Macy’s Place Pizzeria

Macy’s Place – Genesee Location – More than 5 stars in my book! Macy’s Place has such an extensive and creative menu that it can be a little overwhelming to decide what to order—but trust me, it’s absolutely worth it. In our family, we take turns picking what to try, and so far we’ve had both boneless wings and chicken wings. The flavors we’ve tried and loved include Bourbon Chiavetta BBQ, Garlic Parm, Honey Garlic Dry Rub (to die for), Honey Hot Glaze, Mango Habanero, Wu Tang Sauce, and Sweet Red Chili Sauce. Every single one has been excellent—and there are still so many more to go! When it comes to pizza, we’ve tried quite a few: the classic cheese and pepperoni, Pepperoni Playboi (which didn't have the extra pepperoni as expected, but was still very good), Hawaiian Pizza (lacks enough toppings/way to sparse) Stuffed Crust, Nick at Nite, Bubba Kush, Nik-Fil-A, Steak and Rings and Chicken & Waffles. We’ve also had a couple more that were amazing, but there are so many options it’s hard to keep track! One night, we ordered the Nick at Nite, but were accidentally given the Nik-Fil-A. I called and they immediately offered to send a new pizza or provide a credit. I chose the credit—because honestly, the Nik-Fil-A was delicious too. Mistakes happen, and they handled it with great customer service. They’ve got a big staff, and it still feels like they could use more hands—because this place is always busy, no matter the time or day. Even so, the team is consistently kind, helpful, and patient. Bottom line: if you're a pizza lover or wing fanatic, Macy’s Place is a must-try. Creative, flavorful, and consistently great. Over 5 stars, without a doubt.

I wanted to like this. Chicken finger sub and pizza weren’t bad but I found a hair cooked in to my steak hoagie. It made me not want to eat the other stuff that I had ordered. So yeah..

Cauliflower crust pizza spotlight 🚨🚨🚨 @macysplacepizzeria is doing their thing with this gluten cauliflower crust pizza! We got the Blue Velvet pizza which is mozzarella, gorgonzola, shaved steak, arugula, and balsamic vinegar and it is hands down the best gluten free pizza I've ever had! Wow!

I enjoy Macy’s Place occasionally - my problem is their consistency with their food. The price I just paid for mediocre food is beyond me. I ordered extra cheese (double cheese) and pepperoni, wings medium extra crispy - what I received was a cheese and pepperoni pizza (barely any cheese on the outer slices and pepperoni barely there, center of pizza WET because it was barely done, medium wings wet barely crispy. My suggestion is if you order today and it’s good, don’t go back for at least 3 month because if you go the next day or the next week, THEY WILL MISS - I promise you they will. They have all these amazing sounding items, but what good is it if it’s not cooked consistently every time it’s ordered!

This Macy Place Pizzeria, I unfortunately can't rate a perfect. The staff is pretty vibrant, cool and diverse, the atomsphere is fine, like that of most pizzeria's they have a tv on, on the side to watch if you pick up your order. In today's day in age most people arent eating in pizza places like we use too. Where points get deducted from me personally is the actual Pizza. It seems as if quality highly depends on who's there. This place literally is my favorite pizza in buffalo 80 percent of the time. But out of all the times I've ordered from this place and This is where I deduct points I've had a few handful of times where I ordered expecting the same great pizza and either the crust is super hard, super mushy or the pizza got out right overcooked. It's only been a few times that happened. Typically Im so excited when I order pizza from here, but like today 10/21/25 I ordered and the pizza was like cardboard. It really is a bummer, then I feel like I need to take a break from ordering from them for awhile. Like I said if I estimated. I maybe ordered from them 90 times since I moved to buffalo 3 years ago. Of those 90 times 6 of the times I was disappointed. I still would highly recommend them to anyone, just beware you may have 1 of those days.

I ordered chicken wings online from Macy Pizzeria at 4:00 PM for a 5:30 pickup. I arrived at 5:28 and was told it would be another 5-7 minutes - my order wasn't actually ready until 5:50. The wings themselves were decent, but the salt & vinegar ones had an extreme amount of salt. On top of that, the place seemed to be run by very young staff who were blasting inappropriate music while customers were waiting. Overall, the food was okay, but not worth the inconvenience or the unprofessional atmosphere. I would never order there again.

I ordered 3 sheet pizzas and 50 wings for a party & 2 boxes of pizza were completely burned. Half of the wings were burned as well. Very disappointing.

I've ordered from here a few times now for myself and my coworkers since I work nearby, and every single time, the food has been absolutely amazing. The quality and flavor are consistently top-notch. We did one pickup order, and the staff was super polite and friendly. Walking in was a whole vibe — they were playing music from my generation, which definitely added to the great experience. If they keep hitting on all cylinders like this, they’ll be getting plenty more business from me. Highly recommend!