Taj T.
Yelp
The Pumpernickel on its own, even without cream cheese, would be a 5 star. Paired with the fantastic roasted veggies cream cheese, it would add up to a 10! So why the 3 star? Well, even though the pumpernickel had a fantastic, spiced flavor, I felt it was only half the size of bagels you get on the East Coast for the same price. Also, it wasn't toasted well enough...or at all really.
It was more of an issue for the Poppyseed Bagel with Smoky Pepper cream cheese I got, where the flavors couldn't compensate for the lack of toasting. Too dense, too chewy! We wondered whether we'd gotten one of the "day old" bagels they were also selling.
The "Smoky Pepper" was not what I was expecting at all. I thought it would be cream cheese with black pepper, but what I got was some rare pieces of something that didn't taste like anything. So it just tasted like regular cream cheese.
The "Uncle Sal", their lox bagel sandwich, was pretty great. Especially with the chives cream cheese!
A shame their Strawberry Habanero cream cheese ran out, along with a lot of their bagels. We didn't show up too late in the day, 10 am. I'd like to try them, but from my first very average experience, I don't know it would be worth the early morning wake up.