John M.
Yelp
Service is 5 Stars - Jacob was our server and he took good care of us. The other servers were helpful bringing water, chips and salsa.
The kid was in town visiting from college and she wanted to get to some of her favorite eating joints in the area. South of Nick's made the cut. Honestly, it's not one of my favorites as I feel it is overpriced Mexican food. While I have tried a variety of dishes, none have knocked me out. For the price, I would like the food to knock me out! Service is always good and the cocktails are perfectly on point each time, so I give them that.
We did not have a reservation, as if you can get a reservation at any Nick's location, so we walked in around 5:30 on a Friday and it was not really that crowded. Surprised me! I put my name in and we only waited about 10 minutes for a table. Walking, the bar had 5-6 chairs open. Again, quite a surprise for a Friday evening.
After being seated and then greeted by our server we ordered some cocktails and I wanted to try the queso fundido. Fundido to eat and fundido to say! The app is jack and oaxaca cheese, poblano pepper, black olives, mushrooms, pork longaniza. After we ordered these, chips and salsas showed up. Chips were freshly made and the two salsas were both delicious. The third little bowl served with chips was refried black beans. These were fairly bland, so we stuck with the yummy salsas.
Cocktails:
Me: Ketel One Martini. Dry. Two regular olives. Perfection.
The Wife: Mexican Mai Tai: Reposado tequila, malahat spiced rum, orgeat, fresh juices, lilikoi foam. She loved it and gave it a 10 out 10, except that it went too fast!
The Kid: Shirley Temple - she's 20 and still orders a shirley temple I love that! A kicked up Shirley Temple is only 6 months away!
The queso fundido showed up and it was bubbly hot and served with grilled corn tortillas. I preferred the chips as the instrument of carrying the fundido to my mouth, but the tortillas were not bad.
After scouring the menu, another cocktail and making a dent in the chips, salsas and queso fundido, we had made our entree choices. While Jacob checked on us, he did not push us to order our food. I like that. The kid and the wife ordered the Filet and Grilled Romaine salad: Grilled filet mignon, avocado, baby heirloom tomatoes, pickled onions, pepitas,
jalapeño blue cheese dressing. My choice was to get the Ceviche appetizer as my main. Along with some more chips it would be a nice dinner. The ceviche is shrimp in lime marinade with baby heirloom tomatoes, serrano peppers, avocado and pickled onions.
The wife and kid liked their salads, but both commented on the small size of the filet. As you can see from the picture, the wife had 4 small slices of filet on her plate. Perhaps they split the filet between the two salads? Both commented that the steaks were cooked a bit more than the medium rare that they ordered. Not dried out, not medium, not enough for them to send it back. But a bit of a bummer.
My ceviche was a nice pile of shrimp mixture on top of a flared-out sliced avocado. Nice presentation. We had already eaten our chips with our fundido, so I wanted more to use as utensils for my ceviche. What was funny was earlier on, a gal was walking around doling out chips every minute and suddenly she was no longer doing that and we had a bit of trouble waving someone down to ask for more chips. Not being ignored as it was very busy and understandably servers were moving around quickly. I didn't want to jump up and say "Hey, more chips to table 32!!". Ha, ha! I finally waved someone down and they quickly brought the chips. The ceviche was excellent and I enjoyed it very much. Nice portion of shrimp, good pickled red onions, perfectly ripe avocado and a tiny kick of heat from the serranos. This was good as my meal, but would be a good appetizer to share as it was intended.
For dessert there is no question if you are at any Nick's location that the buttercake needs to be ordered. We ordered one to share and for me that is the perfect amount of goodness to end our meal.
Along with the bill, Jacob brought us volcanically hot towels meant to burn the skin off of our hands before paying. He did warn us and he was right, they were hot. We let them cool and it is a nice touch to wipe off your hands after the meal. One guy took it a bit further and looked like he was taking a sponge bath. I was waiting for him to stand up and wipe the towel in unmentionable places. Interesting, but glad he made use of the towel to avoid taking a shower when he got home!
Overall, for over $200 I still feel it is overpriced Mexican food, but the kid wanted to go so there we were. We had a good experience.
Go. Eat Well. HAVE FUN!