Super Secret Ice Cream

Delicious ice cream. Small menu of local flavors with local ingredients and artisan prices ($5 for one small scoop.) In addition to unique flavors, they also had chocolate, strawberry and an awesome vanilla. I recommend a flight for economy and taste: they don’t have these flavors anywhere else. Try them here!

Had the wonderful privilege of stopping at Super Secret twice in two days on a recent trip! Both times the service and quality was just beyond compare. The staff is kind, knowledgeable, and accommodating. The ice cream is always amazing and features expertly executed twists on common and uncommon flavors. The Blueberry Basil with a hint of cinnamon and the Slopeside Mint Chip were the standouts for our group. Can’t wait to go back!

We saw that they were a semifinalist for a James Beard award and decided to drive over to have some ice cream. It is SO good! The honeycomb ice cream was great. My favorite was the Meyer lemon and blueberry. Very creamy excellent flavors! The waffle cone chips and waffle cone toffee were great. Definitely recommend stopping here.

Phenomenal ice cream, I'd even say this is the best ice cream I've ever had. I had the blueberry basil ice cream with their vanilla and my partner had the strawberry buttermilk with vanilla. Homemade waffle cones were excellent as well. My new favorite ice cream shop in New England! Thank you for the delicious treat.

Super Secret is still as delicious as always, very busy but don't let the long line scare you, it moves fast We've been back several times and recommended Super Secret to our friends and they all love the amazing flavors; last visit I got Chamomile and Hyssop anise.. so good!! Omg!! The best icecream ever!! I am an icecream connoisseur and this is one of the very best icecream ever and this is why: homemade flavors, not bought ingredients, their honeycomb is absolutely to die for ... Slopeside mint chip is so creamy and fresh, the blueberry sorbet was absolutely phenomenal! The flavors are delicious, the icecream is so creamy, the sorbet was full of flavor, absolutely unbelievable! Great service. They give excellent recommendations. Many gluten free and vegetarian options. Really fun & cool environment.

Amazing fresh ice cream. I tasted a few flavors and they were all super tasty. Also tried their waffles which were great. The service was nice and polite. I would definitely go back if I visit the area again. Highly recommend.

Amazing & adorable Ice cream shop with all the best vibes & hand made high quality scoops! Super adorbs decor! LOVE that they offer hand made ice cream including vegan! The vegan blueberry was yummy. My partner got their regular cream & said it was perfect! Super friendly staff & welcoming vibes!

This was absolutely the best ice cream we have ever had in our life. Me and my wife was camping in a cabin in Lisbon and hiking for 4 days. We are devoted followers of Jesus Christ so obviously hearing a town named “Bethlehem” we had to explore! Two amazing churches up the road, cute town (not impressed of the LGBTQ agenda being pushed) very sad to be honest but we will pray on that front. We don’t discriminate against anyone at all and we love all but having flags stating someone’s sexual orientation is very displeasing and sad. Back to the ice cream, blueberry basil was AMAZING!!! And I don’t even like basil lol. I had that and the maple and my wife had the mint chocolate chip and cherry almonds. The only thing with the cherry we can say needed more attention was she bit down on a seed and almost cracked her teeth :( the price was high but reflects the fresh natural ingredients. That we did not mind! LGBTQ agenda and the seed stops this from being a 5 start :(

The best ice cream ever! Long lines that went fast and courtesy staff. Nice outdoor seating area. Plenty of parking. Loved it!

After our second visit to Super Secret I am confident it it not a secret, and for good reason. They feature unique flavors, definitely a more gourmet ice cream experience than your typical roadside stand. In Bethlehem it is a perfect fit. Today I had a rhubarb ice cream that had big chunks of rhubarb compote in it - the taste and the texture of the ice cream was perfect and not too sweet - perfectly balanced to work with the tangy rhubarb. Fresh waffle cones and bowls (of course). My daughters got their honeycomb ice cream which I think is a house specialty. From what I can see visiting twice Super Secret is a big hit with the locals and the tourists. very cool, I look forward to returning on our next visit.

What a wonderful find! Amazing flavors!! Favorite was the Blueberry, enjoyed the creamy vanilla and the chocolate - like wow. Not sugary sweet, the cocoa (?) flavor was so delicious...ok we had a bowl tasting all the flavors! Clean, friendly folk with our pup able to be on the outside deck! Go and support..hope we get back to try other flavors!!

This place deserves more than 5 stars. They use local ingredients and offer an ice cream flight with up to 6 unique flavors. A must-stop!

Best ice cream I have ever had. Small batch with mostly local ingredients.Opened all year long.

Wow! Amazing flavors that you won't find elsewhere. Get the six scoop mini tasting and share it! Highly recommended.

Some of the best ice cream I've ever had and a true hidden gem on the near the border of Vermont/New Hampshire! The ice cream flavors were very unique and fitting for the Fall season. The server was super friendly and patient with us as we tried a bunch of flavors (wasn't an easy decision to make, they were all so good!). I ended up getting a cone with a scoop each of the Honeycomb and Apple Bourbon Crisp. Both flavors had just the right amount of sweetness and great texture from the added bits of honeycomb and apple jam. They don't skimp on the scoops either! The store itself is large, well-lit, and comfy. They're also dog-friendly and have treats, too! 5/5, will definitely be back in the future!

5 star ice cream! The Strawberry Fields was were its at for me. My partner got cookies and cream. They make their ice cream with natural ingredients, and have generous serving sizes. Family friendly. All styles of peoples welcomed. Def worth a visit.

Great little place in the center of the small town of Bethlehem. It seems like they have some rotating flavors, and everything we have tried there has been amazing. Apparently these guys were nominated aged for a James Beard award, which after trying their chocolate ice cream, I 100% understand. We've tried a ton of their flavors at this point, but honestly, if it's your first time, get the chocolate. You've never tried any chocolate ice cream like this, and you will be chasing that dragon the rest of your life. It's unique, delicious, and baffling. As some others have said, the portion sizes are on the small side. Here's the reason: it's not mass market, factory made ice cream. They use much better ingredients and it shows. I would much rather get half of the best than twice the meh. It's better if it's worth the calories, and it very much is here.

The ice cream was to die for and I don't say that lightly. This might be the best ice cream I've ever had. Seasonal and rotating menu of flavors, we sampled a few and end up with a couple of them. They were amazing and so rich. We bought pints to bring home! Our dog loved the pup cup! Scoopers were very friendly!! The store is so cute and aesthetic!! Truly such a gem!! Would 100% go out of my way to get some again!!

Love the ambiance!! Cute store, lots of seating. And the ice cream is so AMAZING!!! I had maple flavored sundae. And It was incredible!!! So robust in flavors!!! Their fudge is awesome too! Just all of it!! I tasted everyone else's too and I was overwhelmed with the flavors. So good!!

Amazing, unique ice cream and the people who serve it are delightful. So glad I live within walking distance!

Delicious flavor - peach crisp. Friends live honeycomb but it wasn't available. Friendly service, too.

omg it's is sooooooooo amazing beside that is locally woman owned and the try to get the product from local owned places it's just taste amazingly. we had the mango and honeycomb and strawberry went we went and the blueberry Yuzu lemonade was as perfect as it comes Sadly we live over a hr away or we be there everyday

If you read my reviews about Conway NH, you should be heading here to Bethlehem. First have dinner at Rek'Lis brewing. Then come here and have the best ice cream that you will have in your lifetime. Make it a perfect day. You deserve it. Just get in the car and go!

This is some of the best icecream I have ever had-- tied with Toscanini's in Boston. Super creative flavors, and their waffle cones are made in house, super fresh and to DIE for. I got the honeycomb flavor-- it's going to haunt me how delicious it was.

A stop to Super Secret came highly recommended by some in-the-know locals. Per their recommendation, I ordered my flavor of choice in a homemade waffle cone. I tried the cold-brew coffee. The crisp tang of freshly brewed coffee came through with sweet subtlebess. It was lovely on the palette, smooth, and creamy. The other flavors were both traditional and original twists on classics - their cookies and cream resplendent with rainbow sprinkles, for example. There was a lot of hip merch available for purchase in addition to ice cream accoutrements. For the spoiled pups in your life, they offer a healthy and refreshing pup pop, made with frozen puréed pumpkin, perhaps some frozen yogurt, and topped with a homemade biscuit. Lady Bug loved it and she was still working on it long after we all finished our cones. There is plenty of indoor and outdoor seating, cute details and lighting, and a sweet porch on which to perch with friends. Super secret won't be a secret for long with ice cream this delicious!

Decided to go for ice cream after a 10hr hike in the cold, windy, rain. They aren't lying with the super secret part, we weren't sure if it was the right shop since we didn't see a giant sign that shouts SUPER SECRET! Instead, it was written on a chalkboard. They got a decent list of ice cream and merchandise for sale. Would be nice if they sold other drinks as well besides water. As for ice cream, I went with Orange Blossom & Cardamom Biscuits. Loved the fragrance of orange! Oh and it's also a great place for kids to play inside or out, too! We saw wall of magnetic letters and drawings that kids can color in.

What a cute little place! I saw them on TikTok and was so excited to try it. Our kids loved the flight and they also gave samples!

THE best ice cream! We are so fortunate to have this ice cream shop local. Absolutely delicious! A must try!

The Ice cream is amazing top notch!! The employees are really nice and the inside has a nice touch!! I would recommend going here anyday.

Meyer lemon pistachio ice cream was the best I've ever had! Super friendly staff, great space. What more can you ask for?

Stopped in 20 minutes before they closed for a last minute fix and the service was excellent. Loved the farm to cone concept and the cozy front porch area, this might be some of the best ice cream in NH! I'm still thinking about that rhubarb almond crunch flavor weeks later. Worth going out of your way for, it was awesome!

You're not going to want to miss this little gem. All natural, all made with love. Ample parking and spacious. You'll be glad you checked this off your must-try list.

Wow! Great ice cream. Made in house fresh local ingredients and unique flavors. I had blueberry basil

I think it's the best ice cream I've ever had... Great quality. Unique flavors. Creamy. Great atmosphere.

Best I ever cream I have ever had. I loved the waffle cone unique flavor. They have very unique flavors. Worth the trip.

I have been wanting to come here for a long time. finally got here today and it was as awesome as I thought it would be! I'm a big fan!

Amazing Ice cream !!! I wish I lived closer so I could have it everyday ! I loved the Honecomb!

A little costly but unique and interesting flavors. Very busy too when I went but wait wasn't too long.

Stopped this afternoon for a treat and was delightful. The Vanilla Bean and Hot Fudge is scrumptious. Friendly staff and served quickly. Very busy and clean shop. Several spots to sit and enjoy your treat.

Ice cream is superb. Flavors are simple and clean. No gimmicks in terms of weird mix-ins, toppings, or colors. My go to benchmark is usually mint and this was unlike any I ever had. Normally it's mint chip. This was just mint. Very subtle. Wonderful texture. Was more of an off white color, like a good basic ice cream, rather than artificial green. Waffle cone was super fresh and likely made within a couple hours of my order. Strawberry and honeycomb flavors were similarly excellent. Also, everything was generously sized. Ample seating. Lots of posers out there in terms of ice cream shops but this is the real deal. Worth a detour.

Very tasty homemade ice cream. The waffle cone was very good. The ice cream was rich and creamy. The scoops were small but quality was great.

Super delicious ice cream! I had banana hazelnut and it was the best. Service good. Modern clean business with fun stickers and small gifts. My only regret is I live on the opposite coast and will have to be patient to return.

This is undoubtably some of the best ice cream I have ever had. You should keep this place super secret so you can have more for yourself. 10/10 would recommend

5 stars!!! Literally the best ice cream on the P L A N E T. Interesting and unique seasonal flavors, and the staff is so warm and friendly. They need to ship nationwide! Love love love

Good ice cream with fun flavors. Staff is friendly. Places to sit outside and spacious inside.

Its icecream. Its good. But too expensive in my opinion. There are other options in the area for the same quality at 10-25% cheaper.