Kami M.
Yelp
Steak 44 absolutely earns its place among the top five steakhouses in the Scottsdale/Phoenix area. It checks all the high-end boxes--beautiful atmosphere, an impressively attentive (and plentiful) staff, and an elevated dining experience from start to finish. If you've been to others in this tier, you'll notice that same polished feel here too.
The menu focuses on steak and seafood, with plenty of cut and quality options. We went with the classic 12 oz petite filet, and it was perfectly cooked, buttery, and tender. We also split a Caesar salad that came topped with a poached egg--super rich and full of flavor. For sides, we tried both the mashed potatoes and their thinly sliced baked potato. The mashed were the definite standout--creamy, smooth, and just indulgent enough.
Dessert was a win. We ordered the Key Lime Pie, which was well-balanced and not overly tart, but the surprise standout was the off-menu beignets. Light, fluffy, and served with cream and chocolate sauce--they were incredible. If they're available, don't skip them.
Only critique? The service, while top-notch in quality, can sometimes feel too present. There were a lot of interruptions--refilling waters, clearing plates, checking in constantly--which occasionally made it hard to carry on a full conversation without pausing. A little more space between check-ins would've made the experience feel more relaxed.
Still, this place is definitely a must-visit for a special night out. Amazing food, great ambiance, and overall one of the best steakhouse experiences in the valley.