Izhan P.
Google
I have never been treated so poorly by a company that prides itself on “heritage” and “craftsmanship.”
I received a pair of Cheaney Penny Loafers (brand new, in the original box) as a gift from a friend. Before I even wore them, I went to the Spitalfields Cheaney store because they felt tight. The older salesman there — who knows me personally — reassured me they would “stretch with wear” and even convinced me to buy a £60 shoe tree to help the process.
I trusted their advice.
The result? Severe pain, deep shoe bites, and bleeding injuries to my feet after wearing them — something no customer should endure from shoes at this price point.
When I contacted Cheaney, I was polite, patient, and followed every instruction they gave me — including sending the shoes back to their factory at their request. Weeks later, they dismissed my injury, denied their own staff’s advice, and even claimed they “couldn’t confirm” the shoes came from them (despite having already offered to stretch them). They refused to offer any replacement or meaningful resolution, hiding behind “no receipt” as an excuse.
To make matters worse, one of their employees even looked me up on LinkedIn during the dispute — which is not only irrelevant but unprofessional and creepy.
Cheaney had every opportunity to show integrity and stand behind their brand values. Instead, they’ve shown me that once they’ve taken your money (or your gift-giver’s), you’re on your own — even if their own advice leads to injury.
If you’re considering buying from Cheaney, know this:
• If there’s any problem, you’ll get policies instead of care.
• If you’re hurt by their product, they’ll deny responsibility.
• If you don’t have a receipt (e.g. it was a gift), they’ll treat you like you’re lying — even with evidence.
I’ve spent years admiring this brand. After this shameful experience, I would never recommend them to anyone. There are plenty of shoemakers out there who value their customers — sadly, Cheaney is not one of them.