you cannot mix the flavors. I would have definitely tried 2 scoops of if I could have added another flavor.

Went at about 8 pm on Monday, the line was at the door but moved very quickly maybe 5 minutes. There is about 3 tables outside and 4 inside, the inside is air conditioned, but with the doors constantly opening. They were out of a few flavors, and are not doing shakes at the moment due to their machines being down. I got the single scoop lemon bar. I would not get it again, the ice cream had simple creamy flavor and then there was lemon sauce drizzled on it which was very sour and artificial. There was also pieces of gram cracker type crust which was fine. I've had other flavors which were much better, this one could have just not been for me. The person I was with got a double scoop of That Waffle Dough and the Cookies and Cream. That Waffle Dough is very chocolaty, so make sure you want lots of chocolate if you choose this. The cookie and cream was amazing and some of the best we've ever had. The other issue is the lemon and oreo were fine, but the waffle dough melted very fast. It was in the 80s all day but we were outside for 2 minutes and it was melting all over and was a mess. Overall, would definitely recommend as the ice cream is amazing and unique flavors something for everyone.

The staff is quick and willing to help. They have a variety of flavors all of which I have yet to be disappointed by.

I'll say the quiet part out loud. If you know of someone (including yourself). That came here and still doesn't like ice cream. Then something is seriously wrong with them and yourself. The hand crafted ice cream here is truly amazing. You have so many fun and unique creations to try and enjoy. I was gifted a few of their pints, and I'm having a hard time trying not to eat them all in one go. Every pint was pack with goodies. Ranging from, marshmallows, nuts, fruit, chocolate candies, and even cereal. I was quite impressed with Rosie's Aye Aye Cap'n- Cap'n Crunch ice cream you can't go wrong. Rosie charms- another cereal themed ice cream. But this one is even better than the Cap'n one. Because the marshmallows are sooo delicious My Yammy- This creation is now one of my favorites.. The taste reminds me sweet potato pie. And I throughly enjoyed the pecans and marshmallow swirl Lemon Verbena- can you say this reminds me of the Wegmans poppyseed muffins, but without the muffin. Absolutely a must try Legitamint- This one I could only eat a scoop of. Not because it tasted bad. But because the taste of Andy's mint chocolate, is to much for me.

Awesome!!! Best hand crafter ice cream I've ever had!!! I've never had ice cream that I had to bite and chew!!! There is so much large chunks of delicious goodness that you can't lick it!!!! The price is great too, much more reasonable than you would think. Two double huge scoops in a waffle cone was around $15!!! Well worth the trip to East Aurora!!!

I was excited to finally check out Rosie's! I stopped by with some friends and this spot is just as adorable as I always imagined it would be. Rosie's is known for making small batches of home made ice cream in some unique flavors. They have a wide variety of flavors and you can enjoy your order here, plenty of seats, or take a pint home. I decided to to try Honeylou which was lavender and honey flavored. It was delicious and refreshing, not too sweet and had a subdued lavender flavor. And I took home a pint of cold brew which I sampled briefly. It was a nice mix of coffee and chocolate also a nice and mellow flavor from what I could tell from a few initial bites. I'm excited to come back and try more options another time. The staff was helpful and sweet. They moved through the line quickly so don't shy away if there is a little bit of a wait.

Rosie's has to be one of my favorite ice cream shops! The ice cream is amazing , no matter the flavor. The staff is friendly and they have ample seating! The blueberry pie was fresh and delicious!

First time coming here and was recommended by my friends. They were talking about how good the ice creams are and I been trying to find a time to come here. Cute spot with parking and outdoor seating area. Indoor seating is limited. They have a good amount of selections for me to choose from. There are some ice cream that are only sold by the pint. They also have different cones for you to choose from. I ordered a scoop of the yabbo dabba boo cause I love fruity pebbles. It was good. I don't think the guy heard me say one scoop so he end up giving me two scoops and it was a lot. I managed to finish one scoop only. My husband ordered one of the berry ones and birthday cake which was also delicious. I will come back for more :)

Amazing ice cream that taste real and delicious. They have a lot of options for dairy free that were also delicious. Ill most definitely be back here again soon!

Brought the little grandsons to Rosie's for an ice cream cone after an afternoon at Hamlin Park Playground. The off street parking in a private lot is so very convenient. While the front entrance stairs might be intimidating to some folks with mobility problems, its good to know that there is an elevator at the rear of the store. As you make your way through the crowd of folks enjoying their ice cream on the veranda, the aroma of baked goods will cause you to stop and drink in the deliciousness. The flavors are innovative and spot on for the ice cream connoisseur. We ordered a Birthday Cake complete with sprinkles as well as a Chocolate Waffle Cone. Very very delicious! You know that this is the real ice cream and not some chemical laden frozen dessert. Gluten free and dairy-free are also options. I'd recommend Rosie's to everyone! They accept credit cards which is convenient.

Fantastic handcrafted ice cream and waffle cones. The ice cream has cool flavors - we tried the fruity pebbles, the cold brew coffee and the waffle dough! Just wish there was a little more seating with tables on the grass! We walked down East Auroras beautiful Main Street after! Great time!

Right in the middle of Main St. in East Aurora. Its walking distance from the other restaurants and attractions in town. Ice cream is noticeably homemade. Lots of fun and wacky flavors. I had the Threat Level Midnight. "It'll take a lot more than a bullet to the brain, lungs, heart, back, and balls to kill Michael Scarn." But anyway, this ice cream was chocolaty and when I say chocolatey it was like a scrumptious bar of chocolate put on steroids, then melted, then frozen. My two baby boys left which their faces covered in ice cream. Twas a good day.

Located right on Main St, East Aurora near the Roycroft campus, Rosie's is a clean and modern ice cream bar with an abundance of choices. This morning, celebrating National Eat Ice Cream For Breakfast Day, they added some unusual but kid friendly flavors - Rosie's Charms and Yabba Dabba Doo - and coffee flavor, blueberry muffin, avocado for their parents. The youngest had the two cereal flavors and ate until the bowl was empty. He said he liked them equal, however, he did also say he liked the marshmallows in the Rosie's Charms. We had the Avocado and Cold Brew. The Avocado was a nice subtle flavor with fantastic chocolate discs. The Cold Brew was great for coffee lovers. Service is quick and friendly as you pick the ice cream from the freezer and they build your cone or cup. Seating is stylish and cozy. Recommended for trying out new flavors or combinations of your favorite chilled desserts.

I went to get chocolate shakes they were $9.50, each! Not to mention the sheer size and girth of the cup was not worth what I paid. Not to mention the chocolate tasted pretty generic. Pretty disappointed with this one.

Following a performance in Hamlin Park, my boyfriend and I went to Rosie's for a little treat. I decided to go with the verbena lemon poppy seed (non-dairy) and he went with the corn bread ice cream. I tried a smidge of his and it was pretty great. I'm not really one for fruity ice cream, but my pick of verbena lemon poppy seed was out of this world and has replaced my threat level midnight as my favorite. The flavors were perfectly balanced and refreshing. Rosie's is the perfect ice cream shop in the perfect village. Check this place out. You will not be disappointed at any of the flavors offered.

East Aurora is a perfectly walkable little town and Rosie's is an easy walk from the center. It was very busy, but they had plenty of room for the line. There is no taste-tests available, but they provide good descriptions. Keep in mind when it says two scoops, it actually means the most massive scoops known to man, so unless you're super hungry, one is probably big enough (but if you want those two, go for it!) The waffle cone was good in idea, but it literally fell apart on me within about 10 minutes and I lost most of my ice cream. That said, what I did get to eat before it all caved in was really yummy and I'd love to try more, but probably in a bowl or actual cone.

The service was amazing, everyone was so sweet, the ice cream was amazing!! It was decorated very cozy and very busy!!

This trip we tried a scoop of the birthday cake. I feel like a name of "birthday cookie" would be more appropriate. It was looked with chewy sugar cookies and the colorful sprinkles added a nice bite. Overall it was a great texture of add-ins in a super sweet, creamy base. A bit too sweet for me, but then again, my daughter and I ate every last spoonful. Also the portion size for our scoop was very generous. FYI - They don't sample flavors anymore. I'm assuming it's because people were taking advantage of it.

Heck yes this place is awesome! Walking up I was super excited to sit on the patio or on one of the Adirondack chairs on the lawn to people watch. As soon as I opened the door I got the delicious smell of a homemade ice cream shop. The best part was they had FOUR UNIQUE AND DELICIOUS looking vegan options (plus tons of other regular ones!). I often find that when an ice cream shop says it has "vegan options" it either has like one vanilla one or like a fruit icee type of treat as your only option. Is that better than nothing? Yes. Is it exciting? Absolutely not. Rosie's has OPTIONS for those on a vegan diet and they all sound amazing! I got a chocolate one but it wasn't just chocolate it was a bunch of stuff and it was amazing. I would definitely get it again but more importantly I will be back to try all of the others!

I've been wanting to try Rosie's since it first opened last year. Finally got the chance to tonight, for what will likely be my last ice cream trip of the summer, and it absolutely exceeded my expectations! They have a good lineup of flavors that include vegan options as well, so there truly is something for everyone. They've also got shakes and ice cream sandwiches for those of us looking for something other than a standard cone. I opted for 42 Drunken Raisins -- essentially an oatmeal raisin cookie flavor (controversial opinion, but oatmeal raisin is the best cookie ever). It absolutely blew my mind! There were huge chunks of oatmeal cookie dough throughout my scoop and plenty of delicious raisins. The prices aren't too bad either, $10 for two single scoops of ice cream. For the quality you're getting, I think that's a very fair price. The staff was really awesome and helpful too! My day was instantly made rosier by Rosie's. If you're ever in the EA area, I highly recommend a trip here for a sweet treat.

Finally, made it out to try Rosie's with my boyfriend this past Saturday evening, close to when they closed. Even though, it was a little chilly in the air, still a perfect night for icecream. The line went quick, and was well worth waiting in, my boyfriend had gotten 2 scoops of That Waffle Cone, and my selection was one scoop of Bada Bing Bada Bourbon...which was way better then anticipated. Located in the heart of East Aurora, if your looking for unique flavors, and homemade waffle cones, this deserves a stop.

The ice cream was great got a waffle dough it was very good. Nice outside vibe and the service was good.

Very cute shop and delicious ice cream. It was the perfect last stop for my 4 year old and I after exploring the East Aurora Village. We went on a weekday afternoon and it was not crowded and the service was very quick.

Everything tasted so good! I love the flavors that they have season after season. And the fact that they are open during winter is a huge plus for me!

Locked the doors 5 mins early. I wish I didn't waste the gas going there. If the hours say open until 10 it should be open until 10.

Delicious homemade ice cream right near Roycroft in East Aurora! Friendly service, clean place and nice indoor/outdoor seating options. Homemade waffle cone was delicious!

Wow. Hands down the best I've cream spot I've ever been to. After a nice walk at Knox Park, we drove over to Rosie's and were happy to see there was plenty of parking available on a Saturday afternoon. There was a short line, but it went by very quickly. The staff was wonderful and greeted us as soon as it was our turn to order. There were three of us and we each ordered a two scoop on a waffle cone: the Birthday Cake, the Cold Brew, and the Yabba Dabba Doo! OBVIOUSLY I took a small spoonful of everyone's ice cream LOL. T The Birthday Cake was absolutely delicious and tasted just like a real birthday cake. I believe it had chunks of cake in it as well! The Cold Brew - i wish I lived right next door to Rosie's because I would seriously consider swapping my morning coffee for a daily scoop of this. The Yabba Dabba Doo - MY FAVORITE. I don't even know how to describe this. It's as if I teleported back to my 6 year old self, eating fruity pebbles and watching TV on a Saturday morning. It was THAT GOOD.

We came out of our way from Kenton for this ice cream with the amazing reputation. I will say the hype ... TOTALLY WORTH IT. This artisan ice cream was so good I am still thinking about it weeks later. The flavors are wild in a good way. I got a scoop of cold brew and a scoop of the waffle cone ice cream. AMAZING.

Great oat milk ice cream options! My sister is dairy free so she has tried many, many vegan ice creams and Rosies was definitely one of the best! The ice cream was still creamy and thick, not watery like some vegan ice creams. The flavors were interesting and delicious! I especially liked the lemon poppyseed. Unrelated to their ice cream, but they have a serious bee problem so don't plan to eat outside!

Saw a video someone posted when this place opened and I had to try it for myself. They serve handcrafted ice cream and homemade waffle cones. I'm in! I tried the Breakfast special ice cream which had chunks of candied bacon, brown sugar in a maple syrup ice cream. It was delicious! I liked that it wasn't too heavy to the point where you feel like you need a glass of water. It was creamy and filing loaded with chunks of bacon. I had my Ice cream in the cinnamon waffle cone. When you go I highly recommend their waffle cones! The staff was very friendly and the menu wasn't too overwhelming, so I wasn't panicked when my turn was up. There is a lot of space to sit after you order. Even outside so you won't feel too cramped. Highly recommend for something out of the ordinary if you are in the mood for a sweet treat!

My first time at Rosie's...what to get! There were so many delicious sounding options, but when I saw the cinnamon cookie sandwich, I was hooked. The cookies were soft (yay) and the vanilla ice cream was really good. I would love to try other things, but am not sure I won't be able to order anything but this when I go back.

Stopped in on a summer Tuesday for dessert. The place smells wonderful. I think it is the waffles they make to serve ice cream. I had a dish of the Joshalicious pistachio ice cream. Yum! If you like ice cream you need to try this place. If you don't like ice cream, this place will change your mind.

I definitely will scream for ice cream now that I've had Rosie's home made yumminess! In the heart of East Aurora , everything is made in house , including their waffle cones . I got the Bourbon toffee ice cream in one of those crispy and sweet waffle cones . I was in heaven! Although large in size , I ate every last bite . My father had the Roseberry ice cream in a waffle cone . It had a great strawberries and cream flavor . We also brought home a chocolate chip cookie ice cream sandwich for my dad's girlfriend , which she enjoyed and was very grateful. Staff is super friendly and they have a nice patio . I definitely plan on making the 20 minute drive out there again to try more of their creative flavors !

Had the honeylou ice cream today and it was amazing! So light and fresh with lavender and honey mixed perfectly together. My friend had the bada bing bada bourbon and loved hers, as well.

Delicious is an understatement for this ice cream! I definitely must go-to whenever you are in East Aurora! They make everything in-house and you can tell, so much flavor and so creamy! They change specialty flavors regularly, if you get a chance to try their peanut butter and jam, do itttt!! Lots of places to sit inside or outside. Plus they are dog friendly! (And they offer a doggy sundae so your pup can join in on the deliciousness!)

Simply the best! They have offbeat flavors that you don't see anywhere else. Everything I've had has been outstanding

Delicious ice cream flavors! They are not overly sweet. Well balanced. The cinnamon waffle cones are incredible! The indoor space is small but has a clean and comfortable feel and the outdoor deck is great. The staff are sweet and friendly.

This place came highly recommended from a good friend so I thought I'd try it out. It is in East Aurora which was ways away from where I live so it was a trip to get there. But it was a nice Sunday afternoon and I was craving something sweet so I ended up here. The ice cream flavors had interesting names and since I believe best desserts have nuts, I went with Joshalicious which is basically pistachio ice cream with pistachios in it. The quality of the ice cream was very high and I instantly understood why my friend recommended it so much. It was very creamy and felt like it was made fresh just for me. It is definitely "handcrafted" and was very satisfying. The only drawback I felt for the place is the lack of interesting flavors. Everything was named very creatively but they were all basic flavors (I prefer lake effect for variety of flavors). But other than that, it gets 5/5 for the taste itself. Since it is so far from where I am, I probably won't find myself here anytime soon but if you are in the area, you should definitely check it out!

So I'm not a huge ice cream person and this place is absolutely delicious!! I really appreciate that they have dairy free products that are super good!! I also like that they have pint size options so you could take home which we did. So for my first time here I wish that the service would've been a little bit better like if they explain the flavors for example. If the employee would've told us, which was their favorite because I wanted to know more about the ice cream.. I felt like I was at a fast food place and they just wanted me to get my order and go. The ambience was beautiful and you could tell that they put a lot of detail into the location. I would definitely go back, but I wish the service would improve a little bit more.

Went after dinner for dessert for my sons birthday. All 4 of us had different flavors and they were all wonderful! My favorite was Bada Bing Bourbon! Salty Carmel, chocolate covered pretzel pieces and yummy creaminess! The waffle cones are crunchy and fresh. Ice cream is sooo creamy! Flavors are all very unique. Can't wait to go back and try more!

OMG this really is the best ice cream ever. We had a blueberry pie ice cream that was better than any blueberry pie a la mode we ever had. The chocolate was equally delicious. If you're ever in the area you have to stop by here.

The ice cream was phenomenal. Carefully crafted, artisanal. The waffle cone was fresh and delightful. The food is five star. The helpers were pleasant. The atmosphere was not in line with the village - it is adjacent to the Roycroft Campus - nor is it conductive to a sit down date. But more importantly, it was not welcoming to anyone with mobility issues. There are eight steep stairs to ascend to reach the shop. If you're wobbly on your feet at all, good luck. There is a planter at the intersection of the staircase (see picture) otherwise you're on your own. I noticed a handicapped sign pointing the way to the back of the building (isn't that special?) and a makeshift lift was located with a large, handwritten "out of order" sign attached. If you are an able-bodied family, it would be a nice place to grab an ice cream treat, with limited seating on the deck. Several patrons parked themselves on the lawn next door or on the low stone wall facing Main Street. It's confounding how this building got past the town planning and building department. A new grey shed-like building with a metal roof with a design excluding handicapped access - and back of the building access is what one would expect from an old, existing structure-- not a new building. Adding a "logo" by using the Arts and Crafts typeface doesn't quite suffice for this structure to be village approved. (Look what other new builds had to do for approval, The Irishman, CVS...) Rosie's is a great product in a sub-standard package imho. It would have been nice to see a village-inspired building at street level with interior ambiance for a year round place to enjoy their ice cream creations.