Chris E.
Yelp
OK I see you Serafina.
Was pleasantly surprised at how good the food was when we dropped in for a Saturday morning/afternoon brunch. Our family met up with 2 other friends on a super nice Saturday and the restaurant was very quiet when we arrived. Throughout our meal there were probably only 2-4 tables occupied. Maybe uptown restaurants get a lot more business during the evening?
During brunch hours, customers can order from the regular menu or brunch menu. After reviewing both menus, the regular menu definitely intrigued us a lot more. The brunch menu was very typical of brunch menus and we just felt we could have ordered those dishes anywhere.
Here's what I had a chance to try that our table ordered/shared:
RISOTTO PORCINI Carnaroli rice with porcini mushrooms
- OK, this dish alone would convince me to come back! This was the entree I ordered and boy was I glad I made the choice. At first, I was a bit hesitant to get this as I know some restaurants can royally screw up risotto, but Serafina does it justice and some more. In all honesty, this might have been one of the BEST risotto dishes I ever had - definitely one of the best in my recent memory. It was that damn good! It was perfectly cooked, not too soggy or dry. Major props to the chef who churned this bad boy out.
LEMON RICOTTA PANCAKES served with blueberry compote, butter and maple syrup
- The risotto already had me at 1st bite, but, my goodness, these lemon ricotta pancakes were something else. I thought the risotto was amazing until I tried these pancakes. Rarely does any food knock my socks off these days and these pancakes really blew me away. I thought I had tried some of the best pancakes in the world already at places like Clinton Street Baking Company or Cafe Luluc in Brooklyn, but, major major kudos Serafina on producing some of the finest (if not the finest) pancakes my tastebuds had ever touched. Not only was the tart, yet not too sweet flavor amazing, but the soft, fluffy texture of the pancakes highlighted by the ricotta was really something. If you ever come here for brunch, GET IT.
STEAK & EGGS eggs any style served with grilled skirt steak & French fries
- Steak & eggs is what it is, but the skirt steak was very, very, very, very good. Perfectly cooked at medium temp and super tender and juicy. Once again, one of the best skirt steaks I've had in a very long time. They hit this one right on the nail.
MARGHERITA PIZZA
- So they had to come back to Earth at some point. I didn't really get to try the pizza until it got all cold, but it was OK. Honestly, this is not a fair assessment because it did look really good when it came out, but I never had a chance to try it when it was piping hot.
This was as casual and quiet of an experience we could have at a restaurant and my expectations were quite tempered, but, boy were they exceeded. Serafina just totally turned any notion I had of it inside out and upside down for the better. The risotto, pancakes and steak & eggs were major slam dunks and there aren't many restaurants I would return to a 2nd or 3rd time because of all of the different restaurants at our disposal in NYC, but Serafina would WITHOUT A QUESTION be one of them I would go back to in a heartbeat.