Aws A.
Yelp
After a couple of visits where I indulged in their cheese slice, I was this close to giving Stromboli Pizza a solid 5-star rating. Let me tell you, their slice is no joke--it's huge. And the dough? Amazing. We're talking thin, crispy, perfectly done, with a solid undercarriage (a term only pizza nerds will appreciate). The cheese is spot on, and the sauce? Chef's kiss. It's slightly sweet but works beautifully. Honestly, it's the closest thing to New York-style pizza I've found in Florida.
Then came the test: I ordered a whole pie. Now, to be fair, I took it home, so it wasn't fresh out of the oven, but the dough didn't quite hit the same notes. It wasn't as thin, which threw me off a bit, though it was still good.
This had me scratching my head--are they inconsistent, or does the size of the pizza matter? Is the slice from an XL pie while the large is, well, less large? Clearly, these are the existential questions that keep me up at night. Regardless, I'll definitely be back. This place is too good to write off, and I'm rooting for my next visit to be a 5-star experience.
The service here is fantastic--friendly smiles all around and genuinely great vibes. It's a small spot in a plaza, so parking is a breeze. Bonus points for the Tesla Supercharger nearby--because nothing pairs better with pizza than topping off your EV.
For context: a slice will set you back around $5, but it's basically a quarter of a pie. A full large pie runs about $20. Pretty solid pricing for the quality and portion size.
Stromboli Pizza has earned a spot on my regular rotation, and I can't wait to see if they can slice their way to perfection next time!