Surf

Having a wonderful date night here! The staff is attentive but not pushy, the atmosphere is modern but classy, great view. Food was absolutely amazing- the salmon was to die for, fresh and well prepared. Drinks are great. What more can one ask for? Prices are definitely fair for the experience. Will definitely come back.

Amazing experience. The service and hospitality was outstanding. The drinks were great. The food presentation was excellent and my hangar steak was cooked perfectly and tasted delicious. The ambiance was relaxed but classy. The views of the harbor and Manhattan really added to the experience. A gem on SI. A must visit for a great dinner.

Very good experience. The place has big outdoor sitting, perfect on a hot day with cool breeze from the ocean . We got lobster roll but my wife didn't like much , cowboy steak that was okay ( aspected better) few appetizers and desserts,burata on a roasted bell pepper was amazing and they have my favorite beer so I couldn't be happier. Our server was very good also , we will definitely be back.

Excellent food. Perfect service. I actually forgot my credit card here and didn't notice for several days. Surf held it safe and sound. We will most certainly be back. Great addition to an up and coming neighborhood.

Valentine's dinner experience was excellent. Food was great. I had the cowboy steak which was perfectly cooked with the right amount of char. Wife ordered the ribs which were seasoned well and the meat easily fell off the bone. The brussel sprouts, corn bread and potatoes were good. The cream spinach was ok, it has a sweet taste to it. For drinks I had the berry mojito which was great (not sweet). For dessert had the apple crisp with raspberry and ice cream. It was ok. I will try the chocolate cake next time. Overall it is a nice place to eat, located on the water and is comparable to any Manhattan restaurant. Decor was nice and service was excellent. I had Allen as my server. We are already planning a return for brunch. Only drawback was the cowboy steak for one was $85. Pricey compared to nyc steak restaurants.

WOW! A short visit from Virginia, and I found the best restaurant in town. Gelica was the best! The Filet was amazing, and the Mac and Cheese blew me away. I wish I had the recipe for the steak sauce provided with my filet. Great beer selections, and the staff are so friendly and professional.

Dish came out really fast. Foods were delicious. That hanger steak was so juicy! Nice and comfortable atmosphere. Will come back another time.

every dish we got was delicious. the hunter chicken, salmon, hanger steak and the steak all cooked to perfection. Atmosphere is very nice and staff very kind and attentive.