Siciliano's Frozen Custard

Serving size is HUGE, prices are reasonable, and the staff Isabella and Abeni are absolute angels! They were super nice, answered all our questions, and even give us good recos. I ordered small and yeah two people can even share this

Yes! I recommend, and will visit again! This place is a sensory experience overload, as I told Keebie the first time I visited. "It smells pretty in here!" And it truly does. Next I became aware of the wonderful music playing in the background (something kind of slow jam, R&B, soothing). And then all the delights. Cause though Siciliano's it is not a fancy place, the cones (some of them fancy), the cup and bowl sizes, the menu options and frozen treats in the freezer section all combined to hype the experience for me. Hm, hmm, hmm! ! Next, making my selection, anticipating it and watching as it was prepared and as it wafted through the air towards me .... sigh. I'm so glad I discovered this place. And let me just say I'm the kind of person to visit an area or is new to town and will actually search for "Frozen Custard" in Google maps so I can be in the know. Yup! I'm really am glad I found this place

Great customer service. Love their frozen custard. 10000% recommend their vanilla flavor

Wow! This was the first time we had a frozen custard cone, and it was delicious! It's thicker than ice cream and really fills you up. The server was very nice and helpful and took good care of us. We had been to a restaurant earlier that served spicy food, and we needed something sweet to take that taste away. This hit the spot. This is a nice clean place. Good selection of custards. Easy parking. Wheel chair accessible parking. We will be back.

I recently visited Siciliano’s Frozen Custard and was thoroughly impressed by their delightful vanilla and cherry frozen custard. The unique and exquisite taste was unlike anything I’ve ever tried before – truly memorable. Not only was the frozen custard delicious, but the prices were also reasonable, which made the experience even sweeter. To top it off, the service was lovely; the staff made the visit a real pleasure. Highly recommend for anyone looking for a tasty treat!

Usually the staff is so nice. The ice cream is great. Maybe the Saturday evening crew is different because the handicapped space was actually littered with a bunch of bicycles laying on the ground and 4-5 boys crowded inside. If you have been there the standing space for customers is teeny. So I stood outside to order through the window. The girl waved me rudely toward the door and I pointed at the boys and she just insisted to come in. No thanks. Not going to deal with that.

We r here at least twice a week. Nobody makes the fresh waffle cones every day like they do. Their custard is delicious! Highly recommend this place.

Nice little local shop for tasty custard. They have some seats on the side of the sub shop next door. They have three custard options, vanilla, chocolate, and swirl. They also have a nice selection of sorbets. Their banana and fudge sundae was great. Their Reese's pieces, fudge, and peanut butter sundae was delicious. Their small sundae is the same size as their medium cup. I think the sundae is a better deal.

The minute you walk in you're slapped in the face with the delicious smell of fresh cones & I had the absolute pleasure of being served by Keebee at the custard shop today, and I couldn't be more impressed! From the moment I walked up to the counter, her warm and friendly smile made me feel welcomed. Keebee was incredibly helpful, patiently guiding me through the menu and offering great suggestions, which made my decision much easier. Not only was she knowledgeable, but her sense of humor and positive energy truly brightened my day. She went above and beyond by ensuring I had everything I needed and even made sure my order was perfect before I left. It's rare to find someone who genuinely cares about the customer experience as much as she does. Keebee is a true gem, and I'll definitely be back because of the amazing service she provided. Thank you, Keebee, for making my visit so memorable!

I WISH I was joking about the experience i'm about to write about because what even Let me start off by saying I got a small vanilla soft serve with rainbow sprinkles. Delicious! No complaints there. To set the scene, I was wearing eyeliner, a dark red lip, and dark casual clothes. I had a rose quartz, a hematite, an amethyst, and black tourmaline beaded crystal bracelets. Unfortunately, this is important. We walk in at like 10pm a few days ago, and the lady at the register starts asking me questions. "Are you goth?" I wouldn't consider myself that, no. "But you are spiritual right?" I said oh yeah I am! how did you know? and she tells me it's because i'm wearing "spiritual bracelets", which was a few different types of crystal beaded bracelets as I mentioned earlier, one of which had a small pentagram charm. Then she asks "so you believe in god right?", to which I reply "oh, no I don't believe in any god actually!" Mind you, the conversation has been very friendly so far and I love hearing about people's beliefs. Then she tells me "so you are not spiritual. If you are spiritual, then you have to believe in god". Now, I know this is not true because spiritually covers an extremely vast array of beliefs; my spirituality can very easily be different than my also spiritual neighbor's beliefs. After telling her no I don't believe in any gods, she says "if you don't believe in god, then you believe in the devil." At this point, I really want to leave because obviously this conversation doesn't involve me being heard, but SHE IS HOLDING MY BOYFRIEND'S CREDIT CARD STILL!! I tell her no, I don't believe in any of that, I have my own set of beliefs. Then she tells me that I don't know about what i'm wearing because I have a "jewish star" on my bracelets. My boyfriend chimes in and corrects her and tells her that it's a pentagram on my bracelet, the star of David has 6 points. It's not over yet. Then she tells me that ALL spiritual people believe in a higher being and that includes the universe. And I, trying to avoid confrontation and trying to steer this conversation so I am less uncomfortable, say "oh yeah I believe in stuff like the universe", and she says "SO you believe in god because the universe is a higher being and is god". Then she says that she's not religious but she is spiritual... and no, I didn't ask At this point, my social anxiety is through the roof, my patience is low, and my boyfriend finally has his credit card in hand again. I say "you know what, I will look into that". You think it's done, but no. She has to have the last comment and say "yeah because you can't go around wearing stuff if you don't know what it means girl!" Like.... absolutely unreal experience I cannot make this up. Keep your "spiritual bracelets" and dark red lipstick at home before coming here

Cute little spot in Hollywood Florida. I ordered the chocolate custard with chocolate crunch. You definitely get your dollars worth when adding toppings. They add toppings to the bottom of the cup as well as on top of the custard. Service was friendly and mostly young people working there. Only thing is they only have one table outside. So we just stood and ate our custard in the parking lot. I went on a Sunday night and it was decently busy with many teens and young adults coming in during the 20 minutes that we were there. They probably benefit from additional seating.

Turtle was rich and creamy! Custard is rich and smooth. Glad I don't live here, I would be here weekly. Parking is easy but you have to turn into the lot qui cc just when you see the sign. The smoke shop parking lot is right next door and we parked there. There is a concrete table to sit at to eat your treat. It isn't a big place at all. More like a hole in the wall but a good one at that. Service was spot on! Thanks ladies!

I craved ice cream today and found this spot that has been around for quite a long time. I took the "girls" for a treat. All 3 of us enjoyed it thoroughly. We had vanilla because the chocolate had not been delivered yet. I had way too many toppings on mine. Delicious but I over did it. Next time I will get half the amount. The small cup was a good size. The server was pleasant and greeted me with a smile. Parking could be challenging on a busy weekend. It's tight but there are a few spots. They share the lot with a sub shop. So, win win! Don't expect to sit down. We sat in the car and enjoyed it very much.

It has been exactly one year since my last visit here, just to found out they changed the base of the ice cream custard, what use to be a light, cloudy, creamy, taste of heaven is no more...i'll start by saying Siciliano has been here for ever, like i use to come here back when i was in high school, but everything must come to an end. I didn't try the chocolate soft serve but the vanilla is now overly sweet, yellow, eggy and icee... kind of like gelato not creamy like it use to be, so sad and disappointing. Im not going to say it's horrible but compared to the old recipe one this one is no good. With sadness i payed my goodbyes.

Amazinggggg every time. Service is quick and friendly. Toppings for sundaes are put on the bottom and then more on top so every bite has some. Custard is consistently good, thick and creamy.

My mom's favorite ice cream is frozen custard. It's the only establishment of its kind. My daughter loves the vanilla ice cream with sprinkles and I enjoy the vanilla ice cream with chocolate chips. In the past, I've also gotten the ice cream cookie and it's amazing. It's very soft to the bite. The service is great. They're very efficient even though it's a really small place, it's standing room only for maybe two families. They have tables on the other side of the sub shop where you can sit outside. The owner owns the sub shop and the frozen custard place. There's no bathroom for the public. There is ample parking and one handicap accessible parking spot right by the front door.

Not what I expected at all Disappointed Had a frozen banana It was ok Thought it was going to be exceptional

I've been coming here since I was a kid. If you've never had good frozen custard this place is a must try. To me it's much creamer than regular ice cream. The place is small and old style Italian. So we don't eat inside and to be honest the service is a bit slow.

No, No, No. I was so excited to return to Siciliano's for a frozen custard. I ordered my usual, a small vanilla with cake crunch, almonds, and hot fudge. My first clue that something was off was when I barely saw any cake crunch topping on the sundae. I also had to ask for whipped cream and a cherry. The price is now $6.50 for a small sundae. I took one bite and I knew something had changed. They changed the base they use to make the custard. It's no longer creamy and sweet and milky white. It had a strange off-white color and tasted very icy, reminding me of ice milk. Horrible. So, so disappointing. Why did they have to change something that has worked so well for so many years? I will not be back.

Wow! This was the first time we had a frozen custard cone, and it was delicious! It's thicker than ice cream and really fills you up. The server was very nice and helpful and took good care of us. We had been to a restaurant earlier that served spicy food, and we needed something sweet to take that taste away. This hit the spot. This is a nice clean place. Good selection of custards. Easy parking. Wheel chair accessible parking. We will be back.

I loved the ice cream and the flavors! The staff was super friendly, and I'll definitely be coming back. I especially loved the new strawberry shortcake topping!

This is the BEST place for frozen custard. They also have excellent sorbets Friendly and always with a nice , " Hello what would you like" or. "How can I help you". You can have samples to help you decide what you'd like to have. As for calories !!!!! Sometimes ya just gotta indulge

Small ice cream shop with limited selection but excellent quality and very friendly service.

After dining at Submarine Crab, I had the desire to eat something sweet. Somehow I managed to convince my friend of the same, and well, he suggested this place, along with another when I mentioned ice cream. I figured ice cream would work wonders after having some food with some spice in it. I wasn't mistaken. We went to Siliciano's and the line was out the door. I had passed by many times but never stopped, and whoa baby, I was surprised by this place's popularity and also by their size. The shop is itty-bitty, only permitting a maximum of six people inside at the time. Don't let the size deceive you though. They have plenty of variety and it definitely shows given how many people are willing to wait to order. When it was finally our turn, we both got small vanilla custard in a cup. I don't think I could've gotten a cone if I wanted to frankly. I only had so much space after having a Cajun boil. That and I much prefer cups to cones anyway - less mess, but I'm digressing here. My friend heavily suggested I get hot fudge with my dessert as that's what converted him into a fan, but they were sadly out. I wound up reliving my childhood and got rainbow sprinkles on my custard instead. He ended up doing much the same except he added almonds rather than the rainbow sprinkles. Afterwards, we found the one sole table they have outside and ate our desserts there. Really this is a pick up and go type of shop and we were fortunate to have found that table to enjoy and catch up on life in general. I found the custard thick and fresh and the addition of the rainbow sprinkles only complimented the flavor. Still, I really wanted to try that hot fudge. I guess I will have to return.

We love this shop. One of the only places near me that serve frozen custard. So creamy and delicious. I drive from Miami to Siciliano's in Hollywood because it's so great.

The last time I had custard was in Muncie, IN many years ago. I was never able to find some when I was living in NYC. I was surprised a while back when I passed Siciliano's and made a mental note to try them. Last night I decided to give them a try. Siciliano's is in a tiny building on Hollywood Boulevard but they serve up some big flavors. I had a small cup of their vanilla and chocolate swirl with some chocolate chips as a topping. The custard was as good as the one I remembered. Made with egg it has a creamier texture than typical soft serve ice cream and they give a generous serving. I'll be back next time I'm in the mood for a custard dessert. Go give them a try.

Best Custard ever! This place has been around for a very long time! They have custard and regular ice cream to purchase, with many varieties and different styles from ice cream to sundaes and even cannoli's - they have something for almost every craving. I get a medium chocolate and vanilla swirl with chocolate sprinkles on a cake cone. Very creamy, doesn't have a sweet overpowering taste to it. It does melt fast so if you plan on getting custard versus ice cream make sure you are planning on eating it right when you get it. But it's great to enjoy and lots of people go daily so sometimes there could be a line but it goes quick! High recommend. If you haven't visited go.....like right now! Unless they are closed then you gotta wait for tomorrow...

Love me some Siciliano's custard! I hesitate to write a review for this gem because it's so good and such an iconic spot I want to keep it a secret. But they need the recognition because it's the best custard in the tri-county area. They have a tiny little shop where literally only 3-4 people can fit inside. I love the plain flavors and have gotten toppings in the past but I think it takes away from the quality and flavor of the custard. They do have non-dairy options as well but a classic vanilla or chocolate custard is the way to go. Their waffle cones are also amazing but sometimes they're out of them later at night. Their staff is always so wonderful and friendly and if you're in the mood their frozen hurricane (like a blizzard) is a top tier rec! If you're in the area looking for a sweet treat - Siciliano's is the place to go. Absolute legends in the custard game!

Love this place! Wish it were closer to where we live! The vanilla is so delicious and they put sprinkles on the bottom as well as on top so you always get enough! This time I got vanilla custard with Oreo crumble ---- Highly Recommend! Go & Enjoy!!

I love the custard and different combinations of toppings. They make a delicious sundae. Everytime I visit there the staff are friendly and welcoming. It's a cute small desert parlor.

Love the swirl soft serve custard with a chocolate dip. Servers always friendly. Can't believe I drove by it for so many years.

The BEST frozen custard! I drive 45 mins just to get the Vanilla Frozen Custard with Hot Fudge. The Hot Fudge is delicious, as is the custard.

O M G ! The best soft serve I have had! The swirl that you cannot see the lady made was made to perfection! I got a vanilla soft serve on waffle cone with rainbow sprinkles and Oreos! I didn't even know they add other toppings other than sprinkles but they do it all. The lines are so long inside and out on a Sunday night but it was so worth the trip! We plan on going back often and think we have found our go to ice cream place. The soft serve was lite and creamy and just so yummy, I am drooling writing this post. Def check out this place for a yummy after dinner treat!

I wondered what frozen custard was, so I had to check it out. Oh my goodness it is so delicious. I didn't know that they also owned the sub store next door, so we ate our custard by the sketchy smoke shop. (Highly recommend sitting next to the sub shop) I ordered the crunchy chocolate cake with my custard and they definitely top it off!! I loved how creamy and thick the custard was. If I lived closer, I'd want to come all the time. It would be nicer if there were more seating.

Came to this place for their impressive reviews!!!! The place is as stated quite cozy and looked retro!!! Was greeted by a lady that explained that the ice cream is what is now known to be a "yoghurt" ice cream.... Ordered one in a wafer cone that was good and crispy... the chocolate ice cream was good had good flavor and good texture... creamy, a tad too sweet but very good... Very good prices as well for the size of the serving!!!!

I'm always on the hunt for ice cream. This place did not disappoint. It is a tiny joint with a very small lot. Prices were probably lowest that I've seen compared to other stores in SFL. There was only one person working when I went so service wasn't the fastest when someone ahead orders something that has to be made, ie milk shake. We got a strawberry shake and a custard swirl. No regrets! I think about coming back all the time for another cup, but the location away from my usual errand route doesn't allow it easily. That being said, I have to make a special trip to drop by soon. They do accept credit cards now btw. I was panicking a bit when I saw older reviews saying cash only.

Very delicious ice cream and reasonable price! I love vanilla. Also Sherry is unique taste.

I've been coming here for years and if you like frozen custard you should definitely check this place out. It's always spotlessly clean and the staff that works here is always very nice and helpful. Prices are reasonable. As far as the custard goes, it's incredibly thick and very creamy. They have vanilla, chocolate and a twist of chocolate and vanilla combined. They have a good selection of toppings for your ice cream and they offer other flavors of ice cream that isn't custard and sherbet. Great place for a delicious treat!

Tiny almost hidden frozen custard gem in Hollywood. Next to a smoke shop and a sub place. I absolutely love their frozen custard, my go to is vanilla and chocolate swirl with rainbow sprinkles. I keep it simple but it always hits the spot for me! I usually order a small or kids cup. Highly recommend trying when needing to satisfy a sweet tooth!

I love the frozen custard.. this place is slight hard to find if you're not looking for it. But my daughter and I enjoy find this treasured treat especially on a hot day.

a 1 because the young girl who seems to be new was polite but my ice creams were hollow in the center and the manager has a bad attitude and gives smart remarks constantly, which is the main reason i stopped going here. I stopped going for at least a year , however my child wanted custard and I was hoping the service was better. I took a chance today! I've been coming here for over 20 years and the service used to be the best but now you're greeted with a smart mouthed nasty supervisor and employees who look unhappy. she tossed my change on the counter and then when I called to let her know how uncomfortable and insulted I felt and how i thought it was rude and idk if she's having a bad day. her response was it's usually the customers who are in a bad mood im always happy and the owner knows im always happy. In fact I get on his nerves with my happiness... needless to say. This is not my first encounter with said manager so I will no longer visit this location!

This unassuming, rather tiny shop really hits above its weight. Delicious custard and the portions are plenty generous for the price. Top it off with good service and great covid safety and we've got a winner. We walked into the shop and were greeted by a very polite employee. Only two people allowed in at a time and no eating inside for the time being. This made us feel safe. The gal behind the counter was very nice and super helpful. Honestly my only gripe about my visit is that I wasn't given the option to tip when paying with card. They have an array of custards, ice creams, shakes, and sundaes. I had a frozen custard sundae with vanilla/chocolate swirl (the only two custard options) topped with caramel, brownie, and pecan. Creamy and so delicious. One thing I really liked was that she put toppings in the bottom before putting in custard then put more on top, so I had toppings the while time. A large sundae was only $6, so I figured I may as well go for it. Wow was it a lot of custard. I was greedy and ate the whole thing cause it was so good, but wouldn't recommend the large for one person. What I would recommend is checking this little place out. It doesn't look like much from the outside but it's a great find!

Delicious frozen treats. Very, very small area to step inside and see available flavors, to place and pick-up an order but that explains the two window stations on the front of the building. Only one staff person on shift. She was very friendly and assembled my order with care. I got the large frozen vanilla custard in a waffle cone with Butterfinger crumbles. Absolutely delicious! The sweet creamy cool custard hit the spot. The waffle cone was thick, soft freshly made and the Butterfinger crumbles were crunchy. With my permission (thank you for asking first), the cone was placed in a cup to prevent a disaster ie loss of crumbles I guess; but I should have taken a picture first of the assembled masterpiece. Will definitely return when in the area to try other treats like the Superman sorbet that looked so colorful and rich.

Popped in here on Sunday evening and boy was it busy. Only two people allowed inside due to COVID. The woman serving us inside was pretty low key, not the friendliest, but she quickly served us two waffle cones with chocolate/vanilla custard. The price for two soft serve waffle cones was $11, a little high, but this is high quality custard; very thick and creamy. The waffle cone itself, dipped in chocolate (on the cone) was absolutely delicious. It was crunchy and chewy at the same time. Very good flavor. They also have hard ice cream and sundaes with toppings, but we didn't try them, yet. :-)

This is a place that I never would heard about nor visited had it not been for Yelp and fellow reviewers. It's on the north side of Hollywood Blvd -- just east of 441/State Road 7. But it's a tiny separate building between the smoke shop and a sub shop that you could easily drive by unless you were looking for it. Right now, they are only letting 2 people per time inside. But it was a very short wait until the 2 guys ahead of us were served. I ordered their combo white and chocolate custard together in a small cup. I added on butterscotch sauce as a topping for only 75 cents more. There are lots of toppings from which to choose if you like them. My husband just got a small cup of vanilla custard, plain. There are bigger sizes if you wish. As well as a kiddie cup for only $2. And cones, of course. Other items include sundaes, shakes, splits, etc. Plus they have fruity sorbets/sherbets, too. We figured we'd try one of their basics first. All I can say is that their product was wonderful -- rich and creamy. I loved both flavors of the soft custard ice cream and also the butterscotch sauce. And it was so very inexpensive! They definitely give Whits and even Culver's a run for their money. This place isn't that far away for us -- at least via the turnpike -- so I know we will return again soon. But if you live in south Broward, you have to make a trip here and try them.

My favorite place ever. No one makes custard like they do. Not only is their custard delicious, but they give such good portions and the prices are so good. You can't go wrong with anything from here. My favorite things to get are just the classic vanilla custard in a cone or one of their shakes. Lines can get pretty long in the weekends but it is 100% worth the wait.

This place has been at the corner of Hollywood Boulevard and 441 in Broward County for decades. It still has the best custard in town. It's smooth, rich, creamy, and deeeelicious! A small is $2, and for $3 you can drown yourself in a large cone. Don't mess it up with toppings. Enjoy the sweet, succulent taste of the creamy vanilla.

Delicious custard!!!! It is so creamy, it's a dream come true. The prices are incredibly cheap for such good quality costs. There's multiple toppings to chose from for your custard. They also offer sorbets and ice creams! If you haven't stopped by, it's definitely worth it!! We've driven by this place a thousand times! So happy we decided to stop by and find this Hollywood hidden gem.

Solid custard, only had the soft serve can't speak for the rest of the products. Would visit again

Amazing! Amazing! Its a small spot in Hollywood but a golden one. I had a small cherry/mango sorbet, my mom had a sundae which was super creamy & delicious. Staff was nice too. Definitely recommend this place.

Their custard taste great and their size portions are huge! Medium serve 2 person no doubt! Their special vanilla chocolate crawled is amazing.

Sicilianos is a small take out ice cream place on Hollywood Blvd and 441. I love this place with its custard product. The custard is awesome and they serve regular ice cream too. The product is five stars but...I lowered its overall rating because the last few times I am literally being asked to tip when I pay by credit card. It makes me very uncomfortable to be asked to tip, especially where it is solely a take out place. Putting ice cream in a cone is not like being served with waiter service like Jaxsons. So it makes think twice about returning there again.

My guilty pleasure is Siciliano's their custard is top notch and is way better then going to some big name ice cream shop!

Not sure why they changed their custard after so many years. Very disappointing that the taste and consistency is completely different.

After having drinks and dinner with Yelp friend Ray N., I wanted a light dessert. Found Siciliano's Frozen Custard searching through Yelp and decided to try it out. Located along Hollywood Blvd., Siciliano's Frozen Custard is a small frozen treat shop that offers a variety of items such as: * Old fashioned floats * Cakes & pies * Sorbet & sherbet * Pints & quarts * Novelties & sundaes * Cones & cups * Shakes & malts * Dream shakes * Frozen hurricanes (custard blended with choice of topping) * Various toppings Siciliano's is next to a sub shop and the parking is small and limited, but from the looks of the steady traffic pulling into the premises, I take it that the place serves some good frozen treats. The place may be small on the outside, but it's very compact on the inside for customers waiting to be served (think of a 3L x 6W rectangle)...I wouldn't like to see this place during summer break. I asked one of the employees if they had soft serve and she replied that they had vanilla, chocolate, and chocolate/vanilla swirl. I asked for a chocolate/vanilla swirl with chopped peanuts in a small cone. I was truly impressed. The custard was swirled into the cone and the peanuts was applied so neatly it looked like a work of art, but as soon as I stepped outside, it was starting to melt causing the peanuts to drop. Had to lick around the cone very quickly...uh, for those who have a dirty mind...you get the idea ;-). Very light and creamy in taste. A perfect way to end the evening. Next time I'll get the custard in a cup for less mess.

The staff is super nice. Lots of sundae options and everything tastes delicious. I had vanilla custard with chocolate fudge. Yummy Black Forrest sundae was a little sweet but very good. German chocolate sundae mom said was great Cones are fresh. All the toppings are great

Very tiny ice cream shop located off of Hollywood Blvd. near 441. Keep your eyes open or you may just miss it - and you definitely do not want to miss! They are following all COVID/CDC rules and only allow a few people in the small building at a time to get ice cream - while waiting others have to wait outside. I felt very comfortable ordering from here. Staff is very friendly and quick. Ice cream was outstanding. I got an oreo milkshake and it was the perfect blend of ice cream and oreos. Not too thick and not too thin in terms of milk shakes. Small parking lot but be patient, it's worth the wait!