Supreme Pizza NY

This is the worst Pizza I think I've ever had. And I've had a lot. A total disservice to NY pizza. Not cooked. The worst crust I've EVER had. Ingredients were suspect. I ordered a Supreme and they sent me something like a Supreme with fried chicken. Asked for peppers and they sent none. The absolute worst. I think I'm switching to Indian after this

The white slice is fresh and has good garlic. Comes out with a solid crust and the dough has an enjoyable puffiness. Great being open very late

My son told me about this spot so I decided to stop by and give it a try because I absolutely LOVE PIZZA. I was a bit apprehensive about the quality because of the low price. However, this pizza did not disappoint at all. It was absolutely delicious and I enjoyed my two slices. Although, it was my first visit I’m sure that it will not be my last. Keep up the great work!

My experience here is exactly what I expected. Cheap pizza - no frills. Exactly what I needed when I suddenly felt hungry. The person at the counter kindly heated up my pizza when requested. There was ample space for me to bring my bike (there are no doors, the shop is open) There was a standing counter for someone like me who didn’t want to park his bike. The pizza itself is the kind of lower grade pizza you get at 2 bros. I didnt expected any more than that. When you are hungry you don’t care what you are eating. They had a great selection of other pizzas (see video below)

A regular slice is $1.25 or $1.50, and if you want toppings? You’re looking at $2.50. That’s not outrageous at all, if the pizza was good. But it’s not. In fact, it’s the worst pizza I’ve ever had. The cheese doesn’t even seem real. You know that satisfying stretch you get with mozzarella? The creamy flavor? You won’t find that here. This stuff tastes like salted rubber. It’s overly salty without actually being flavorful, and the texture is weirdly firm and plasticky. And when you pair that with barely any sauce and a thick slab of dough that tastes like cardboard? You’re not eating pizza—you’re just eating disappointment in triangle form. And the toppings? Forget about it. The vegetables taste like they were soaked in a bucket of chemicals and then left under a heat lamp all day. There’s no freshness, no flavor, no pride in what’s being served. This is low-effort, high-profit food with no respect for the customer or the craft. But the worst part isn’t even the pizza. It’s the why. This place isn’t aiming to serve good food—it’s aiming to catch you at your lowest. It’s open late, and it clearly knows its main customers are drunk, high, broke, or all three. And I say that with sympathy for the people, not the business. Because when you’re out late with nothing else open, this becomes your only option. And it knows that. The environment reflects this too. It’s common to be approached outside by people begging for money—many of whom are struggling with addiction. The issue isn’t poverty. The issue is that this business is nestled in a struggling community and gives nothing of value back to it. It just takes. The bigger picture? This isn’t just about one bad slice. It’s a whole trend in this neighborhood: cheap, low-quality food being sold at the highest price people will tolerate. Produce shops get torn down, and in their place we get delis, fast food, and pizza shops selling garbage. They’re not feeding the community—they’re draining it. I'm not writing this in hopes that they’ll do better. I’m done hoping. This is a warning: don’t expect quality from this place. And if the price ever goes up again? Don’t be surprised if the pizza somehow gets even worse. Truth is, the best food-related spot in the area might just be Walgreens. And that should tell you everything.

Told me the pizza was ready to pick up. Went to the place and had to wait for 20min. Unbelievable

Absolutely love their pepperoni pizza! The flavor is spot on, the cheese-to-sauce ratio is perfect, and the crust is crispy but not too thin. It’s my new favorite pizza spot in town!

Amazing pizza, amazing price, amazing location. I tried 3 kind of the pizzas here and I loved them all, but the plain $1 was my favorite, it's full of cheesy-guilty pleasure.

Swung by this corner pizza joint around 1am after a Saturday night show at the Paramount. Keep your coat on because it's a carry out place only. No room inside to stand around and eat either. The prices are very cheap, we got the pizza & drink deal but had to point to the advertised sign in order to get the deal. The pizza is out in the open in a glass display case. You pick what slices you want and they heat it up for a minute in the oven. Safe to say this is not what you'd call "New York Pizza". The pieces of chicken on the bbq chicken slice were about 1/2 a centimeter wide. The pizza tasted soggy, old, and tasteless. None of us ended up finishing our slices. Only giving 3 stars for the worker, he was quick and extremely friendly. If you are desperate for a cheap no frills pizza place this place will do the job. But if you're looking for good New York pizza I'd suggest you look elsewhere.

Convenient corner store right by my best friend's apartment. I came around 11 am on a Thursday to get a quick slice for my pregnant sister and it did the job! There was one guy in front of me but it was quick. The pizzas are premade and on display in the counter. Whatever slices you want are taken and put in the oven briefly. Then depending on how many you get, you'll receive them on a paper plate or a pizza box. The cheese slices were $1.50 and the specialty pizzas were $2 each slice. I ended up getting 2 cheese, 1 pepperoni and pineapple, and 1 Buffalo chicken. Obviously not the most amazing pizza but it did the job. Also pretty big slices, thick kinda soggy crust. Not a ton of cheese on the cheese pizza. The other ones had a good amount of toppings. Wish they heated it up a little longer but that's okay. Service was fast and friendly. My friend frequents this place since it's so close but I probably wouldn't go again unless I was in need of a quick slice!

Another place that I've tried at my son's urging, Supreme Pizza. Owner states that he has been at this location for seven years. Slice of pizza is quite affordable, a little over $1.00. They offer many options of pizza. To be honest, I did not expect the pizza to be as good as it was because of its low price. Location is small in size but makes it up in big flavor. I enjoyed a regular slice and a pepperoni slice which both were good. The only thing they need to fix is the bottom crust because it was falling apart after two bites but not enough for me to not enjoy it. I'll stop by again for some more pizza.

I've scarfed down way too many of these .99 cent slices after a night at Duff's heavy metal bat around the corner. Super convenient, reliable, open until the wee hours, no frills joint to grab a decent enough slice of cheapo pizza. After getting in an 8 mile run tonight to hydrate with a cold one at Duff's a slice of pizza afterwards hit the spot.

I went there and got three pepperoni slices for $7.50. Slices weren't bad for a former 99¢ pizza spot. They were crispy and had a good amount of pepperoni on them, but they did look like some of the cheese melted off and went on other slices. Pay cash and you won't get charged the credit card fee. Not a bad spot if you are craving pizza, but there definitely are better spots.

Our guy never disappoints us. Crazy night at Duff's? Just came back from the airport at 2am? Coming home after a party in Bushwick? He's our lighthouse in the dark Williamsburg night. Cheap slices and now they even have pizza boxes! Wow.

No frills pizza place. They have a variety of pizza and options, but I went with the classic 99 cent pizza and couldn't have been happier. You always know what you are going to get a place like this.

Great idea to open a dollar pizza spot here. Quick and easy, lots of foot traffic. My bf and I tried a couple of slices - pepperoni and the white pizza. Both were good for being only $2 each. Service was fast.

This place is fire. Good for a dollar slice. Dough is really good, rest of the stuff is good.

Just a simple little shop with pizza and other small sides like mozzarella sticks and cinnamon sticks and other "italian" snacks. The "99 cents" name is kind of misleading and only pertains to slices of cheese pizza. Any other pizza with toppings is $2 per slice. Their selection is laid out in a display counter. We got pepperoni slices and some mozzarella sticks. Once we told him our order, he reheated the items in his oven. Obviously they weren't fresh but it's the best you can get at 3 am, right? Appreciate that this place is open so late and is some great late night food especially after drinking

amazing pizza. great. quick. convenient. can always rely on this spot after work :) ty

Favorite delivery & pickup pizza place - epitome of a perfect dollar slice! Consistently delicious.