Super Nice Pizza

👍👍 Thumbs up! Came in expecting pizza, but the **brisket short rib burger** completely stole the show. So good I came back *twice in the same week*. Perfectly cooked, juicy, and served with a huge portion of fries. **Pro tip:** Ask for the burger off the *secret menu* — it takes it to another level. Don’t skip the **calamari + cherry pepper appetizer**. They’re good separately, but amazing when eaten together in one bite. The **espresso martini** was smooth and well-balanced. Owner is hands-on and checks in on tables, which is always a nice touch. They also have a **rewards program** and offer a **birthday discount** (make sure your server scans your QR code before paying). Great spot for date night, friends, or family dinner. Would definitely return.

Amazing addition to the neighborhood! This place feels cozy and neighborhoody. Our waiter was professional, friendly, and personable :) Service was super quick. Smoky potato pizza was GREAT, with the tomato and olive pizza coming in second. Caesar salad was divine (not drenched in dressing — important!) and came in a fun sharing portion. Would be great if they had pizza knives. Coming back soon!!

WOW! I dream of great eggplant parmigiana and found my answer with Super Nice Pizza’s eggplant parmigiana sandwich!!!! It is truly stuffed with eggplant smothered in the most delicious tomato sauce. The sandwich is huge!! As I was starting to leave, the aroma of baking chocolate drifted through the cafe. A woman sitting near me and I started talking about what smelled so wonderful. It was their chocolate cake baking and of course I now had to try! Wonderful surprise! Our server, Sofia, was the bonus to our visit. Sofia took great care of us with her friendly, warm, and inviting style. Also made a great latte! She made us want to come back! So glad I discovered Super Nice Pizza at the beginning of my NYC visit as now I can return again before I go home to Chicago!

Extra Super Nice Time every time we go! Love their focus on high quality ingredients and their professional & friendly staff. Their dinners have always been amazing so we tried their brunch. The fluffy pancakes with blueberry compote (light sweetness and a perfect hint of tart) was pure joy. My favorite was the breakfast pizza -beautifully creative and delicious with eggs,ultra thin potatoes & onion. I usually don’t eat the crust on pizzas but this was so perfectly crispy ( with the right amount of chewiness) that nothing was leftover. Coffee was good as well, so we’ll definitely add to our brunch roster.

Having had their doughnuts, we were curious to try their pizza. Prior to making a reservation, we looked for pictures of the food. After seeing the clam pizza and the towering slice of cake we were sold. Not only did the clam pizza and coconut cake exceed expectations, but we were also impressed with all the fine details, from the flatware, earthenware plates, to the beer glasses and everything in between. The feel of the restaurant with the exposed brick and half curtains in the windows, was like something you'd find in the Village. The service was quick and polite and they took time to answer questions about the beer and the dough used for the pizza. This is a wonderful addition to our neighborhood. We'll be back with more of our friends. Congratulations!!

Best pancakes in the UWS. Got the chorizo breakfast pizza and burger and also wonderful. Can’t wait to try the dinner menu. Staff was welcoming, food came quick, and everything was delicious. Highly recommend

I might be biased because the staff wear the same cute apron I have at home, but this is by far the best new-ish restaurant in the neighborhood -- we don't get to eat out much, but we've gone to SNP at least 4 times now. The pies are interesting and outstanding (clam and spanakopita highly recommended, if available), the drinks are well-made, and the vibe is super friendly and relaxed, while having a certain old NY bistro elegance. We just went for the new brunch service, which was fabulous -- I don't normally go out for brunch (so often a restaurant afterthought; I can make it myself), but the offerings at SNP are way beyond eggs benedict and very worth it. Shakshuka, chicken parm, and the breakfast potato/egg pizza all got raves. Get there pronto!

Super Nice Pizza has me in a chokehold. The chicken parm is unreal — cheesy, saucy perfection — and the Caesar salad is plentiful, shareable, and easily one of the best I’ve had globally thanks to that incredible dressing. The clam pizza? To die for. And if you somehow save room, the coconut cake is a must — freshly baked in-house, light yet decadent, with a salted caramel ribbon woven through the layers that takes it over the top. Come with an appetite because you’ll want to try everything. The staff is amazing, the owner is fantastic, and it’s truly the perfect addition to the neighborhood. Get there, you won’t be sorry.

New pizza spot by Danny @ Super Nice bakery. I was lucky enough to snag a friends&family spot prior to their official opening - lots of promise (still working out some kinks, I think) but the place is lively and the staff are SO nice. We got the arugula salad, original pizza, potato pizza, and chocolate cake. I loved the tomato sauce on the original pie and the chocolate cake - whose size recalls something out of Matilda - was amazing. Can't wait to return and sample more :)