Sugarwitch

Ice cream shop · Patch

Sugarwitch

Ice cream shop · Patch

3

7726 Virginia Ave, St. Louis, MO 63111

Photos

Sugarwitch by null
Sugarwitch by Sugarwitch
Sugarwitch by Sugarwitch
Sugarwitch by null
Sugarwitch by null
Sugarwitch by null
Sugarwitch by null
Sugarwitch by null
Sugarwitch by null
Sugarwitch by null
Sugarwitch by null
Sugarwitch by null
Sugarwitch by null
Sugarwitch by null
Sugarwitch by null
Sugarwitch by null
Sugarwitch by null
Sugarwitch by null
Sugarwitch by null
Sugarwitch by null
Sugarwitch by null
Sugarwitch by null

Highlights

Nestled in a charming spot just outside downtown, Sugarwitch serves up creative ice cream sandwiches and tacos in a nostalgic setting, making every visit a must for foodies.  

Featured in Eater
Placeholder
Placeholder

7726 Virginia Ave, St. Louis, MO 63111 Get directions

sugarwitchic.com
@sugarwitchic

$ · Menu

Information

Static Map

7726 Virginia Ave, St. Louis, MO 63111 Get directions

+1 573 234 0042
sugarwitchic.com
@sugarwitchic
𝕏
@sugarwitchic

$ · Menu

Features

payment credit card
Tap to pay

Last updated

Jun 22, 2025

Powered By

You might also like

Terms of Use • Privacy Policy • Cookie Policy
 © 2025 Postcard Technologies, Inc.
@eater

"There is a mystical allure to Sugarwitch, the Carondelet neighborhood shop crafting ice cream sandwiches inspired by, and named after, “bad-ass witches from literature and lore.” Novelties like the Ursula — miso ice cream paired with milk chocolate chip blondies — and the Nerissa — a combination of spiced apple crumble ice cream and oatmeal pie crust — are clever and delicious sweet treats. The business is owned and operated by Martha Bass and her wife, Sophie Mendelson, who together hold degrees from Yale, Johns Hopkins, and Washington University in sustainable food systems, regional food economies, and environmental sustainability; they have built their business guided by a commitment to forming equitable food systems." - Holly Fann, Joel Crespo

The 37 Best Restaurants in St. Louis, Missouri
View Postcard for Sugarwitch
@eater

"Sugarwitch, set in a historic former bakery in South City, St. Louis, offers a variety of ice cream sandwiches named after famous witches. The shop is known for its commitment to supporting local charities and advocating for political causes, especially queer rights and bodily autonomy. Since its inception as a pop-up in 2021, Sugarwitch has been actively involved in community events and fundraising efforts, collaborating with local organizations like the Missouri Abortion Fund, the St. Louis Metro Trans Umbrella Group, and St. Louis Queer Support and Healing. The shop also hosts events like QueerMess, a celebration of LGBTQ artists and vendors. Co-owners Sophie Mendelson and Martha Bass emphasize creating a community they want to live in, using their business as a platform for activism and support for the local LGBTQ community." - Mary Andino

St. Louis’s Sugarwitch Ice Cream Shop Is a Political Organizing Hub - Eater
View Postcard for Sugarwitch
@eater

"There is a mystical allure to Sugarwitch, the Carondelet neighborhood shop crafting ice cream sandwiches inspired by, and named after, “bad-ass witches from literature and lore.” Novelties like the Ursula — miso ice cream paired with milk chocolate chip blondies — and the Nerissa — a combination of spiced apple crumble ice cream and oatmeal pie crust — are clever and delicious sweet treats. The business is owned and operated by Martha Bass and her wife, Sophie Mendelson, and the two hold degrees from Yale, Johns Hopkins, and Washington University in sustainable food systems, regional food economies, and environmental sustainability; they have built their business guided by a commitment to forming equitable food systems." - Holly Fann

The 32 Essential St. Louis Restaurants
View Postcard for Sugarwitch

Debbie Volstromer

Google
The icecream sandwiches were amazing g nothing g else like it. They were very thick and square made on homemade sandwich ingredients from cookies to gram crackers and chocolate. The inner sandwiches were so creative. I had goatcheese with lavender and raspberry dip sauce.

Christy Gilbert

Google
Cute small shop. Ice cream was delicious. I also tried the Canoli Latte. That was ok, not large or hot enough for my personal taste, but the flavor was nice. My daughter had an iced lavendar mocha, which was delicious. Staff is very friendly and has a great sense of humor. They do cator to GF and VEG as well.

Mark Engel

Google
Love the concept and execution. As a foodie I really appreciate tasting new flavors and textures and Sugarwitch nails that perfectly with their Ice Cream Sandwiches. They are very creative in how they pair their unique ice cream flavors with a variety of equally creative sandwiches. Check out the menu and you will surely see what I mean. Bring a cooler with you when you go as you will surely want to bring a few “witches” home with you. Can’t wait to go back.

Austin Patton

Google
It’s called Sugarwitch but both times I’ve been in, I’ve failed to be bewitched by their ice cream 😕 Both times I’ve left thinking the same thing: their ice cream sandwiches and tacos are creative and the sandwich/taco outside is tasty, but the ice cream itself falls way short. Last time I had Sweet Em’s the same day and noticed a big difference between the quality of what I had here vs there, and this time I had Clementine’s yesterday and I feel like Clementine’s vs what I had here are in completely different leagues. The choco taco was good, but $12 good? Not even close in my opinion. The cookie butter charm bar was definitely solid, and if you like the Butterfinger candy bar, this is a Butterfinger on steroids. cookie butter charm bar > Choco taco > neopolitan ice cream sandwich > key lime pie ice cream sandwich > black sesame cookie with passionfruit ganache

J. Lee

Google
Just had two of their sand "witches": Ursula (brownie sundae) and Becky (gooey butter cake and lemon). Absolutely fantastically delicious! I can tell by the taste that the brownie was fresh baked from scratch. Sweet, but not sickly or overpowering. I can't wait to have my third which is s'mores flavored! The higher cost is worth every penny. Perfect for an indulgent treat in more ways than one. I will also happily bring my vegan friends here--unlike a lot of sweet shops, they don't make vegan customers choose from a single option. As far as I can tell, every menu category has something for a vegan diet. Well done!

Alyson Robinson

Google
LOVE, LOVE, LOVE! ❤️ The made-from-scratch “witches” are DELICIOUS! Yes, they are a bit pricey, but soooooo worth it! My dad and I enjoyed the gooey butter witch and the “Becky” (I think that’s the name). Thanks to the owners who breathed new life into the old historic Carondelet Bakery… There are artifacts of days gone by that they kept which add to the ambiance and coziness of Sugarwitch. Staff super friendly! What a treat!

Marc Gregory

Google
We drove four hours just to have ice cream sandwiches! They are amazingly delicious. We also bought four of the custom truffles. These are some of the best! It is worth the trip to get a tasty treat here. With the seasonal recipes, there is always something new!

Michael Hall

Google
A must visit if you like ice-cream & ice-cream sandwiches! A short 10 minute drive from the main downtown city area. Parking is available outside the parlour. The staff are very friendly and helpful too! There is seating outside to relax and enjoy your sweet treats. Expect to spend around $8/ person.