Zipporah M.
Yelp
(3.8)
We've visited Stillwell's several times over the past two years while staying at the Holiday Inn (The Lodge), and overall the experience has been welcoming. The restaurant is clean, nicely decorated, and the staff has always been friendly.
On our most recent visit, the customer service truly stood out. Even though they were clearly short-staffed, the bartender--a gentleman with a ponytail and a quick-witted tongue--went above and beyond. Not only did he make an excellent drink, but he also supported the waitstaff without missing a beat. He definitely deserves a shout-out.
For food, I ordered Renee's Pasta with added shrimp. The seasoning was great, but there was a bit too much oil for my taste. The Texas toast on the side, however, was excellent. My husband and son ordered the chicken wings, and unfortunately this is where the experience fell short. Both sets of wings came out undercooked. They were sent back, but due to the short staffing there was some mix-up and the food never came back out. After a half-hour wait, they apologized and remade them, but even after receiving them (nearly 40 minutes later) and bringing them back to the room, the wings were still undercooked. My advice: maybe skip the wings until the kitchen figures out the issue.
On a positive note, breakfast at Stillwell's has always been consistently good. We definitely recommend the omelettes--especially with their delicious homemade salsa. The pancakes are large and fluffy, though a bit on the bland side. The biscuits and gravy are decent but not outstanding.
Overall, Stillwell's is a warm, clean, and inviting place with great staff. There are definite highlights, especially at breakfast, and some areas that could use improvement during dinner service. We hope to see those changes, because the potential and hospitality are definitely there.
* my pictures are not uploading right now for some reason. Hopefully, I will get back to share all of those.