David S.
Yelp
To start off with, I neither found mouse turds nor paper thin sheets in my experience in the main house (not the Seventh Acre house). My wife and I were planning on staying with relatives, but one of them was hospitalized the night before we arrived so we needed a new place. Six Acres was the cheapest B&B available with one night's notice, at least where you could book online. Like every place, it had its pros and cons.
Pros include its historicity. This house was a stop on the Underground Railroad, and they are redoing it to preserve how it used to look historically. It's also pretty and set off from the road so it's not visible from the road (there's a sign as you are driving up Hamilton Avenue). The parking, while not consistently paved, is right next to the house and large.The Sallie Mae room, which has a king-sized bed, is very large, and the private bathroom is as large as our Chicago apartment's master-bedroom. Kristen is accessible by phone and text into the evening and she makes sure to ask about dietary needs when she first talks with you. I ordered chocolate covered strawberries as a surprise just by talking with her and she made sure they were delivered shortly after we got to our room. Breakfast was tasty and filling. When we were there it included glasses of watermelon pieces, omelet casserole (vegetarian for us), sausages, and freshly-baked banana walnut bread slices. Kristen is very friendly and enjoyable to talk with.
Cons - The neighborhood is sketchy. When we drove up, my wife and I got more and more nervous about this location. Fortunately we decided to stay, and you can't see the house from the road, which helps. There are no dinner options within walking distance. You have to drive back down Hamilton Road and cross the bridge to continue on Ludlow Street to find a bunch of good restaurants. Kristen will leave you a list of places if you ask, but there are no maps so you will need to rely on Google Maps. This is a problem because the Internet is spotty (though it is free). Additionally, the rooms only have lace curtains, so privacy isn't amazing in the daytime from the back yard, though if it's dark and the lights are out you should be OK. You might still be woken up early by the sunlight, though. The Sallie Mae toilet doesn't flush well - you have to hold down the handle to get it to work. Also in the Sallie Mae room, there's a couch which appears to be for mere decoration because the cushion is not designed for sitting. The driveway only holds one car at a time and goes around a curve, so you'd better hope nobody is coming the other way when you are on it - also, it's a bit scary to descend. Also, breakfast is called for 9:30, but if you have earlier plans then they can make it for you earlier.
In general, Six Acres is a good place to go if you want to have a (clean) adventure.