Julia C.
Yelp
Very pleased with our Shake Shack experience. First, the cashier was super friendly. Props to him for being so pleasant and welcoming.
Boyfriend and I ordered Shake Stack $10.95, a Chick'n Shak $6.89 and ShackBurger $5.69, Crinkle Cut Fries $2.99, plus a Malted Mocha Cookies & Cream Milkshake $5.99 + $.50 for Malt.
The Shake Stack is a very thick piece of deep-fried portobello mushroom topped with a ton of melted cheese and a beef patty topped with cheese. It was really tasty, but kind of expensive. I think I could almost get all the pleasure of a Shake Stack without the beef patty -- so I might just get a 'Shroom Burger next time. Feels weird not to order beef at a hamburger place, but the mushroom was really good!
Chick'n Shack -- also delicious! Very crispy fried chicken breast, a nice thick piece.
ShackBurger was actually my least favorite? It's kind of just a normal burger, and I probably honestly prefer In N Out. Hometown favorite.
Crinkle Cut Fries were tasty, but not can't-stop-eating-them tasty. Maybe I should top it with Cheese/Bacon next time.
Malted Mocha Cookies & Cream. Ran into some issues here -- they gave my shake to someone else! As soon as my beeper started buzzing, I ran up to pick my order, and saw a shake that looked like mine being handed to someone else. I figured -- maybe we ordered the same thing? I waited about 5-10 minutes until this stranger's order was ready, when they handed her the coffee shake she had actually ordered with the rest of her food. She was understandably confused and I immediately figured out that they had given her my shake. Her name wasn't remotely similar to mine -- clearly the employee handing out orders hadn't bothered to verify either her name, number or order. And she was more apologetic than the employee who had made the mistake. It was so frustrating!
Also, the shake was very good, but since I could barely taste the malt, I probably wouldn't choose to add malt next time.