Franki H.
Yelp
Writing this review, I'm a bit caught between a four and a five but I'll hold off on the five until I can try more.
That said, there's a lot of good elements to this little shop/eatery. I went in for lunch. We both had a seasonal special with warm apples, honey, and a cheese (cheddar or blue) on a ciabatta. The balance of bread to stuff was a little skewed with such a sandwich, which bothered my dining partner more than me, but I did find myself thinking I wanted more food, not because I wasn't full, but because I didn't have much substantial besides the bread. All that said, it was really good! The sandwiches come all wrapped up in a really aesthetically pleasing cheese paper-esque wrapping that would make it perfect to leave with or to crack open at their one indoor table or one of the three two-person outdoor tables.
We also had their brownies and those were De-Lish! Get one. They were really fudgy with a nice crust all the way around (because they were baked in cupcake tins or something so each brownie was its own whole piece).
We sampled their house chevre as well, which was very good.
Overall, pricing for the sandwiches was around $10 each, which isn't bad. For something with high quality cheese inside, I didn't find it expensive. Other items seemed comparable to similar cheese shops, which is to say a bit spendy, but that's the price of high quality cheese typically.
There was free public parking just beside it so parking was no issue.
We also purchased a seasoned feta so once I try that i can update on how some of their products are.
Looking around the shop, they had a good selection of cheese, but only two or three of them were from a local region (Wisconsin was the closest I think) versus many were from other countries. Personally, I like stumbling onto huge local selections more, but they seemed to care for their cheese stock.
Overall, I thought it was really good. I was happy to have gone, but I'm not sure yet if I would pick it for a lunch again right away unless I was specifically craving a sandwich. I found all elements of the experience really enjoyable from easy parking, friendly staff, and a yummy meal. I wanna go back though to sample more of the store element over the sandwiches.