Laurie V.
Yelp
The food at Shift is exquisite, and it's clear why this is a 5-star restaurant and James Beard Award Semifinalist. What's a welcome surprise is that Shift has such a warm, comfortable and casual atmosphere.
While in Flagstaff, a realtor who knows the area well recommended Shift to us. He even said it was his "favorite restaurant anywhere!"
The restaurant has a cozy Flagstaff vacation vibe, with a woodsy-warm, casual yet trendy decor, and the food is Michelin Star quality. The menu changes slightly, but I'll bet the following (which we loved) will be there when you visit. For starters, you must order the Pickled French Fries. When the realtor mentioned it, I thought it sounded odd, but trust me--the secret sauce is delicious, and we added the House-made Ranch with truffle which I could not get enough of.
As for my entrée, I can confidently say I would never choose anything else! The Agnolotti Pasta was so amazing that I knew I had picked the right dish the moment I saw its beautiful presentation with edible flowers and smelled the wonderful Italian aroma. The homemade pasta, filled with a divine mix of white corn and ricotta, had a wonderful sweetness that was far more complex than it sounds. Every bite was elevated, especially with the luscious saffron cream sauce, soleggiati tomatoes (sun-dried), and bits of pancetta. The balance of flavors was masterful.
For those in the mood for a burger, the Poutine Burger is a highly recommended option. It was topped with cheese curds, gravy and a beautiful slaw. While I didn't try it, my friend said it was amazing.
The servers here are top-notch: polished, experienced, elegant, & friendly, and the owner is so gracious. The moment we stepped in, we were greeted with bright smiles and warm welcomes from more than one person which made us feel so special. When we left, they made us feel truly appreciated.
I can't wait to return. You really have to experience Shift to understand just how special this restaurant is, with its incredible food and welcoming atmosphere.