Captain Z.
Yelp
Serafina Vino e Cucina 30 Broad is a re-imagined concept for a location they have occupied for some time in the Financial District of lower Manhattan, just one block south of the New York Stock Exchange on Broad Street.
The restaurant is absolutely beautiful and only opened less than a month ago at the end of January, I love the yellow accent color they use, which makes everything seem so bright and fun. The walls decorated with wine and champagne bottles, backlit by LED lights is a beautiful and modern touch. My only complaint about their decor is that they packed just a few too many tables into the space. At the time we visited, the restaurant was only about 25% full and the server had a difficult time reaching our table because of the space. With a full house, it could be just a bit overcrowded to fully enjoy the meal.
Christian, at the host stand, greeted us with a big smile and told us a little about the history of that location. He asked us where we wanted to sit, which is always a nice touch rather than being 'put' where they want us. The table was beautifully set, though it seemed a bit smaller than usual.
Our server came over right away to greet us and take our drink order. I ordered the Lambrusco Riserva DOP. It was perfect for that moment, not too sweet with a light effervescence.
For our appetizers, we ordered meatballs and bruschetta. The meatballs were some of the best we have had in a long time. I prefer my Italian food bold with lots of Mediterranean spices and garlic and they delivered. I would go back just for the meatballs; they were that good! The bruschetta was fresh as could be with red ripe tomatoes and fresh ribbons of basil - light and delicious.
The main courses we ordered were the Orecchiette sausage with broccoli rabe and the tagliolini carbonara. The Orecchiette Sausage dish was the star. It was not too spicy but had the depth of a good meat dish without being too 'meaty'. It was perfect. Unfortunately, the carbonara had to be sent back. I do not mean to be overly critical of the dish but the only way I can describe the tase is that it smelled like a dirty dish rag. It was unlike any carbonara we have ever had.
Sometimes things happen like this, it is not the end of the world and the way the restaurant handles a hiccup says a lot about the restaurant. They immediately offered us an alternate dish. Because the sausage dish was so good, we ordered that but decided to take it to go, which was not the fault of the restaurant. We were just running short on time. In the end the restaurant was very apologetic and wound up taking one entree off our check. They handled the issue professionally and to our satisfaction.
I want to give this restaurant a 5-star review and if I could give 4.5 stars, I would do that with no hesitation. At this time, I am rating our experience as a 4-star experience but will come back again soon and hopefully be able to submit a new 5-star review.
Bottom line - try this great new place but stay away from the carbonara.