Matthew's Pizzeria

To celebrate National Pizza Day, I took my parents to check out Matthew’s Pizza in the Highlandtown area. Luckily, there was no waiting time and we got a table right away. We started with mozzarella sticks, French fries, and Bone-in Buffalo wings; the wings were the perfect crispy texture and the buffalo sauce was mild and tasty. We ordered the ‘Fiery Hawaiian’ and ‘The Great White Veggie’ pizzas; watch out for the jalapeño peppers, they’re spicy, but the pizza is so good! For a sweet finish, we had ‘cannoli’ and the star of the night, the ‘limoncello cake,’ which was very tasty, with great fluffy texture and the right amount of sweetness. They’re very popular for their crab pie. Service was attentive and outstanding overall; we enjoyed the nostalgic vibe and the quiet atmosphere.

I live nearby and somehow I haven’t heard of it! But let me clear, I will definitely be back. Amazing deep dish. I ordered the veggie option which I’d recommend, but something also tells me to stick with the classic 3-cheese pie next time. Service was fast and helpful. Around $20 for a solid meal and some leftovers.

I don't post a review on a business often but when I do, it's because I was disappointed or extremely impressed. I've had pizza from many establishments, many times because of recommendations from others. Some were better than others but most were pretty much like all of the others. My husband being from Baltimore ( I'm from Pennsylvania) he has often talked about Mathews. I never gave it much thought because when I wanted a pie, I'd always go where I knew was good. During the most recent visit, I wanted something good, something authentic. My husband suggested Mathews. I looked them up and decided to give them a go based on the pictures. Upon entering the small but not cramped dining area, we were greeted immediately by the friendly staff and our orders were taken. We ordered the Caprese Toast which was amzing and then Greektown Pizza, both of which the 2 of us shared. The toppings were simple and fresh and I could taste each one with every bite. The crust was light and crispy. I can honestly say this was by far the best pizza I have ever had. I was extremely impressed. We both left full with nothing left over (because it was so delicious). I have found my new pizza spot for when we visit Baltimore and want pizza. In fact, before we left the city to go back home to Pennsylvania, we called and ordered "The Popular" to take home to our kids. Bottom line....eating in was very comfortable, staff was extremely friendly and attentive and the food was superb. A visit here is highly recommended and a must try!!

A friend of mine recommended that I try this pizza... in my honest opinion the pizza was just ok...the crust was the star of the show, the back edge was crispy and delicious, but the pizza itself was pretty bland it definitely lacked flavor. I waited 20 minutes for an 8inch personal pizza. The pizza came out on a paper plate wrapped in paper with no pizza box It cost me 20 bucks for a 8 inch personal pizza and a 20oz soda....

Great food. Knowledgeable staff. Casual, comfortable. Exactly what you expect in a great pizzeria. They are rightly famous for their crab pizza. Crust is lighter than you’d expect. Flavors were subtle and balanced. A must try place if you’re in Baltimore.

Matthew's is my favorite neighborhood pizzeria with only one other that I normally consider. I admit it has been awhile since I've been here, but I've not been in the neighborhood in a long time. I found it comforting that the pizza and the service have not changed. I have never been disappointed when I choose to enjoy food from Matthew's. I highly recommend that if you haven't already, give Matthew's Pizzeria a try.

Matthew's Pizzeria is a Baltimore classic, offering dine-in 8" and 10" pies that are perfect for lunch or dinner. The classic mozzarella and white pies are both delicious. I'm a New Yorker but will be back!

The Myth, The Legend, and Totally Worth It We finally stopped into Matthew's Pizza around 5:30 p.m. on a Friday — the place was packed, which we took as a good sign. After a short 20-minute wait, we got our pizza, and let me tell you, it did not disappoint. Easily one of the top three best pizzas I’ve ever had. The crust was perfectly baked, the ingredients tasted incredibly fresh, and the cheese was rich and flavorful , you can tell they take pride in every pie that leaves their oven. If you're a true pizza lover, this spot is a must-visit. Highly recommend.