Mary S.
Yelp
We were here for Thanksgiving and were sorely disappointed both with the food and service. The lunch took 2 1/2 hours with long times between courses in a restaurant that wasn't even full. The reservation form asked if anyone in the party had food sensitivities, to which I indicated one of us had a seafood allergy. The waiter at first said they couldn't accommodate her, although they eventually did. Why ask if you aren't going to make accommodations? The bartender took forever to recognize that we were sitting in front of him at the bar. The soup and salad started out really yummy, but the entrees (steak and salmon both) were very mediocre. The Thanksgiving turkey entree was very bland and unappetizing. I'd been to another Sarabeth's and had a great experience. This experience, however, has turned me off forever and I'll never go back. I had high hopes and this ended up being the worse meal of our whole trip to NYC.