Jonathan Flint
Google
DO NOT DONATE TO THIS LIBRARY. THEY WILL NOT DO WHAT THEY SAY THEY WILL DO.
I am a San Diego native and a local business owner. I donated a rare 1847 volume with double fore edge paintings to the San Diego Public Library to reunite it with its missing mate, which had been in their collection since the 1970s. From the start, Matthew Nye, Special Collections Manager, assured me that the library’s marketing department loved the story and ‘definitely wanted marketing to be involved.’ On June 17, 2025 he even asked me to write the donor’s story in my own words so their team could publish it. I submitted the text and offered full cooperation.
Despite months of patience and repeated follow ups, nothing was ever shared. On August 5, 2025, Mr. Nye admitted in writing that he was ‘rather embarrassed by this delay,’ confirmed that marketing had been ‘so excited and touched by the whole story,’ and said he had already escalated it to their supervisor. Still, nothing was done.
This library received my donation, my written story, and my trust. They failed to honor every promise. I had intended to donate additional very old books, including volumes with fore edge paintings, but after this experience I am not only hesitant, I am fearful. The photos with this review show me turning the book over to the library.
Do not trust their promises. I may be open to updating the review if the library finally honors its commitments.
Photos of me turning the donated book over to the San Diego Public Library in June 2025. This image simply documents the donation itself, which the Library later declined to publicize despite written commitments.