Daniel B.
Yelp
I ate at Sam's BBQ1 years ago when it used to be known as Sam and Dave's BBQ1. It also used to only be a takeout joint, but now they've opened a dine-in space two doors down from the previous and still existing space. This was a much needed addition as I'm sure many customers were occasionally deterred by the takeout-only option.
While Sam stayed here, the other two Daves (there was a Sam, Dave, and Dave) opened their own restaurants. One Dave opened Dave Poe's BBQ across town while the other Dave opened up Community Q in Decatur. Both have dine-in seating, so perhaps Sam opened up his dine-in space as a response. Unless you live in the area, BBQ1 is not easy to get to from any of Atlanta's major highways. It's too bad for the many Atlantans who don't live or work up this way because BBQ1 is pretty good.
Out of all the BBQ joints I've eaten at, I've never seen so many trophies proudly displayed inside one restaurant. At a recent Friday lunch, Sam was ringing up customer after customer by himself. The space inside the dining area is comparable to Dave Poe's BBQ, maybe a bit bigger. It consists of a combination of booth, table, and bar-style seating along the windows. This is one of those restaurants where you stand in line, place your order, and take a number. The servers bring your food out to you. You grab your own drinks (fountain drinks), silverware, napkins, and BBQ sauce. This place fills up fast and seating can get tight. You can tell they tried to fit as many seats inside this space as comfortably as possible.
Sam offers two kinds of BBQ sauce for you: KC-style (tomato-based) and NC-style (vinegar-based). It's nice that this restaurant offers North Carolina-style BBQ sauce as I haven't found too many places in Atlanta that offer it (Heirloom Market is one of the other ones). The menu offers traditional BBQ favorites including pulled pork, brisket, chicken, sausage, and ribs. Sides include Southern staples such as Brunswick stew, mac and cheese, fried okra, green beans, slaw, etc. With the BBQ, you can order sandwiches or plates. The plates come with two sides and in two sizes: "lunch" and "dinner." The lunch portions are smaller and less expensive (lunch plate is $8.95 and dinner is $11.95). The food comes out surprisingly fast.
Items I've tried include the beef brisket, cole slaw, baked beans, mac and cheese, fried okra, fried pickles. My favorite item to get at almost any BBQ restaurant is pulled pork or beef brisket. I almost always get the brisket here because it's very good. It's sliced into small pieces and tender with a good smoky flavor.
Their mac and cheese is among the best. Large noodles, very cheesy, though sometimes a bit greasy. That's what helps make it good, though. The slaw is comparable to intown rival Williamson Bros. because of its muted, not-as-sour taste. The texture is completely different, however. The fried pickles are lightly battered and salty. They are not served with any type of dressing or dipping sauce. Sam also offers rum cakes, which are quite delectable. Soft, moist, and melt-in-your-mouth good. Try one - they're located next to the cash registers.
So, kudos to Sam for opening a dine-in space. Now he just needs to move closer to town!