Sundae Best Boardwalk Cafe

I ordered a 2 scoop sugar cone, and was given a dish of ice cream with a cone stuck on top. I thought it was a mistake. Then all 5 of us in the group got cups with a cone on top. Ice cream was delicious, but they don't know how to make a cone...

Oh my I have not have had ice cream in awhile, but I had a craving for some. While on my break I got some home made ice cream from Sundae Best and I was so excited and happy that I found this place and tried them out...OMG the best in Avalon next to Avalon Pizzeria they are such a great pair for the taste buds and the hunger or just to chill.. My favorite place to enjoy my lunch or have a great snack while I'm delivering in Avalon. I highly recommend 💯💯♥️♥️♥️♥️

Honestly, I thought long about writing this review and it pains me to bring attention to the negative experience I had at an ice cream shop, of all places. I travel for ice cream and it is quite often, even out of season to many places on the east coast and beyond. It’s shameful that I had such a bad first visit here at Sundae Best in Avalon on the boardwalk. This was mainly due to the service I received at the window. Young girls tend to have a difficult time managing their attitudes with peers around a relaxed setting and this was no exception. It was evident there was flexibility in their given responsibilities. Maybe they forgot they were working on such a light traffic day. I was waiting for my SIL and kiddos when I stopped at the shop, I found a table around the corner from the window and rested after a long beach day. I let the girls working know that I planned to order when my family arrived back from the playground, that I wasn’t loitering. I saw there weren’t many food options besides maybe a hot dog and I wasn’t interested as a snack. While waiting, I was eager to try some new ice cream flavors, I was denied (which is acceptable policies to have). I do believe there is a friendly way to present that. However, when I continued to ask a few questions about the flavors to narrow my choices, I think of the slim 6 flavors to choose from at this location, I was met with disgust for my interest in knowing more about the unique ice creams (some being signature flavors). I typically order a cup of ice cream for immediate consumption and a pint or so to take home. This was important to me for making a decision on what I was going to take home. This trip I only chose to have one small portion. I may have also asked about dyes or added color in the ice flavors for sake of the kiddos allergies and went back to sit at the table while I continued to wait. While sitting by the open door at the back of the scoop shop (where you pick up ice cream after ordering around front), the girls could be heard very clearly complaining and mocking the questions/interactions we had prior. No judgement, what you do behind CLOSED doors is your business, but it can haunt you when you make poor decisions in the wrong setting(s). The lack of pleasant interactions during any of the above and hearing the immature, non-professional staff, added to the “exceptional customer service” listed on the website, I felt this was a fair way to express concerns. For those interested, Avalon Mud is I believe a vanilla based ice cream with caramel of some kind. I did enjoy the ice cream flavor (vanilla peanut butter?) that I purchased but it was nothing special compared to many local available shops nearby. I wish them success if they’ve found better service and will consider giving a second chance.

Exceptionally long wait times. Then completely missed our order.

Sundae Best is a family-owned business that resets the paradigm for experiencing homemade ice cream and water ice at the shore. First and foremost, they treat every single customer as if they were family – with the upmost respect, compassion, and kindness. They are extremely friendly, welcoming and always mindful – they even take the time to get to know their customers on a personal level, first name basis, and often remember their previous orders -- like who does that in this day age! It’s so beautiful to see a business go above and beyond the expectation of your normal service industry simply because they really care about making you happy and want nothing less than for you to have the most enjoyable of experiences while vacationing and relaxing at the shore. When you shop here, because of how welcoming and open they are, and the culture they have created, you and your families experience of tasting their incredible products is that much better. Now, on to the ice cream and water ice. Every single flavor/option is magically delicious, and you can’t help but want to eventually try everything they offer. It’s always made fresh, with love, and great attention to detail -- and they use the very best of ingredients. There is no better way to enjoy the shore than to make a stop here (or in my case, many stops!), see your family laugh and smile and their bellies full. I give Sundae Best my highest commendation because they really are the Best in the game – no question about it! Thanks for always making my experience and for the all the delicious products you offer! -- Dr. Stanford

The Affogato is an amazing espresso on top of home made ice cream. To die for!!

If I could give no stars I would. I've never been to an ice cream shop where after spending $20 on tiny cups of water ice then being told no to a sample. Even though it was extremely obvious they prefer catering to their own. Minorities beware there are other ice cream shops in Avalon.

Great spinoff of the main shop. Has less flavors. And often runs out early in the night!

First of all the ice cream here is arguably top 3 I ever had as far as the taste and the texture, I've had my fair share of ice cream and I swear I had a favorite but the only reason this ice cream won't be my favorite is because it's so far from my house and I'm not driving two hours to get some ice cream, but you feel I'm going with this. I can't think of a better dessert than ice cream on the beach, but when I learned quickly is that sand is not a topping for ice cream and I should wash my hands before partaking. The only issue I had with this place is the price for certain items that seemed less than what you're paying for compared to others like a scoop of ice cream was $5.50 but a milkshake was $7 but the scoop of ice cream seemed like it was just as much volume of ice cream as the milkshake. I'm not going to complain because the taste is ice cream is heavenly to say the least. I got the cookies and cream ice cream which I've had a million times at a million places, but none like this place!

maybe it is worthwhile to wait 20 minutes for an ice cream cone, but for one iced tea? I recently stopped by after using the public restroom to 'grab' an iced tea. first it was $4.00, but I had waited a few minutes to get to the window, so I was invested. next I was given a number and directed to wait on the side of the building and my order would come out of the window. I waited while the specialty coffees were crafted, the waffle was made from scratch, and various frozen treats were scooped and handed out before the worker went to an urn, poured iced tea into a cup and handed it to me. ridiculous. one and done.

Had to wait 20 mins for a sundae that never came. I ordered at 4:30 pm and it didn't come until 4:50. I'm not an expert on ice cream but I don't think it takes that long...I could be wrong!!

The Affogato is an amazing espresso on top of home made ice cream. To die for!! Their main store is on Dune and we have been eating there for years. This store on the beach is a great addition because of location and coffee. Kim is the owner and ensures top quality and kindness.

Delicious ice cream. I would say the best I've had. The boardwalk location doesn't have all the flavors of the other location but there wasn't any line here and kids can play at the arcade next door. I really like the setup of both locations. You order from the outside. It makes it actually easier than before and very covid friendly. The other location has non dairy and gluten free options. I thought the prices and portions were reasonable, much better than ice cream shops in Sausalito, Ca. Please open a shop there!

Went here for ice cream today. Oh my goodness was their ice cream delicious!!! I will definitely be back.

If you want "regular" ice cream, this is the place to go. Homemade, interesting flavors along with the standards. The best on the island. If you want soft serve, go to Avalon Freeze.