Brian M.
Yelp
Edited for more information:
Thinking I may have been a little rash in my initial judgement I decided to chance one more visit. The pools were back to just slightly scuzzy, in other words, tolerable. The real issue is that the owner (and I was misinformed here, the owner has been the same since 1988) wanted to confront me.
This is the "make it or break it" moment for any business, how you deal with criticism/complaint/honest issue. Excellent companies, those that have stellar reputations, simply do what's needed to make it right, whatever "it" is. I've seen hotel rooms comped, airfare refunded, and no-cost replacement of items. This time was not one of those positive encounters. It was a lecture about how I was wrong... I was wrong about their ownership (and promptly said "Sorry about that, I was misinformed"), how they (SIC) 'set the standards in Montana' for their pools, and how their pools are cleaned nightly. Meanwhile, the owner said they had ~150 guests (no clarification on hotel or pool users) the day it was the worst and the owners wife admitted it was more dirty than usual that night. Ok, I guess that's a round-about way of admitting what I already knew, but the accusatory tone that accompanied the information made it somehow seem that I was wrong for telling things they way they were. I was accused of not tracking down the owner, despite the fact that I mentioned the issue to the on-duty staff and was ignored or at least she had no reply. The whole confrontation ended with my walking out, calmly and never having raised my voice or engaged in the argument, and being called a loudmouth before being told I was banned. I do find the last bits particularly amusing as why in the World would I want to offer money to be treated this way again? The last visit was simply because we had a pre-paid card.
The saddest part? The thing that provoked the above incident could have been Completely neutralized very simply. "I'm sorry the pools weren't to your standards those nights. We were very busy and will figure out how to prevent the same situation in the future", or something along those lines. But you'd think that someone who's owned the business for 26 years would know by now that there are busy weekends and the cleaning system is overwhelmed on those weekends. You'd think that when a minor renovation was done with the addition of a new pool and more rooms, that you might need to upgrade the filtration system as well. Or, maybe they did and there was a Real issue where it wasn't functioning ~ in that case it's probably a good idea to investigate once you know it's an issue (and it is an issue, when another local is grumbling about the conditions in the changing room without ever having gotten in, and multiple other guest comment to everyone in the area about the cleanliness, it's an issue).
For you, this is fine and dandy, just a single review. But consider what happens if you come in and find that your room hasn't been cleaned well/to your standards or the prior guest left you some "leftovers" that the cleaning staff missed? I mean, cleaning staff can have off days. How are they going to deal with your complaints? It's my guess that you'll be told that it's "impossible, our cleaning staff has been doing it for 20+ years", and worst case you'll be told to leave immediately. Is it worth the risk?
Original review:
20 years after my first visit (and roughly 5~10 soaks a year), I've had my last at this place. The pools were so disgusting last night that I couldn't even bring myself to get in. First time ever that I've seen a Thick layer of scum on the 2 outdoor pools (which was present on Friday 2/14 and obviously hadn't been touched/cleaned until I went again on Monday 2/17), clumps of hair mixed with other 'stuff'. I have seriously never seen it so filthy before. I suspect that the newest owners are raising prices, cutting services/quality and just looking to ride the prior good reviews until they've milked it for all it's worth and then dump the property on someone else.
So, be warned. This WAS a place worthy of the reviews found online, but has taken a marked turn for the worse. I was in the changing room with another local last night who also couldn't bring himself to get into the water and was shocked at just how much the place had changed (for the worse) in the last few years. Even considering the newer outdoor pool. It's a difference between a one time effort and caring about the place Daily.
Guess I'll be putting my own hot tub to use more often now.