Spilt Milk Market

Bakery · Pilsen

Spilt Milk Market

Bakery · Pilsen

1

1844 S Blue Island Ave, Chicago, IL 60608

Photos

Spilt Milk Market by null
Spilt Milk Market by null
Spilt Milk Market by null
Spilt Milk Market by null
Spilt Milk Market by null
Spilt Milk Market by null
Spilt Milk Market by null
Spilt Milk Market by null
Spilt Milk Market by null
Spilt Milk Market by null
Spilt Milk Market by null
Spilt Milk Market by null
Spilt Milk Market by null
Spilt Milk Market by null
Spilt Milk Market by null
Spilt Milk Market by null
Spilt Milk Market by null
Spilt Milk Market by null
Spilt Milk Market by null
Spilt Milk Market by null

Highlights

Nestled in Pilsen, this charming bakery offers an array of homemade pies and pastries, great coffee, and a cozy vibe perfect for lingering.  

Featured in Eater
Placeholder
Placeholder

1844 S Blue Island Ave, Chicago, IL 60608 Get directions

spiltmilkpastry.com

Information

Static Map

1844 S Blue Island Ave, Chicago, IL 60608 Get directions

+1 312 344 1497
spiltmilkpastry.com

Features

payment debit card
coffee

Last updated

Mar 6, 2025

Powered By

You might also like

Terms of Use • Privacy Policy • Cookie Policy
 © 2025 Postcard Technologies, Inc.
@eater

"Sister-owned spot Spilt Milk Market is closed at 1844 S. Blue Island Avenue, co-owners Meg and Molly Svec wrote in an Instagram post." - Ashok Selvam

Chicago’s Restaurant and Bar Closures for 2019 - Eater Chicago
View Postcard for Spilt Milk Market

Matthias Lampe

Google
Fantastic new bakery in Pilsen. All biscuits, sweets and pies are baked in house and they taste delicious! I got the vegetarian savory pie for lunch. The people are super friendly and the place has a nice atmosphere to stay and enjoy the food. I like that they kept a lot of the old interior such as the fridges.

Riley Lynch

Google
What a delightful place! Nice staff and delicious products! They have fixings so that you can prepare your own picnic with the breads, meats and cheeses they have, or you can have a great coffee break right there with some of their sweets and coffee. The chocolate cream pie and key lime pie are both INCREDIBLE. There’s games and books for the kids, too!

Giovanna Cruz

Google
It looked so good we couldn’t help but dig into them before taking a picture. Very friendly staff and delicious pies. There is also a good variety of pastries, we will definitely be back to try more.

MSF

Google
I haven't tried their baked goods yet (though they all looked amazing), but their coffee was great! Looking forward to trying their food and pastries soon. EDIT: I’ve since tried their pie and cookies and can say that both are incredible! Definitely stop by here if you’re looking for a good dessert place. I’m glad I don’t have to travel outside of Pilsen to get high-quality pie anymore!

Corbin Koepke

Google
Coffee is awesome, pies are super tasty and our favorite is the biscuits. We cut them in half and put them in the toaster to eat with eggs. Crispy outside and chewy inside. With a little butter and jam, oh so good!

Sara

Google
Love this location in Pilsen! Their chocolate pie is absolutely mind blowing. They’ve really done justice to this space- keeping much of the original interior and cooler space. Staff was thoughtful, helpful, and kind. Will be back here again and again and again. ❤️❤️❤️

Ellery R

Google
Chocolate cream pie is sooooo good. Metric coffee served here. Customer service is top notch. Antique fridge is pretty sweet too.

Spencer Lee

Google
Best pie and cookies in the city plus maybe nicest barista I've ever met.