Daniela T.
Google
My partner and I chose Sullivan’s to celebrate our anniversary after seeing all the great reviews. Unfortunately, we were quite disappointed with the experience. We aren’t very picky and are not usually ones to complain or leave bad reviews. In fact, I typically only go out of my way to write reviews for restaurants that exceed my expectations. However, this experience fell so far below the mark that I felt compelled to share.
To be fair, the evening started off great—our table was decorated with roses, which was very cute and romantic. We ordered the cheesesteak egg rolls to start, which tasted amazing, along with a Caesar salad that was also good. However, it took an hour and a half for our entrées to arrive, and when they did, they were far from stellar. We ordered a Wagyu strip cooked medium and a bone-in filet mignon cooked medium rare. The Wagyu strip was slightly burnt on the outside and, honestly, much chewier than expected. While some fat is to be expected with a Wagyu cut, the large portions of extremely chewy fat were disappointing, and the same was true for the filet mignon. Both steaks also arrived lukewarm rather than hot.
The sides were also lackluster for the price. We ordered the lobster mashed potatoes, sweet potato casserole, and Brussels sprouts. The mashed potatoes were quite bland, and the lobster contained pieces of shell. The sweet potato casserole was overly sweet, and while the Brussels sprouts had decent flavor, they were undercooked. All of the sides arrived rather cold as well.
Our waitress was pleasant but not very attentive. We were rarely checked on, and she seemed to be stretched far too thin. We were seated near the kitchen, which appeared to be having issues, with numerous servers standing around waiting for food. We ended the meal with a slice of cheesecake for dessert, which was also underwhelming. To their credit, they did add a nice decorative touch to the plate.
Overall, the experience was definitely not worth nearly $400 for a meal that we honestly felt we could have prepared at home for a fraction of the cost. When dining at a restaurant of this caliber, one expects a cohesive, elevated experience—from the service to each course—and we were left unimpressed. This was also the first restaurant of this tier we’ve visited for a special occasion where we did not receive a complimentary dessert. Not that it truly matters (what’s another $15 on such a large bill), but it felt notable given the nearly 90-minute wait for our entrées.
What was meant to be a luxurious experience to celebrate our years together ended up feeling like an almost three-hour waste of time and money. Based on the reviews, perhaps it was just an off night—but we expected better.