Scully’s Restaurant

We’re from out of town and felt very welcomed here! We were a party of 8 with 4 toddlers. Received great service! Our waitress was friendly, patient & attentive. Food was delicious and the mimosas were perfect. Highly recommend!

Fresh, locally sourced ingredients made what would have been a good breakfast into an amazingly delicious experience! We had two specials, the salmon Benedict and the gyro skillet. Both were beyond expectations. Also, the bloody Mary’s are made from scratch with various salted rim options (I recommend the bacon salt). Lastly, and certainly not least; quick, friendly and super attentive service from Sam was superb! The views of Silver Lake serve serve as the cherry on top of this experience. Highly recommended!

Who knew!!! What a gem of a place right in my backyard. I am kicking myself for not trying this place sooner. Friendly, attentive service and GREAT FOOD! The Polpetta meatball appetizer was without a doubt the best meatball I have ever had. Moist, flavor-packed with such fresh tasting marinara. Everything here is fresh, local food, and hand prepared. The bacon wrapped meatloaf was simply amazing. No dried out loaf here. Nice charred crust, but juicy inside and packed with flavor. The veggie side (summer squash, zucchini, and potatoes) tasted like it just came out of the garden. I can not wait to come back and try more of the menu!

First off, our only complaint: No silverware, even after the soup was served. There were 9 people in the entire restaurant. No excuse, my friend. Otherwise... Great view of the lake. Comfortable seating. Clean environment. Soup was great. Fresh potatoes and cheese in a soup that's not as thick as your normal cream soups. Wonderful tasting Long Island Ice Tea. Smooth Pan seared chicken with marsala sauce... perfection Again, fresh mashed potatoes. Mild chicken wings were fresh but a little spicy for the wife. Don't let that scare you. Limited parking so get here early.

Excellent breakfast spot! Great menu options — love that they use fresh (sometimes local) ingredients. The staff is always friendly, and the cafe is cute, clean, and has a warm, welcoming vibe. Parking can be a little tricky, but there are usually spots available on the side road.

We love finding new and unique places to dine especially for breakfast/brunch. We discovered Scully's by chance taking a Saturday morning drive and searching breakfast restaurants in the area. I'm so glad we decided to give it a try. This place is so great. It's a smaller restaurant with a modern farm to table vibe and delicious food selections. It's also located across from Silver Lake so you get a nice view out the large front windows. The staff is super friendly and efficient. The menu has a lot of unique options. We ordered the Scully bites which are homemade fried donut holes dusted with powdered sugar to start. I mean a breakfast appetizer is so fun and these were heavenly. We also ordered the country fried steak which was so delicious. This was not a premade patty. This was tenderized sirloin steak hand dredged and fried with a wonderful homemade sausage gravy. My husband ordered the homemade corned beef hash - so tender and flavorful. Both entrees were amazing. I highly recommend this restaurant if you are in the area and I also recommend seeking it out if you're not in the area!

Very friendly environment. Beautiful view of the lake through big windows. The food was superb, local and fresh. Everything was exactly as we ordered and absolutely delicious!! We will continue supporting this place!!

I went to this small place in silver lake called scully's not one car was in the lot, seen them on FB. Went in on a Thursday great gal served us, all the food was fabulous and the drinks were great. I came back on Saturday with my son and daughter-in-law. Again not 1 car in lot and again amazing food and drink. Met one of the 2 chefs, Tim nice guy I Complimented his food. Stop in and try an appetizer or a cocktail. The bruschetta appetizer and pork tenderloin medallion with cherry sauce was amazing.

Didn't feel like driving to Lake Geneva or Antioch for a good cup of coffee and a bite to eat. So, I used my trusty Yelp! only to discover a revamped menu at Scully's in S.Lake. Great choice!

A very warm and inviting establishment. The waitress, Anita was very nice and super attentive. I ordered the fish fry. First time I had a hand battered one. It did not disappoint. The whole meal was absolutely delicious. I highly suggest eating there and ask for Anita to be your waitress. Although I didn't order breakfast, they are famous for their chicken fried steak. I must make it a point to stop here for breakfast. Very nice view of Silver Lake. Very reasonable prices and plenty of parking.

Stopped by for their Friday Fish Fry, something new that they have added to their menu several months ago. It is now one of our top 5 places for fish fry. They offer lightly breaded or beer battered. Both were crunchy and tasty. The beer battered version avoided the gumminess that sometimes happens. You have a choice of hand cut fries or house made potato pancakes. The fries were thin and crispy. The pancakes were very crispy on the outside and creamy on the inside and well seasoned. Our waitress was very friendly and helpful, making the evening more pleasant. Scully's is not a large place, which does give it a warm and welcoming atmosphere. It was a snowy evening so the dining room was not very full. I highly recommend that you give them a try, you won't be disappointed. Sorry we forgot to take some pictures.

Walking in it is so loud and I mean loud!! It is a small place but cute. If you are not in a rush and want to WAIT 45 minutes to get your food then by all means this is the place. They had a ton of servers. The kitchen is either VERY short staff or something because for a Friday night with a very short menu they should have been cracking out orders . That was not the case. Was it an off night? Not sure but I know I will not be back. The shrimp was absolutely excellent and huge size. The fish.. I have had better but then again I was spoiled for 5 years living in the West Coast.

Finally made it! Fiirst time here since the opening! Fantastic service and the quality of food is five star in our book. My wife and I recently changed our eating habits and the daily menu and portions fit right in. All quality and mostly fresh, local ingredients. Thank you for being here and may you make many memories in Silver Lake.

Great breakfast place. I hesitate to even post this because I know they are already busy. But Scully's deserves a serious shout out. This was our first visit. Our server, Amber, was very friendly and she shared helpful information about the menu. Everything is locally sourced and made from scratch. Fresh food made with the best ingredients. I had the corned beef hash which was a big slab of the most tender corned beef with roasted tomatoes, onions and potatoes. Finished with two farm fresh eggs. My wife had the traditional eggs and bacon with hash browns. We also ordered a short stack of mixed berry pancakes which were awesome and scratch made. All their meat products come from Wilson's meats in Elkhorn. So naturally we had to drive there after breakfast and load the truck up with all sorts of "provisions." Also, they make their own epic Bloody Mary with pickle vodka and this great spicy salt. Truly excellent. Fun spot. Definitely coming back with my three sons.

Food was SO good! Incredible flavor and the server staff is so friendly! Great price with large portions. The atmosphere is also very nice, great views of the lake and looks nicely remodeled inside. I would definitely recommend!

Service was great, ambiance was wonderful. Food was all fresh and cooked to perfection. Simply delicious.!! We will definitely be back!! This restaurant is a hidden gem in Silver Lake Wi.!!

Amazing food. Warm atmosphere. Expected just sandwiches Found outstanding dinners. what a find!

Joe and Staff helped with a party we hosted there. The food was amazing and the staff took care of everyone graciously. Joe went above and beyond and delivered more than expected. Can't thank Joe and his team enough for a great night!

I was too hungry and excited to eat, I forgot to take a picture. We showed up randomly as a group driving through. Food was delicious! We all tried different things: chicken salad wrap, corned beef hash, biscuits and gravy, and chef special. Bloody Mary was really good as well! Service was great! Owner even chatted with us a bit to explain the homemade ingredients and items sourced locally. We really loved it and wished we could come back more often (but aren't local). Definitely a hidden gem.

My husband and I ate at Scully's in Silver Lake Friday night February 21, 2025 and it was a severe disappointment. My husband's fish he said tasted good but was not served hot and my cheeseburger and fries were cold! I ordered a cheeseburger with cheddar cheese and pickles NO lettuce tomato or onions. The picture on the menu shows a nice patty and the description on the menu and the website claims it is made of a combination of brisket, sirloin, and ground chuck. The patty I was served was so thin and had no flavor! It was served with a half of an onion sliced in large slices and a woody tomato which I specifically said no to. The waitress didn't even try to offer to take off the charges for the extras I didn't order! We paid $45 for a burger I barely ate 1/4 of and the fish which again my husband said tasted good but was not hot. I didn't want to complain because the place was busy and when our waitress asked us how the food was, I told her about the tomato and onion I didn't ask for and she simply said sorry! We will not be back and we DO NOT recommend dining here.

Went for brunch with family and it was amazing! The waitress was SUPER helpful, and accommodating to our indecisive group. She made us some great drinks, and was the best waitress I've ever had. Food was great, prices were great, the place has a great atmosphere, and the owners were amazing! They home-make their Bloody Mary's, and they're to die for. Definitely will be going back when I'm in the area. Ask for Brittani!

I have been in contact with the owner over my experience, he was quite gracious and apologized for my experience at his establishment. I am willing to retract my harsh review as it seems my experience wasn't in keeping with the standards he has set for customer service. I will revisit Scully's in the future, should I be in the area again.