Miriam W.
Yelp
Because Sweatman's is only open on Fridays and Saturdays, and I don't live in the area, I've literally been trying to plan a visit here for years. I did try on a Friday night a few years back, not knowing that they close for the Thanksgiving weekend. So today's lunch was long anticipated by both my husband and me. I have learned, however, to temper my barbecue expectations, as this seems to be one cuisine where people go overboard with the love when it's not all that deserved. Sweatman's is a case in point.
There was much to like here and a couple of things that had me shaking my head. I'll start with the positive. This is a self serve (mostly) buffet. Today's choices were baked beans, mac & cheese, butter beans, pork rinds, SC hash and white rice, pulled pork (they smoke the whole hog here, but separate the light from dark meat on the buffet), smoked chicken, smoked ribs, cole slaw, pickles and banana pudding. We both opted for the all you can eat, because we're realists, and I took a bit of almost everything. I skipped the chicken, as it didn't look appetizing. The woman behind the line serves the ribs to you, I guess to stop folks from taking too much. The pulled pork was good. I took a bit of both the inner (light) and outer (dark plus bark) meats, as the dark is moister and keeps the less fatty parts from drying out. I honestly don't know why they separate the meat this way...most whole hog pit masters mix them together. Anyway, both were good, especially with the NC style vinegar sauce that was at the table. They have 2 mustard sauces table side too, and I liked the darker one; the lighter one just tasted like yellow mustard with a few spices to me. The baked beans were terrific; they put bacon in them, and I'm now wondering why more places don't do this. The mac & cheese was also excellent. Had I just tried these 3 things, this might be a different review. But there's the matter of the ribs...
There was nothing good about these ribs. They were tough, dry and flavorless, with not even a hint of smoke. They tasted like they had been cooked days earlier. I just don't get it. The hash was decent, but the slaw had way too much mayo in it. On a positive note, the banana pudding was divine, so lunch ended in a very happy way. Service was also very friendly, and I like the old house and the surrounding countryside...it's a beautiful setting. So, if I ever get the chance, I'll return for more of that pulled pork and the delicious sides. I just can't give them 4 stars with ribs that bad.