Jason F.
Yelp
I stopped by here earlier today with my wife and twins for lunch. We had found Shrimp City on Yelp a couple of days prior and bookmarked it, but the stars aligned for us to head here today. We arrived at the shop around 1 PM as another customer was leaving. Outside of that, we were the only customers inside. The inside of Shrimp City is clean, straightforward, and no-frills. Along one side is a long glass seafood counter showcasing fresh shrimp, oysters, clams, crab meat, and more, all clearly labeled with bright, handwritten signage. Behind the counter, a staff member was working at a stainless steel prep area. Across from that, several upright freezers are packed with frozen seafood and bait, including king crab, snow crab, crawfish, and various shellfish. One fridge even has a bold sign reminding customers not to forget their bait, offering items like shrimp, squid, and cigar minnows. There are also shelves of sauces, seasonings, and cold drinks.
For lunch, my wife and I ultimately decided on 2 pounds of XL Gulf shrimp (31-35 count). We asked to have them steamed with Old Bay and garlic butter. The lady who waited on us behind the counter was super nice, and we had a pleasant conversation with her while the shrimp steamed. After they were finished, we headed back to where we were staying to eat. The shrimp ended up being excellent. The meat was sweet, and the balance of Old Bay and garlic butter was spot on. You could taste both, but neither overpowered the other. All too quickly, we had made it through our 2 pounds of shrimp, and my wife immediately told me I should rate it a 5. If I had to go here again, the only change I would make is to have chosen the peeled and deveined shrimp they offered just to make my life easier.
The bottom line for me is that I would head back here again in the future. Our shrimp were very good, and I thought the lady working the front was nice as well.