Riley's Sandwich Co.

The service was quick and the process was easy. I’m very disappointed in the portions of meat on the sandwich. I’ve seen a plethora of pictures of items on their menu and they all had substantially more steak on the sandwich. I ordered the Kensington Oakland. There was so little steak on the sandwich that I couldn’t actually taste it, but the bun was great. The sandwich was warm and the other ingredients were fresh. There was an excessive amount of mozzarella cheese on the sandwich so much so I couldn’t taste any other flavors in the sandwich. It was excessive, and frankly it was ridiculous. Maybe they were having a bad day, but look at the pictures and posting you can see for yourself.

This place screams great memories. The dogs are all friendly like their owners. The customer service was beyond rewarding. You felt so accepted because everyone called you and your dog by their names. Almost like you are wearing invisible name tags. The drinks are so good and consistent. I love a place that makes the drinks the same every time. I will be telling all my friends with dogs about this place.

I used to love Riley's in the 3rd Ward. Right across the street from my offices. Very good sandwiches, that weren't boring. However, today I am waiting for my pick up order for 10 minutes and witnessed one of their chef's blow his nose with his gloves on and didn't change his gloves. Tough thing to witness, obviously I walked straight out, no food. Done with them. I attempted to call but kept getting the Shorewood location number, no other way on their website to contact. So unfortunately needed to communicate this to them in a review.

Love the sandwiches!!! Crazy that it's closed 4 days a week though! I know there has been staffing issues but it's been so long now, years. No tables or place to eat it with the exception of a small window bar in the dog supply shop.

I have been to Riley's 3x, and each time it gets better and better. First of all, the owners are as sweet as can be and work their tails off! The food and cocktails are top notch, both in quality and diversity of choices. The entire team at Riley's makes both humans and canines feel extremely welcome. I'm so glad my gal, Sweet Pea, has the luxury of this joint just a 10 minute walk from home. A win for the Third Ward and surrounding communities.

We've been to Rileys a couple times. Sandwiches are amazing, staff is friendly and helpful, and being pet friendly is a major plus. Not a lot of room for dining in, but they have bartop space indoors and a few tables out on the sidewalk in the summer. I'd never let the limited seating prevent me from stopping. I'd recommend this place to anyone and everyone! A must stop when in Shorewood!

I had the steak & avo sandwich. This was hands down the best sandwich I’ve had in my life. I could eat that green sauce on anything. Steak was cooked perfectly, bread was Devine. I could tell this was made with high quality ingredients. I encourage everyone to go visit Riley’s! I will be back, and will be ordering a full Sammy next time. 💕

We got the steak and avocado one and I'd say this is probably the second best sandwich I've ever had and I've had a lot >.> The meat was super tender (falling apart vs having to tear it apart), the sauce was tasty and the bread tasted very fresh.

This is the coolest idea EVER! It's a pet store AND a restaurant! Hold on, hold on. Don't get grossed out. Let me explain. The restaurant is fully carry out and dog friendly. They legit have dog food items in the menu including Pete's Pops dog popsicles. The kitchen has a completely different space and ventilation system than the pet store. To order food in person you walk inside and place your order at a tablet. For this reason, they do not accept cash. Then, when your food is ready a kitchen staff person brings it to you all boxed and bagged up. So, where do you wait for your to-go order? In a pet store called The Milwaukee Dog Club! Yes! ‍ They have dog food, treats, a toy library, toys and more. Ohh, they even have a photo booth to take pics of your puppy dog! It's so cool! Now, for the food. Hunty, it's good! I had the wings and HOMEMADE ranch sauce! The ranch is fire! That means super good and tasty if you're not up on the lastest lingo. I also had an Italian salad which was also very tasty. You should go here! Its a great place to buy dog products and food. It's a fun outing with your pup. It's a cool place to go if you don't have a dog but you want to get cuddles and pets from another dog. It's the place to go for tasty food! You'll dig it like I did, no doubt.

I've been to Riley's downtown location, but this was my first time swinging by the Shorewood spot. Such a great concept! I'm not even a dog owner, but love this shop for those who are. They have lots of treats, eats, and toys for pups, who are of course welcome in-store. Beyond their doggie mission, they provide insanely good sammies. I ordered ahead online, as this place is takeout-out only. There were three of us and we decided splitting two large sandwiches would do because they are very generous portions. Which is something to note because their prices are definitely high. So though I wouldn't treat myself here too often, I'll say you do get what you pay for in quality and quality. Absolutely loved the bbq chicken. The bbq sauce itself was perfectly tangy, the chicken was plentiful, and the onion, slaw, and melty mozz cheese was all a perfect combo. We also got the steak Kensington which I thoroughly enjoyed as well. You'll need to be a horseradish fan to like this one because that was the main spread. Along with that was lots of well-cooked steak strips, parm, mozz, onion, and sautéed mushrooms. The bread they make their sandwiches with is so good too. Very quality with a soft inside and crunch on the outside. Beyond their 25+ sandwiches, you can also find chicken wings, salads, snacks and drinks here. Go get it!

Stopped in the Shorewood location to try for the first time. Seating is limited to a couple of barstools and a ledge in the window, and some outdoor tables. Of course not a problem if you're eating alone. The employee was very nice, explained that everything is ordered by yourself using the iPad followed by payment and then they bring your order out to you. I ordered the Buffalo Chicken Sandwich at it was stuffed with fresh ingredients and so flavorful. That comes at a cost, but well worth it. If looking for a quick bite it's a good place to stop, if you decide to try and eat in the car I suggest you request extra napkins, you'll need them. I'm looking forward to trying more of the menu.

Fun variety of high quality sandwiches. While the sandwiches are pricier, it is so worth it. Big portions and wish we could've tried every option! Our favorite was the jerk chicken.

Instagram isn't the most reliable source for everything, but it's usually right about local food. The buzz on Riley's is strong. Dog-friendliness is the "novelty factor" but people go back again and again for the sandwiches. How good are the sandwiches? Good enough to merit the hype. For my own part I tried the chicken aji verde, with avocado and Peruvian aji verde sauce. It was 4:00 and I hadn't eaten a full meal all day, so I got a large. It was a substantially-sized sandwich, but I didn't leave feeling overly full. Also I added the house pickles because I believe in doing so when given the opportunity. They were fresh and tangy. and a little sweet. I had a cookie, not pictured, that was delicious as well. Besides all the treats for dogs, Riley's is notable for a nice selection of vegetarian sandwiches. Emphasis on selection. Several feature roasted cauliflower with different accoutrements. Others are based around portobello mushrooms. I had my eye on the buffalo cauliflower and will probably try it next time. But the main reason to visit Riley's is the super nice people. It's obvious that they love all the dogs that come in and that they care about the quality of the food. The sandwich prices are a little higher than surrounding businesses' but the quality of the ingredients shows and they're transparent about it with the customers. Don't snooze on this place, and bring your dog if you have one.

A really great sandwich shop! Ingredients were super high quality and it is SUCH a cute shop. I had the Cajun Chicken, which was delightful, but it was pretty onion heavy. I like onions but it was even a bit much for me, so if you're not an onion person maybe something else! Also huge portions, I made 2 meals out of it.

If every business had the same business model as Riley's, the world would be a better place. Customer service and food are really above and beyond. The owners take care to remember their customers and add a friendly note or small freebie when they can. Prices might be higher than you're used to seeing, but it's because they take care of their employees and the food quality is excellent. Also, the sandwich portions are huge. If you're in the mood for something lighter they have a couple different kinds of toasts - hanna toast and jade toast, both really good. For your sweet tooth, don't skip the s'morewich!! Keep an eye out for new sandwiches and salads - they roll out every once in a while and they're always unique and tasty. Most recently I tried their jerk chicken sandwich - organic chicken breast, spicy house jerk sauce, roasted cinnamon pineapple, avocado and roasted red onion. Did you catch that in there? ROASTED CINNAMON PINEAPPLE. Yes, that's right. Amazing. And I'm still wishing every day that chips and queso were healthy for me because it's so, so good here and I never want to stop eating it.

Saw it on Instagram and decided to give it a try. There are a couple of things that I really like about this place: 1. This is the cutest sandwich shop in Milwaukee!!! Bright and clean with lots of dog related decors. 2. Online ordering system is so convenient and the service is on time! Love restaurants that provide online ordering to save customers' time. 3. Yummy and fresh sandwiches. Although the price seem high for just one sandwich on the menu - there is a reason for that - the portion size is big! We got the Steak Philly and Jerk Chicken sandwiches and Lumpia City - 5 Cheese Mac Rolls. The sandwiches were already nicely cut in half and wrapped well so we shared them. We honestly enjoyed both sandwiches. Particularly we loved the Jerk Chicken because it's spicy and flavorful! 4. The owner is so friendly. 5. Street parking is not bad at all. * Bonus: they have a rewards program and collecting points is very easy. We can't wait to try the rest of the menu!

Lunch for Days I was in awe when I first saw their sandwiches on Instagram and knew I had to make a trip "up north" to see it with my own eyes. These are clearly high quality. Great bread. Great ingredients and the sandwich is STUFFED with goodness. I've ordered online twice now and they were ready before I arrived. The storefront is perhaps a bit sterile right now but I blame that on Covid. They've got outside seating which is super handy too. Each 'wich has got me covered for two days worth of lunch. They are just so good it's hard not to devour it all!

I discovered Riley's by following Brute Pizza on Intagram. They posted a very tasty-looking sandwich of Riley's on their story one day. Since sandwiches are one of my favorite foods, I had to check it out! I love that you can bring dogs inside and take a photo of them in front of the dog wall. They even have a little box of dog toys. There are a few items you can order for your pup too! (Popsicles from Pete's Pops and a chicken/veggie mixture). Although my dogs did not come with, I brought them home the chicken/veggie mixture and they loved it. Two small containers for $4.50. I got the steak kensington sandwich and a Third Space Frog Weis beer (light and fruity). The sandwiches are a bit pricey at $16, but they're huge. Two meals for me. The sandwich itself was really good. The meat was tender and cooked nicely. My only complaint was that it was a bit heavy on the garlic spread. My friend got the steak & avo sandwich which he enjoyed. We both especially liked the green Peruvian sauce on it. My fiance got the chicken Philly. It had a cheese sauce on it that was delicious. Everyone agreed the food was great, the service was awesome, and we will be back!

I went to visit this restaurant for the first time today, almost all of the reviews a red were claiming how wonderful the food is and how much they liked it. I can only tell you my opinion, and I'll share a few pictures with you. The roll is terrific. It's warm, and a light crunch on the top and soft in the middle. However, my biggest complaint is that there was hardly any steak on the sandwich. It wasn't consistent with many of the pictures that I've seen online, including their own website . I may give this place one more chance, however, if it is the same as the first one, I have, I will not be back ever. A couple of the pictures are mine and I'm going to include a couple other pictures that are posted online. I'm certain you'll be able to tell which ones are mine I took side shots not from the top and you can see my bite marks.

Ok can I be the first one to tell you how awesome and dog friendly this place is! Especially in the winters its nice to be able to take your dog inside and check out dog treats and things while we wait on our Sammie. The Steak Philly sandwich is so delicious and tender, I am still dreaming about it. They have a ton of locally made dog treats and dog apparel/leashes. They also had a dog selfie area setup and that was so fun to try. Definitely recommend checking out this sandwich shop. Go for the sandwich, stay for the dog treats.

The sandwiches were really good, the workers were really nice, and I love that you can bring your dogs! I will say, we went to the Shorewood location which is meant for takeout only. I'm not sure if I missed that, but it was a little bit of a letdown. If you do go to the Shorewood location and looking for somewhere to eat, bring it to Draft and Vessel or Camp Bar down the road! Both are dog friendly as well. Overall, I'll go again but will head to the 3rd ward location for a better atmosphere and a place to hang out.

Super tasty sandwiches I had seen on Instagram and had wanted to try for months... we finally made the 1.5 hour drive and tried the Kensington - Oakland style. Delicious sous-vide tenderloin, perfect texture for the bread, all packed nicely so that it was relatively easy to eat! The large was plenty of food for the two of us. While I won't be driving 1.5 hours again just for the sandwich, I would definitely stop by again when I'm in Milwaukee to try one of the other options! Probably the chicken parm or one with the green sauce :)

Fantastic, delicious sandwich! Would suggest if you've got any sort of appetite to get the full sandwich. Half would have left me a little hungry. High quality ingredients. Slightly confusing order process, as the photos for the Shorewood location show interior photos of the Milwaukee location so I thought I could go in and grab a beer while I waited for my order to go, but Shorewood is located inside a full blown pet shop with an order kiosk that sends the order behind the building to a separate space where they make the food and then bring it around the outside to the pickup area. Other than that little hiccup, the food was fantastic.

This is a pleasant enough place and I thought with the reviews I would like the sandwiches. HOWEVER, I got a cheesesteak sandwich and my disappointment is manifest. It was barely even lukewarm. The steak was high quality but everything else was almost uncooked. This includes the cheese. The sandwich was way too expensive for what I received even though the steak is tenderloin so I understand the price. I was told that everything is cooked sous vide style which is fine but without a sear and a toasty sandwich, forget it. I was hoping to like this place and find a new resource for a good sandwich. As it sits right now I just can't recommend it.

I really tried to like this establishment. I enjoy odd and quirky places- however, my sandwich and those who also ordered with me just didn't care for our food. The employee did not seem super stoked about their job and wasn't keen on helping us order through their system. When we asked where the kitchen was we discovered that the food is prepared in another building due to regulations about restaurants preparing meals near pet food. If you are looking for pet food alternatives other than chicken, beef, or pork-based, then this might be a spot you want to hit up.

Riley's Sandwich Co. is an AWESOME food stop and a must try. Their food is hearty and extremely well executed - when you eat it you can tell they are using the best ingredients (if you have ever had any of their steak sandwiches, you'll know what I mean! But all of their sandwiches truly taste so fresh and well balanced.) Their generous portions always have me thinking, "I'll save the other half of this for lunch tomorrow" and I've never successfully done so because it is so good I always end up finishing the whole thing. Jess and John really go above and beyond with Riley's Sandwich. Their food is amazing, but what really brings it home is their investment into their customers (and their customer's dogs!) My dogs love Jess and John (and the "Riley's Fave") so much that we can't walk past their store without lots of pulling towards the door. I highly recommend Riley's Sandwich Co!

It's only been a year since Riley's has been around, but boy, has it filled a sandwich-sized hole in our hearts and bellies that we didn't even know was there! Riley's is a sandwich spot for foodies, dog parents, dog lovers, and a dog's paradise! Bomb sandwiches + superb customer service + chance sighting of some regulars who are part of Riley's Pack and featured on the wall - it's always such a pleasant experience! And Riley's is the rare instance where the quality and taste of the food matches, nay, ~surpasses~ the social media game (which is incredibly strong). The sandwiches: I've said it before and I'll say it again. What takes a sandwich from good to EXCELLENT? A flavorful filling is of course a must, but what makes a sandwich next level is the attention paid to the bread sandwiching that filling. You've got to have good bread. It's imperative! And Riley's understands the assignment! It's a crusty but still soft bread, lightly toasted before stuffed to the gills with delicious and hearty goodness! They sous vide cook their proteins which makes for moist (sorry) and flavorful steak and chicken. The spicy giardiniera is indeed spicy (medium to hot) but my god - I'm going to have to ask them to jar it up for me because I need that on everything I eat! So flavorful, not overly oily, al dente veggies, clean heat. Perfection. And the vegetarian and vegan sandwiches are NOT an afterthought. My veggie/vegan friends LOVE their sandwiches and might go there weekly. The corned beef reuben on rye. My absolute favorite sandwich so far is unfortunately a seasonal. Can every month have St. Patrick's Day?! Hope they bring it back next year, and don't sleep on it! Steakin' Bacon - such a wonderful amount of steak for a steak lover with lots of other fixin's - I wish the special sauce was a little more flavorful because it gets lost with all the goodies on that sandwich. Terrible City - a little too salty for my tastes because of the beer cheese + dill pickle chips combo. But I'm a salt-sensitive flower. Cajun Chicken - def has that smokey vibe I look for in cajun-style. Steak & Avo - I wish the aji verde was also a little bolder - maybe more cilantro and garlic, more of a chimichurri style, but only because it's trying desperately to shine on a stage of standouts. Oh, and there's homemade Riley's Fave - organic chicken and veggies - so that your doggo has something special to eat too! My dog is a diva and very picky, and she gobbles Riley's Fave up like I haven't fed her in days. The venue: It's a bright, clean space with just a few areas to sit - one bartop along the window with 4 stools, and two long benches. You can order at the counter or on the toast app. The kitchen is hidden in the back (with its own HVAC system) so there is usually 1-2 runners who bring orders that are ready to the customer. The whole place is so instagrammable, including a changing photo backdrop, and my favorite detail is and will always be Riley's Pack: The Wall of Fame featuring all the canine regulars. The service: Every employee genuinely seems to love their job, and they LOVE the dogs. Service with a smile - a lot goes a long way! Giving back: The owners have such kind hearts and they've been featuring a charity every month with a chance to win free sandwiches for a month with every donation. They feature local artisans for dog-related swag that I literally have to tear myself away from because I want all the things! All in all, you can't go wrong with Riley's, and John and Jessica deserve every success! Can't wait for Riley's Social House to open soon!

How to win over this Milwaukee foodie's heart: make your establishment dog friendly and serve up some delicious food. Riley's is doing just that. I dragged my husband and a couple of friends and of course we brought our pups. The place is super cute with a photo booth and a small area featuring goods from local MKE businesses. The sandwiches were huge and SO good! I got the Philly Steak- the meat to cheese ratio was perfect and the sandwich itself was super tasty! I would definitely recommend stopping by and of course, you must bring the pups!

Amazing. We were on a baseball stadium roadtrip and spent the day in Milwaukee. I was searching online and found this place highly recommended, so glad we stopped. The steak sandwich caught my eye and it did not disappoint. I love horseradish, but a couple bites were a little too heavy and made me tear up. Slight reduction in that spread and it would've been the best sandwich I'd ever had, still top 5. Keep up the great work!

Everyone at Riley's was so nice! The food was great and there are several vegetarian options. Definitely recommend the buffalo cauliflower sandwich.

Awesome variety in sandwiches. The steak and kimchi is by far one of the best sandwiches I've ever had. The aji veggie is amazing for those who don't eat meat. I've yet to have a sandwich there that disappoints.

The steak sandwich with horseradish sauce is incredibly good. Every aspect, including the bread, is top notch! Nice to have a super delicious sandwich place in the area.

Absolutely delicious! Sandwiches are on the large side, so you may have leftovers...however, you'll look forward to eating them later! The bread seems like a french baguette with a crisp bite and warm, soft interior. Perfect. I'm a big fan of Potbelly's, so take it as a compliment...this reminds me a bit of that, but Riley's has much higher quality ingredients, more adventurous sandwiches, better preparation, local charm, and personable staff. Can't wait for their new location in the 3rd Ward!

We met the owners before they opened the restaurant at Third Space Brewing Company. Their passion for dogs, sandwiches, and drink is undeniable. The couple is so warm and inviting, and so is their sandwich shop! Their shop is an experience - with the photo booth and all of the cute dogs around to say hi to! The gourmet sandwiches are SO good. Definitely a must to visit here!

This place rocks. They take quality ingredients and turn it into quality food. The sandwiches are large so bring a friend or two to share. Better yet being three and split a couple different because it is hard to choose just one. The Steak and Avo is my favorite and what I ordered today. Split the sandwich with my spouse. We also shared a salad. For the kids, grilled cheese sandwiches. Sorry, didn't think to stop and take any pics. I was too consumed consuming my food. I am putting this place in my rotation. Next up, Terrible City.

This place isn't a gimmick and they serve a serious sandwich game. The 15$ price tag starting is well worth it as every order is loaded on heavy with quality ingredients. You can easily get 2 meals out of one sandwich. The good fillings aside, the real highlight for me was the bread. Great flavor. Just the right bite and chewiness that's lightly toasted. The atmosphere was very wholesome and they are nice dog loving people that will make you and your dogs feel welcome.

First visit today. They have an impressive list of sandwiches. Sometimes that's not a good thing because trying to be all things to all people means a lack of focus and mediocre results. Not here! These are huge sandwiches with more filling than bread. And the bread is good quality. Come hungry. If you are a fan of jerk chicken, you're going to be pleasantly surprised by their version. Just enough heat to be interesting and not enough to overshadow the flavor of the spices and condiments. Wow! Get you some!

The sandwich was truly amazing! However, this is a storefront with seating for about 4 along the front window. Recommended for take out only.

It was delicious! The place is very charming and the owner was very friendly. I love that you can bring your dog in with you!!

Suck it Arby's. Riley's got the real meats! Soooo good, soooo nice, and those buns hun.

Highest quality of sandwiches - even higher quality of service. So yourself a favor and get to Riley's Sandwiches A.S.A.P. You won't regret it.

Traveling for work and choose Riley's after a local recommended. Awesome choice, sandwiches were made fresh, tasted delicious and friendly quick service. I was only sorry I did not have my grand pup for the adventure! Dog friendly, complete with water bowl, toys and menu items for your furry friends!

The cutest little shop! Super good sandwich's and great dog treats. The sandwich's are pretty expensive but taste amazing! totally recommend, it's also gluten friendly!

Friendly service and great sandwiches. We will definitely be back here. They were running a bit behind so even gave us complimentary cookies

Delicious, need to come back and try every sandwich. Also had the chips and guacamole and Brussels sprouts salad. Recommend everything

Stopped by on a whim. Heard about it through a couple of friends and I have to say I was not disappointed!! Wow! Just really well excited sandwiches with high quality ingredients. Packed full of flavor and that bread, oh that bread is just delicious. I didn't get a picture because I ate too fast. Can't wait to order again and try other things on the menu!

My pup loved this place, and the sandwiches were to die for! Super yummy, great customer service. Can't wait to be a regular customer and try more products!

I was charged $26 for a double steak and cheese sandwich and it was horrible. The meat was undercooked.the bread was stale. Yet they charged me over $26for a sandwich? Highway robbery.

Went for lunch had the chicken Philly and the steak sandwich not sure the name but had garlic, mushrooms and cheese and added hot peppers it was very good love the bread fresh ingredients. The place is cute they have meal option for your pup will be back

If you haven't heard about this newish hidden gem yet you need to check it out. I'm not usually a huge sandwich lover but this is one of the BEST sandwiches I've ever had. The bread had a perfect balance of crusty and chewiness and you can tell it was freshly baked. The filling was so tasty, with a twist on phillies and a cheesy inside - had the Cajun and the Kensington and both were massive. No dine in but you can get it delivered to Draft & Vessel down the street. And of course the bonus - you can bring your dog to get the full experience!

Really good food and service. Had the MKE Philly and it was delicious! As other reviewers stated the sandwich was huge. Will definitely be back

One of the best sandwiches I've ever had! Steak Kensington Oakland style with hot peppers added was delicious and huge!!! Can't wait to go back!

Great for dog lovers. Very good service. Not great food. Sandwich was large but flavorless. For the price it would have been nice to have chips or some other side option included. Drink is not included - there are ample wine and beer choices though if that is what you are looking for. One sandwich on the menu will run you over $24 (The MKE Philly). Brussel sprout salad was good but nothing to write home about - even the salad dressing was bland. I feel bad because the server was so nice. A very strange operation though - all food prepared in back and delivered through the alley. We will not be going back.

This is our go-to place! Riley's sandwiches are DELICIOUS and the owners are incredibly kind and so personable. The portions are so generous, and their tenderloin on the steak sandwiches is always cooked to perfection! This place will want you coming back time and time again - I might be addicted!!

Picked up lunch and was not disappointed! Amazing, high quality food with fresh ingredients. The Philly cheesesteak sandwich was big enough to share. The salad was also a dinner portion. Chips and guac and queso were also delicious. They have a cool photo booth inside too. Highly recommend!

This place is awesome! I got the Steak Kensington and CBR to try with some queso and chips. The portions are much larger than you'd expect, easily can eat half the sub and be satisfied. While waiting for my order I got to chat with one of the owners, you can tell the pride that has gone into getting this place off the ground! I will certainly be back and sharing with many friends :).

Great service and a really incredible sandwich! The "steak Kensington" was delicious. Our dog loved it too, she got lots of treats.