Cathy W.
Yelp
Previous reviewers have explained the island highlights well, so I'll concentrate on logistics that will help obsessive planners prepare for the trip. The ticket-buying experience turned out to be much more painful than I'd expected, but may have been due to a boom in visits because of a recent Boston Globe article. We actually waited in line longer than it took us to ferry over to Spectacle Island. Seriously.
We arrived on a weekday via the T at 10:40 to buy tickets for the 11AM ferry. There were probably eight ticket purchases ahead of us, with two people working the booth. It was twenty minutes before we got to the window. That's right, 11:00. We'd already given up hopes of making the 11AM ferry, because a posted sign said the 10 and 11 were sold out. But, surprise surprise, the ticket agent said she could get us on the 11:00 if we were willing to run. Even more surprising, the ferry had plenty of seats. So, here are tips that fellow obsessive planners crave:
1. Even if you reserve tickets online, you still have to wait in the line to claim them. Ugh!
2. The island does a brisk business with summer camp kids, so don't be surprised if you are in line behind a young woman who gets to the ticket counter and requests tickets for herself and 35 kids!
3. There were a lot of camp kids on the ferry and island, but they were well-supervised and a positive addition to the island's atmosphere.
4. If you're running from the Aquarium T stop, don't go to the ticket booth in front of the Marriott that says "BHC" - go around the hotel and you'll find the Boston Harbor Islands Ferry booth.
http://www.bostonislands.com/mainland-piers-long-wharf-north
5. You do have to book a return time when you buy your ticket, but nobody was checking the times on our return. They were, however, keeping count of how many people were on board!
6. Resist the urge to take the ferry straight to Spectacle Island. It's only a ten minute ride, but it's worth it to ride to George's Island first and then back to Spectacle. About 45 minutes total and totally worth it to see the harbor and islands up close.
7. The Summer Shack offerings were limited - it's a snack bar, with hotdogs, hamburgers, tuna salads, chicken sandwiches. There were no lobster rolls the day we were there, despite the menu
http://www.summershackrestaurant.com/uploadDocs/Summer%20Shack%20Snack%20Shack%20Menu.pdf
8. It's worth repeating: water, sunscreen
The island and ferry staff is helpful and friendly. The views are outstanding - Boston Harbor water looked almost like the Caribbean.