Sorelles Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria

Sorelles is a community favorite restaurant with a small hidden bar in the back, outfitted as a Italian diner. Service is good. The Al Pacino is penne sitting in a bowl of water and oil, with grilled chicken. The Chicken Marsala with spaghetti was good. There is a full bar. Reservations are recommended.

Best marinara sauce I've had in a while. You can taste the basil. Loved the garlic knots. Perfectly fluffy and soft. The Italian sausage was also delicious. The Alfredo was very bland but everything else was amazingly

Everything was so delicious. The garlic knots were the perfect flakiness and crunch in one bite. You can tell that everything is freshly made. Chicken parm was scrumptious! Will be back again for the pizza! Looked so good!

Guys, I just love this place. Nestled in a small town, run by family. It’s always busy and it never disappoints. Good food and good cocktails. It’s worth the wait. They now offer call ahead seating…

This is the best restaurant in all of Tennessee! The staff is amazing, the food even though it’s not space food and just Italian is out of this world! Their food is so good it’ll make your tongue slap your brains out! The servers and management are the kindest people in the world! And that old fashion… spot on!!!! Good food takes patience! And it’ll be worth the wait!

This place blew me away. It is truly a hidden gem. Who knew I would find my favorite Italian restaurant in Eagleville TN! Be sure to sit in the "hidden" bar area in the back and ask for Liz, she is an amazing waitress. We asked her to order for us and bring two of the Kitchens best dishes... she did and it completely changed my typical "lukewarm opinion" of what Italian food can be... I finally get it! The flavors were complex, deep, and varied. She brought me the "Scarpariella " - Tender chicken, sliced Italian sausage and pepperoncini in a lemon butter and white wine sauce... AMAZING!. The portions were perfect, and the garlic knots were addictive! One of the sisters who owns the restaurant visited our table to make sure all was good, and I assured her I now had a new favorite Italian restaurant... and that is saying something for me :). Actually, it is one of my faves period. It is one of those times when you feel like you have discovered a hidden treasure the rest of the world does not even know about. So, so SOOOOOOO good.

Best Italian food in Tennessee! The cutest place with 20’s, 40’s and 50’s music playing. Cozy and very clean!

We love Sorelles, they really came through for us tonight! I called ahead this morning for a party of 9 for dinner! They were honest and told us they were booked up except one time window but they accommodated us perfectly though! Our waitress Madison was wonderful she did a great job! We had the whole restaurant watching the Vols game on our phones it was great!😂 10-10 will be back!

Good Italian food in Eagleville! Call ahead, because this is quite the local hotspot! Depending on the day and time, you might be in for a bit of a wait. Staff are very kind and helpful. Pasta was good and definitely restaurant quality, but the pizza was the star!! This restaurant is definitely an Eagleville gem!

Such a mixed bag. The food was incredible. Everything we had was delicious. Our server Heather was fantastic. But as an old restaurant guy, the host staff...and whoever answers the phone...needs major hospitality training. Made us feel like pariahs because we had the nerve to want to eat there. It's a shame because the food is 10/10. But I always thought small businesses wanted paying customers. Made us feel like we were intruding on their private clubhouse. And they had twice as much staff in the house as they did diners. Wish it hadn't happened because this would be a favorite spot otherwise. Still giving them 4 stars because the food is great (5+). Would give them another shot at some point...everybody has bad nights...but it will be a while.

This is a gem of a family restaurant that may seem to be out in the middle of nowhere, but that is well worth a visit. The service was excellent, warm, and friendly. The Penne Ala Vodka was amazing! So flavorful! I'm going to have trouble ordering anything different in the future. The Baked Ziti was good but not great. The pizza was good, but huge! For the regular pizzas there is only one size, which is 18 inches. They have a gluten-free pizza (smaller at 12 inches) that is pretty good. They also have gluten-free pasta, which was almost indistinguishable from the regular pasta. It is great that they have some gluten-free options, especially being an Italian restaurant where bread and pasta dominate. The restaurant is cozy and comfortable, and everything was clean. Overall a great experience. We'll definitely be back, especially because I can't resist the Penne Ala Vodka!

Sorelles is a community favorite restaurant with a small hidden bar in the back, outfitted as a Italian diner. Service is good. The Al Pacino is penne sitting in a bowl of water and oil, with grilled chicken. The Chicken Marsala with spaghetti was good. There is a full bar. Reservations are recommended.

I really enjoyed this place. The vibe of the restaurant is really relaxing. We came in on a Saturday afternoon it was busy but not too busy. We got the bread service and the freshly baked bread was perfect. It was crunchy and soft. The only thing I didn't like was how little balsamic they put in the olive oil. It was like 3 drops of it. That's why I didn't give 5 stars. The chicken parm was tasty I wish it was a little crispier but the flavor was nice and the spaghetti was good. The Chicken masala was tasty. Oh the house made Italian dressing was so good. I wish they sold it. All in all we will be back. I wanna try their pizza

The food was amazing. We traveled over an hour to try this little gem and it did not disappoint. The friendly service was over the top. It has a very homey atmosphere and feels very inviting. We loved every we ate in house and took a pizza to go since it looked so good. We'll definitely be back!

This has quickly become one of my favorite local restaurants, and my family's go-to for great Italian food! It's a family-owned establishment, with a comfortable/casual environment and consistently friendly, attentive service. I have truly never been disappointed. From pizza, pasta, and Stromboli, to their salads and appetizers, all the way to their cannoli and zeppoli (basically Italian beignets) -- all of it is authentic and delicious! And to top it all off, sometimes when we have been there on a Saturday night they have even had a live saxophone player playing laid-back jazz music. This is definitely one of those must-try restaurants in the area and I can't recommend it enough!

The garlic knots , pizza, stromboli, and drinks are worth the wait. And the staff is fabulous. On our first trip I had to try the calamari, having lived on the Mediterranean, I try anywhere they say they have fresh fried calamari. The first visit it was cooked perfectly. Second visit- over cooked. (It doesn't take much to over cook it unfortunately- and I'll be giving it another try!) We have tried their pizza two times. Next time we will return to the stromboli. (I save the butter garlic mixture from the garlic knots for my pizza bones.) Their marinera sauce is tasty- I order a side with the garlic knots. (On our first visit, we were seated in the bar area, where there was a man and his guitar playing some great 70's and 80's tunes.) Tip: If you ahead it might save you wait some time!

There's not another mom and pop Italian place in town thats as good (especially compared to all the chain Italian restaurants). The pizza's are all once size and for 2 adults and a child we always take home leftovers (their cold pizza for breakfast is where it's at). We like the meat lovers. The salad house Italian dressing is really good! I recommend it. The meatballs give homemade vibes and my family always orders them. The garlic knots are 10/10 - probably because they're sitting in a pool of butter. If a pool of butter isn't for you don't get these. The seating can get tight, and they get very busy. There's no changing table in the bathrooms.

Ambiance was amazing! We loved the cozy hidden gem vibe. Although it was packed, the service was great. Our waitress was very attentive and knew the menu. The food was really good. The quantity of the food was a lot for the price so that's a PLUS. Prices were good as well. It's definitely a hidden gem and will come back!

This place is so good. Lexi our server was great. Attentive, Energetic and fun. She kept our glasses full and the food was amazing. We will definitely be going back.

This place is amazing. The people are wonderful especially Lexie. She is very courteous and friendly. We will recommend to family and friends. We will be back most definitely.

Our time at Sorelles was amazing. Waiting at the bar for our table was a wonderful time. We talked to Kyah about the history of Sorelles and how it came to be, charming!!! The food was amazing! Simply fantastic. We will be back and look forward to trying the Stromboli's for lunch. The building and ambiance is wonderful!

Love, love, LOVE this place for amazing Italian food. Every time we come here, the food is OUTSTANDING. It's a family-owned restaurant and you can tell that everything is consistently good. I've had several dishes here and each one was so tasty. The sisters that own this restaurant really take pride in it because they also make sure that service for their guests is top notch. When we come in, we're always recognized and greeted as if we were part of their family. I love the new addition to their waiting area inside and the front porch is always a fun place to wait. I can tell you, an hour wait if you even have that is VERY WELL WORTH IT. The place is so cute and cozy! Not trying to throw shade on Demos, but that place has NOTHING on Sorelles who serve AUTHENTIC Italian. There's truly no comparison!

We love Sorelles! Everything we've ever ordered has been great! We always go mid-day so we don't have any negative experience with wait times at night. The restaurant is small but mighty. The staff is great. It's a beautiful drive out to Eagleville too.

The food is the best in the area, worth the drive from Murfreesboro for sure. Pizzas are great but the pasta is some of the best for our area. Wait for a table can be long but the service is well worth the wait - ask for Liz she is great! Gets loud in the main dining room but you get lost in the sauces and garlic knots so it gets drowned out by your taste buds.

Some of the best Italian food you will eat in middle Tennessee. Not to mention the service is amazing! Great casual but also fancy restaurant for any and all occasions. I recommend getting a reservation or calling ahead! They are always busy because this place is incredible!

I have to say this is one of my absolute FAVORITE Italian restaurants. My only complaint would be that my party of 6 had to wait awhile but that was hit with positivity because we were able to sit on the rocking chairs and bench's in the front and watch the sun set. Me and my friends were also able to order wine while we were waiting and that was perfect. Once we got inside we ordered lots of things. For example garlic knots that were gone within the first 3 minutes that they were placed. The waitresses were also very kind and made sure we got everything we needed. Of course I had to use the bathroom but I didn't mind because on my way there they had it decorated like an alley but one that was lit up and cute looking. The bathroom was adorable and literally made for a girl. First of all it was one stall and as soon as you close the door you see a full body mirror. There was also funny girl talk in picture frames. For example one said, I see London I see France, right above the toilet. It made me laugh and smile. Before I sat down I was like oh no because there wasn't any toilet paper. But as soon as I walked out a waitress was standing outside and got me a roll. Then when I came back our food was coming. We also got a margarita pizza, lasagna, fettuccine, and another pasta. Everything was amazing and there was also Parmesan on the table which made things even better! We of course got boxes but over all had an amazing night! Thank you!!

The food was fantastic! The homemade bread should be illegal as I was on a keto diet ... I ATE IT ALL!! WORTHY or EVERY CALORIE :) The baked penne & the sauce was super delicious !! Highly recommend!! *Note Our waitress was very personable & welcoming.

Fantastic Pizza, Great Chicken Marsala and delicious pepper and sausage sandwiches!! Staff is outstanding

I went to Sorelles a few weeks ago on a Friday. I had the salad, and it was awful. Straight from the package. My son had the garlic bread appetizer which was swimming in oil. I think they have great pizzas, but that's all you should order. They have revamped their back room, and it looks much better. They also had live music, and it was a plus. The service was not great.

I had the Ribeye Marsala, while my wife had the Penne a la Vodka. We also snuck in a slice of pizza as an appetizer. Really enjoyed our dinner. exceptional service and such a cute restaurant. It was a nice surprise.

Fantastic friendly service, a true hidden gem in the area. My wife is Sicilian and very picky about Italian cuisine. She loved her food. The tea was fair, the portions were large, and the atmosphere was friendly. I had a Cesar salad which was really good on an ice cold plate. I also had the chicken piccata which I normally don't like but this was delicious, my wife had penne ala vodka with blackened chicken, and our daughter had a Stromboli. Everything was great and we will visit again.

Hidden gem! A friend shared with us that there was a fabulous Italian restaurant in Eagleville so we had to check it out. Boy are we sad we didn't know about this hidden gem sooner. The food was 10/10 excellent. I especially loved the calamari. It was fried perfectly and reminded me of calamari in Italy. I loved their marina and be prepared for the out of this world garlic knots they bring to the table. Our sever Peter was friendly and personable. Wherever you live, it's worth the drive! I can't wait to go back to try more dishes. They take reservations for 6 or more and do a big take out service - and even have a counter dedicated to take out.

Not very impressed especially for the wait. Good service though. I had heard good things about but didn't live up to it. Thanks for the response. Hopefully we can try it again and the food will be better. I had the reverse lasagna and the pasta was overcooked and seemed store bought. It was valentines weekend and very busy so it may have just been a tough night. Thanks again for your response.

This is by far our favorite restaurant in the Murfreesboro area. Everything we have ordered has been great. I would highly recommend the Caesar salad and ask for the balsamic drizzle. When available, order the lemoncello cheesecake for dessert. Yum. Alfredo is great, meatballs are huge and delicious. Pizzas are wonderful with a crunchy yet soft crust. Service is phenomenal. It's a quaint little building on Main St in Eagleville, TN that is comfortable for lunch but the bar area seating usually has a sax player performing some great classic jazz and rat pack type tunes at night on the weekends.

Great little Italian spot in the quaint town of Eagleville. I remember driving through here as a kid & there wasn't anything to stop for, maybe the occasional yard sale during the spring, but food wise nothing enticing. Now the community has a nice place to grab a pizza or some pasta. I can here with my relatives from nearby Shelbyville & honestly it was much easier to get a table for 5 on a Saturday night here than in that town. The place was popping but we were seated immediately at 5:30 at the last table. Took awhile to get water & place our order but it was fine. I got the blackened chicken fettuccini & it was a solid iteration of the dish, no complaints really. My mother doesn't do red sauce at the moment & they were nice enough to change some things so she could get the manicotti with white sauce. The garlic knots are good too, basically just twisted pizza dough with garlic sauce, would be better with marinara. Would recommend if you're in the area & want simple no frills Italian.

My son and his family bought take out and my dish had 2 inches of olive oil. Never had I had an Italian dish with so much olive oil. Would not recommend. They also ordered the calamari and received 10 pieces at the most. The amount of money spent on this dinner was not worth it.

Sorelles hasAmazing food with fantastic service. So far this is our go to Italian restaurant. Even my picky daughter eats here and loves it

Our gang of 10 enjoyed dinner at Sorelles at the recommendation of friends. Our group was large, so reservation was accepted and table was ready on time. Sorelles means sisters in Italian. Friendly, attentive service. Sorelles is a family-run Italian restaurant with both sit-down and busy pizza take out. Now offers limited beer and wine selection. While the menu is limited, there is something for everyone including mostly pasta, pizza and chicken dishes. Each couple ordered a Antipasto Salad platter to share. It was a hit. Ordered extra "Garlic Knots"--pizza bread "knots" covered in garlic butter and parmesan. Our group ordered Chicken Marsala, Chicken Scarpariello (means shoemaker), Chicken Piccata (meaning thinly sliced), and Pasta with Meatballs. Street parking was not a problem in downtown Eagleville. Lunch and dinner daily, and closed Sunday Two Italian menu suggestions would be nice additions: * Spaghetti alle Vongole/Linguine with Clams * Steamed Mussels with White Wine Broth Small gripes: * A Surprise: The check automatically added a credit card surcharge that was not disclosed on the menu. Presumably a cash payment would remove the surcharge upon request so not to penalize the server. * Though we tip generously, the suggested tip included tip on sales tax...an oversight or deliberate?

Sorelles in Eagleville (of all places) was an exceptional surprise! The food is full of flavor, the garlic knots are AMAZING, so is the pizza, the entrees are what you expect in a truly Italian restaurant. Do yourself and your family a favor and go as soon as you can. The service is down home and welcoming. The ambiance is superb.

This place gets busy so make sure you get here early. We got here at 4:30 and there was no wait for our party of 10. We got several apps that were not pictured. The garlic knots were the best in my opinion. The pizza was the perfect consistency with a stiff crust but still doughy enough. We really liked the antipasto salad with their homemade Italian dressing. By far the best thing I had here was the tiramisu. I would definitely come back just for that!

The place was pack packed when we got there. But we could smell the food before we even got outta our car! The smell was so strong, and amazing. Once we got seated, the waitress was with us immediately, and kept up with us the entire meal. We never had to wonder where she was, or look for her. The rest of the staff was very friendly, and helped each other out. No one was left out or left behind in their tables. The atmosphere was on the quiet side for the place being so full. I really appreciated that the noise level was not a so loud. My Stromboli was the best I've ever had before! I'm usually a 1 Italian restaurant girl. This place definitely blows my normal, big chain, outta the water! Pricing was surprisingly low, and perfect. Will most definitely come back again! Love this place.

Great family owned business.. friendly staff, great food and atmosphere. Has a good selection of pizza, sandwiches and pasta dishes. We've take the family there several times and each experience has been a consistently positive experience. Definitely recommend if you are craving good Italian style food.

Sorelles Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria just opened May 10, has a nice home feeling, and about as loud as an Italian family gathering for a Sunday dinner...LOL Currently they do not have wine (BYOB is available with a cork fee) but they do have beer available and wine should be soon. My server Shaina (the little Sorelle) got me my drink and I placed my order for a slice of plain cheese pizza and Fettuccine Alfredo with Blackened Chicken. I've enjoyed a lot of different styles of pizza and this one closely resembled a slice of NY pie, but much more "crisp" and thinner. I liked the pie...good flavor, not too much sauce, a nice coating of cheese, and didn't need any additional cheese or seasoning. The fettuccine alfredo was very good, the sauce rich and thick, and the noodles perfectly al-dente. Really loved the blackened chicken, not overly spicy but great flavor while the chicken was moist and went well with the alfredo sauce. It was well worth the 25 minute drive out there and I'm looking forward to trying other dishes and a whole pie too!!!

Than place has amazing food and prices. Well worth every penny. The standout was the absolute best service. My partner has spaghetti I bad Stromboli. Everything tasted well. The tiramisu is a must have

Outstanding service and food. Expensive but totally worth the price. Very nice place. A wonderful place to celebrate an occasion.

Family owned, Great food, friendly employees, nicely decorated and clean restrooms!!! Next time we will try the desserts. This is a great fine. We will be back

Why do you sacrifice yourself to such scrutiny by "skimping" on your pizza topping along with the smaller serving size of your entrees?? Your meals are so very tasty but the greed for an extra dollar is very disappointing. This doesn't mean it's OK for another price hike!! Be above the trend for all of us.

Best Italian joint around. I honestly have enjoyed everything I've tried. Pizza is also top notch. We get it to-go all the time!!

Great location with the small town feel Friendly staff Good wine and beer selection Clean We served timely but not rushed Plenty of parking

Love this hidden gem. No longer hidden so expect a wait on weekends. Great food- reasonable and greatbservice

We love the food at Sorelles as well as the friendly service. We especially love the garlic knots. So delicious!!

Best little kept secret in middle Tennessee ! Great food, great service, and atmosphere..! Highly recommended

Had the baked ziti. OMG! Homemade and delicious!!! The service was over the top!!!!!!!!!! Great Italian!!!!

This family-owned restaurant always delivers the best authentic Italian experience. We love that they offer gluten free options for our friends when they visit. Warm atmosphere

So good! The garlic knits are a MUST! Get a dozen because they're small and 6 leaves you wanting more. Alfredo lasagna was great. Tortellini lasagna was good but not really lasagna... This place is worth the drive.

My wife and I came for dinner Friday night. It was our first time here. The place was super busy and very loud. That said, it was clean and all of the staff were welcoming and courteous. My wife had chicken piccatta over spaghetti and I had the chicken scarpariello over penne. Both dishes were excellent. We also each had a small house salad which were also very good. The drinks were well made and our server was fantastic. I noticed several of the staff greeted us, took up dishes, helped deliver food, and I think the manager/owner came by to ask if everything was good. Even though we were both stuffed, we shared a cannoli which was amazing. We will definitely be back even though it's a 40 mile drive.

The food is okay for Italian but is in order with Olive Garden. The service is good. The servers appear to be overwhelmed but deal with it. Truth of the matter is that this place succeeds because there isn't anything else to compete but a Mexican restaurant within walking distance.