Stacy W.
Yelp
Sincerely, Bagel. I don't even know where to start. I am quite the critic when it comes to eating out, as I always expect a high quality-to-price ratio.
Sincerely, Bagel blew my expectations upon first bite! I've been to a variety of bagel locations throughout my life as it is a great easy breakfast option, but Sincerely, Bagel easily surpassed all others (to the point of neglect). I first tried their bagels in July and have not stopped thinking about them as my go-to bagel location (I've been a handful of times since then). The selection does vary due to demand and production, but I have not been disappointed with any of the bagels I've tried thus far.
The first time I tried Sincerely, Bagel, I got a Za'tar & EVOO bagel with regular cream cheese (you save a few cents). WOW! I never expected to have a reaction to a bagel as I did with this one, it had a crispy exterior, was seasoned generously, and provided a soft interior with a perfectly textured cream cheese.
The later times I've gone, I've tried the Rosemary & EVOO bagel and the cheesy garlic bagel with the scallion cream cheese and the garlic and herb cream cheese. While I realized I may not be a cheese bagel type of girl, I did enjoy all selections greatly. The price for a specialty bagel along with a flavored cream cheese is about $6.50, but I believe it is worth every cent (including additional tip).
I have not been able to thoroughly assess and describe their product as I typically do with other food places as I eat the product too quickly. I do know that the process that they are consistently delivering with their product is spectacular and has not disappointed me at all (staff have been different multiple times as well).
Sincerely, Bagel is definitely worth the visit and price for me (which is very rare)! It intrigues me to the point of interest in their baking and preparation process.
Typically when visiting, I'm in a rush or taking out, but they offer a nice seating area with a few tables, chairs, and a bench! There is often a line (but wasn't once), which can take some time to get your item (I would assume an average of 3-4 minutes per bagel as the wait time), but it is definitely worth the wait! They seem to perform to perfection with all varieties of bagels (whichever suits your preference).
If they had a stamp card, that would be dangerous and I'd suddenly become an early bird! My only complaint is the early closing time (as most other bagel places have), because I can eat a Sincerely, Bagel bagel at any time.