Kirs D.
Yelp
Writing this lengthy post with more practical info about the different cottages as hard to find that info online. By far the best located & reasonably priced lodging in Highlands area! My partner and I came on the NYC ferry - if you have a car that's best but Kranky's bikes saved us! We stayed in corner cabin F - from their website map it seemed north facing towards the beach (but no, no views of any water) and was on the bigger side with a big porch and more privacy. It did have all those things but if we go back we might choose G (or H if bringing a dog) as these seem to be same size but the porches face the courtyard -- which was a nicer view than just our partial streetview. But with F we could park our bikes on Center Ave if we had to quickly access our room which was nice. Cottages A-E looked a bit smaller but they do have outdoor showers if you go the beach, etc. Between C&D seemed to be a nice separate sitting area too. Cottages A-C also have porches that face the street. Cottages I-J porches only face the street.
Cottage F was tidy with everything you needed in a compact, pleasant presentation. The lady maintaining the rooms was very nice - blonde, her name escapes me- & also gave us some tips. We even bought treats for the sweet, resident cat (a neighbor's cat but loves to hang at Summerhouse) at the gas station market across the street. Easy walking to many delicious restaurants, Ice cream plc literally next door. Easy bike ride to Twin Lightowers - great views and interesting museum.
We were there a little after peak season so you need to doublecheck that places are open.
For the most part, compound is quiet and we never really heard other guests, Occasionally kids in the neighboring houses were really loud. In the main house (if you need to use the kitchen, laundry or a bathroom if you've already checked out) it can get a little more livelier - I think there are guestrooms on the second floor.
Overall, we loved our stay!