Matt C.
Yelp
Three decades in business, baby! Spinelli's Market is a local corner store and deli in Park Hill, specializing in all-things-Italian. They do have additional items on hand, however those seeking high quality pastas, sauces, cheeses, etc. will be at home here. I can assure you I was!
Proud of my Italian-American heritage, it's a travesty that it took me three years to get here. I've driven by it dozens of times...there's no excuse. When my wife suggested it for my birthday lunch (knowing they have a deli) I was elated to feast on an Italian sandwich.
Walking in reminded me of my favorite Italian markets, specifically similar style bodegas in New York. The deli is located in the back and if you're like me, it'll take you awhile to make it to the counter. I was ooing and ahhing over all my favorite cans of Cento, Sclafani, Bianco Diapoli, etc. Whole artichokes, cherry peppers, canned anchovies, it's all here.
The deli menu is pretty diverse and not limited to Italian cold cuts. Around 20 subs if I remember correctly. However, I knew I wanted their classic Italian, Jerry's Classic Italian Sub (#1).
This sandwich was wonderful. The usual suspects of Genoa Salami, Capicola and Smoked Ham were a joy to see. However, the two biggest takeaways were the roasted red peppers and marinated onions. I've eaten more Italian sandwiches than most, and I've never seen these both working in unison. As a roasted red pepper fan, I really like the addition. Additionally, the "ciabattini roll" was soft and flavorful, and the sandwich held up nicely.
We ended buying some carrot cake and pantry items while we were there. It was gloomy out, but they actually have a few seats inside so we devoured our lunches inside. This place reminds me of my childhood and I'm so happy I finally got to experience it firsthand. Mangia!