Michael S.
Yelp
OVERALL: 6.8/10 (Yelp Converted Score: 3.4/5 == 3/5). My partner and I snagged an 8pm omakase sushi bar reservation on Wednesday, August 17th, 2022. We probably didn't need one - given that the restaurant only had two tables seated - a boisterous party of 5 and a quiet party of 2 (both at tables). We were the only ones at the sushi bar, and we were off to the side in the corner.
Verdict: Definitely the worst omakase of my life. What shocked me was this guy sitting front-center of the sushi bar (previous seating), claiming this place should have a michelin star... I've had michelin star sushi, bud; this ain't it. It's not even close. The highlight of the night? The automated door at the front of the restaurant; felt like something out of a futuristic movie / TV show.
1) VARIETY/SELECTION: 7/10. Overall we had 14 courses, if you include the appetizers. Given that this is a Chef's choice "omakase" ("trust me") menu, you're going to get the same things!
The only two highlights overall were the appetizers (the 2nd one was nice) and the lobster tail. The rest was too salty (according to my partner, but I didn't notice as much), or were overseasoned (especially with regards to wasabi usage) and over-sauced. It makes sense that they're trying to be creative and take a new spin on omakase, but this is slightly too adventurous.
My partner docked a point because the handroll counted as a course at the very end (it was ok, but she was already very close to full).
2) FRESHNESS: 6/10. The ikura almost made my partner throw up (due to how salty it was). Some of the fish pieces were definitely at least 1 day old (or approaching there) - which might make sense, considering our timing (8pm arrival). Besides the lobster tail, I don't really remember a lot of the other fish being fresh. The uni was definitely at least a day old, but given that it was coming from Santa Barbara, California, that makes sense.
Additionally, one theme I noticed throughout: The rice was too hot for nigiri sushi - it's supposed to be "body temperature" (Kashiba taught us this, it's basic omakase 101), but here, the heat of the rice usually overpowered the sushi itself (and in the case of one piece, made it completely fall apart due to being unstable). If you see heat coming off the sushi, you f**ked up.
The miso soup we had at the very end (after all the food was done) was actually pretty nice, though. So it wasn't all bad.
3) VALUE FOR MONEY: 5.5/10. My partner ordered green tea ($3 USD, unlimited refills), and I ordered the ever-elusive Asahi black ($8 USD). For both of our omakase and drinks, it came out to $369 USD. Not cheap (also more expensive than every other omakase I've had so far, except Kashiba - but that was a stratospherically better quality experience)!
After tax and tip, it came out to $442 USD - so $221/person after tax and tip. You decide if that's worth it for you!
4) SERVICE: 9.5/10. Service was actually pretty decent - we never came close to running out of water or green tea, and generally speaking each "course" came quickly. It probably helped that there weren't more than two other parties total in the restaurant, with two wait staff constantly rotating about (clearing plates and refilling glasses). I also appreciated the complete explanation of what we were eating (as we were being served the corresponding course), and with what garnishes it came with.
5) CONSISTENCY / FIRST IMPRESSION: 6.5/10.
As a mantra, "trust me" works well if there's a strong, consistently high-quality track record; given this places' more recent neutral reviews, maybe this was an off-day, or the main Chef's in a slump. Given my experience, though, I can't say I'd come back until there were significant improvements.
Also, compared directly to another omakase in Seattle (sushi kappo tamura) - this in the same ballpark, but Kappo Tamura wins by a hair.