Sugarwitch

Vert friendly and inclusive staff. Saw this cute place on Tiktok and felt the need to go whenever I visit St Louis next. The float I had there was so awesome! And the honeycomb cookies that I ended up eating upon getting home were super good also. Verified that the ice cream was indeed made gay💅

Sugarwitch is endlessly creative and such a charming space. I am picky about ice cream, and this is delicious. My favorite is anything strawberry—theirs is the best, creamiest strawberry I have ever tasted. I also had an espresso flavor with cookie bits recently I especially loved. I adore any of their ice cream sandwiches made with rice crispy treats—the Thai tea this summer was chef’s kiss. And I really appreciate the light hand on the syrups in the coffee and tea drinks when requested. When in doubt get the Ursula—that brownie! What a friendly, delicious, adorable ice cream shop!

This place is absolutely delicious and impressively creative! If I have to pick, my favorite is the Gideon. It’s a salted brownie with rich (but not overwhelming) chocolate, sandwiching a layer of peanut butter and the creamiest, high-quality vanilla ice cream. It’s a flavor combination that goes far beyond what you’d expect from a typical ice cream shop. On top of the incredible treats, the staff are genuinely friendly, and the shop makes a positive impact in the community. Definitely worth a visit if you’re looking for something memorable and unique! They sell out fast! So check their socials before your trip!

Every time I've had a Sugarwitch ice cream sandwich, it's been a delight! They often have booths at the many cycling events around the city, and it's the perfect post-ride treat! The folks working the booths have been kind and patient with all of my questions. The Elfaba is my current fave! Om nom nom nom 😁

It’s called Sugarwitch but both times I’ve been in, I’ve failed to be bewitched by their ice cream 😕 Both times I’ve left thinking the same thing: their ice cream sandwiches and tacos are creative and the sandwich/taco outside is tasty, but the ice cream itself falls way short. Last time I had Sweet Em’s the same day and noticed a big difference between the quality of what I had here vs there, and this time I had Clementine’s yesterday and I feel like Clementine’s vs what I had here are in completely different leagues. The choco taco was good, but $12 good? Not even close in my opinion. The cookie butter charm bar was definitely solid, and if you like the Butterfinger candy bar, this is a Butterfinger on steroids. cookie butter charm bar > Choco taco > neopolitan ice cream sandwich > key lime pie ice cream sandwich > black sesame cookie with passionfruit ganache

The icecream sandwiches were amazing g nothing g else like it. They were very thick and square made on homemade sandwich ingredients from cookies to gram crackers and chocolate. The inner sandwiches were so creative. I had goatcheese with lavender and raspberry dip sauce.

The staff was super friendly and helpful. Ice cream treats were delicious! We will definitely be back soon!

Love the concept and execution. As a foodie I really appreciate tasting new flavors and textures and Sugarwitch nails that perfectly with their Ice Cream Sandwiches. They are very creative in how they pair their unique ice cream flavors with a variety of equally creative sandwiches. Check out the menu and you will surely see what I mean. Bring a cooler with you when you go as you will surely want to bring a few “witches” home with you. Can’t wait to go back.